# Boeing Special Attention Service Bulletin 747-53-2460: Revision 2

- Rights: © The Boeing Company. Filed by the FAA in regulations.gov docket FAA-2013-0366; AD 2014-24-05 incorporates this document by reference. Not covered by OpenAirDocs’ CC0 dedication.
- Document: [Boeing Special Attention Service Bulletin 747-53-2460](https://openairdocs.org/service-documents/boeing/sb-747-53-2460.md)
- Title as filed: Ref D - DAL-DAL-13-1299-02B_SB 747-53-2460 Rev 2 - Clarification
- Pages: 2
- PDF: https://openairdocs.org/files/sha256/7f/d0/7fd05c2be875633bfbae07fe167dc9f1dc9f34f9742a04b194ce0bc7fefa43ad
- Page: https://openairdocs.org/service-documents/boeing/sb-747-53-2460/file/7fd05c2be875

## Text

Each page's text from the PDF; open the PDF at a page with #page=N.

### Page 1

From: Boeing Customer Support
Subject: SB 747-53-2460 Rev 2 - Clarification
Date: Monday, June 24, 2013 2:51:23 PM
FROM: THE BOEING COMPANY
TO: Delta Air Lines (DAL)
[MESSAGE NUMBER:DAL-DAL-13-1299-02B]       Boeing Response
MESSAGE DATE:  24 Jun 2013 1251 US PACIFIC TIME / 24 Jun 2013 1951 GMT
The following message is distributed to the following people at Delta Air Lines:
Sandy Wiese
Field Service Base:  BFSATL
Service Category:  Service Bulletin      Model:  747    Series/Product:  SB - Airplane Service Bulletin       
ATA:  5300-00
SUBJECT: SB 747-53-2460 Rev 2 - Clarification
REFERENCES:
/A/ DAL-DAL-13-1299-01F
/B/ Boeing Service Bulletin 747-53-2460 Rev 2
DESCRIPTION:
Delta report they are working on an FAA NPRM   and have a few questions about the interpretation of a
Table in the Boeing Service Bulletin 747-53-2460 Rev 2.   Delta would appreciate clarification because
they will submit comments through the   NPRM process by June 24, that include Boeing's response.
Attached is a marked-up section of the service bulletin that relates to the following question in this
email.
1.      When DAL reviews Para (r)   of NPRM FAA-2013-0366, it is clear and understandable as to the
actions and any/all repetitive activities required. When DAL reviews all of the conditions in Table 1 of
the SBRev2 that apply to this group "previously inspected Group 4 a/c: corner reveal not replaced or
replaced with two piece reveal" =Circle note A and either Circle Note D or E   depending on Mat'l ID
outcome, we conclude that all of the applicable conditions of   Table 1 of the SB align with the proposed
AD requirements as defined in Para (r). However, when DAL reviews   Para (s) of the NPRM and then
reviews the conditions of Table 1 of the SBRev2, DAL questions if either all conditions of Table 1 should
be reviewed/evaluated?   DAL believes that only Circle Note C applies (since no material ID is required
and therefore determination of casting/ no casting is irrelevant) which leads DAL into Table 8 and the
applicable conditions which would align with para (s) AD requirements.
Question: How is an operator supposed to know to review/evaluate all remaining conditions Circle note
D/E/F of Table 1 for the first condition (circle note A)   but in the case of the third Condition (Circle Note
C), the operator is expected to ignore  the remaining conditions D/E/F.   DAL believes a more
clear/concise Table could be built to discern the different/unique conditions.
2.      Reference sheet 32, Table 8, in the last row   under the "Action" column, the highlighted text  
shows there is a reference to Table 9. There is not a Table 9 in 747-53-2460 Rev 2. I have also
checked Rev 0 and 1 and they do not contain Table 9 either.   Could you clarify what is the intended
reference for the inspection? (DAL believes "Table 9" notation should be   "Paragraph 3.B, PART 2").
RESPONSE AND/OR REQUIRED ACTION :

### Page 2

1.      When DAL reviews Para (r)   of NPRM FAA-2013-0366, it is clear and understandable as to the
actions and any/all repetitive activities required. When DAL reviews all of the conditions in Table 1 of
the SBRev2 that apply to this group "previously inspected Group 4 a/c: corner reveal not replaced or
replaced with two piece reveal" =Circle note A and either Circle Note D or E   depending on Mat'l ID
outcome, we conclude that all of the applicable conditions of   Table 1 of the SB align with the proposed
AD requirements as defined in Para (r). However, when DAL reviews   Para (s) of the NPRM and then
reviews the conditions of Table 1 of the SBRev2, DAL questions if either all conditions of Table 1 should
be reviewed/evaluated?   DAL believes that only Circle Note C applies (since no material ID is required
and therefore determination of casting/ no casting is irrelevant) which leads DAL into Table 8 and the
applicable conditions which would align with para (s) AD requirements.
Question: How is an operator supposed to know to review/evaluate all remaining conditions Circle note
D/E/F of Table 1 for the first condition (circle note A)   but in the case of the third Condition (Circle Note
C), the operator is expected to ignore  the remaining conditions D/E/F.   DAL believes a more
clear/concise Table could be built to discern the different/unique conditions.
2.      Reference sheet 32, Table 8, in the last row   under the "Action" column, the highlighted text  
shows there is a reference to Table 9. There is not a Table 9 in 747-53-2460 Rev 2. I have also
checked Rev 0 and 1 and they do not contain Table 9 either.   Could you clarify what is the intended
reference for the inspection? (DAL believes "Table 9" notation should be   "Paragraph 3.B, PART 2").
RESPONSE:
In a compliance table, if the action given with a condition includes an inspection, the possible conditions
discovered by that inspection are also included in that Compliance table (or possibly another identified
compliance table as is the case in Table 1 with the crack inspection). For Compliance Table 1, the
conditions labeled D,E,F in the attachment to this SR are conditions established by the material type  
inspection to determine if the corner reveal is a casting. Condition A is the only condition that includes
the material type inspection, so this is what links Conditions D, E, F to Condition A.   The conditions
labeled C, E and F in the attachment to this SR include an inspection for cracks and the possible
conditions associated with the crack inspection are given in Compliance Table 8. With Condition C it is
known that the new one-piece reveal is not a casting, so the material type inspection is not necessary.
Note that the conditions labeled C and F are equivalent conditions, but Condition F is established by the
material type inspection whereas Condition C is linked to a previous change.
Regardless of the above explanation, Boeing appreciates this input which suggests that there will be
benefit to clarifying the contents of the Compliance table(s). Boeing will take this input into
consideration with the next revision to the SB.       
In Table 8 on page 32, the reference to "Table 9" in the Action column should instead be to "Paragraph
3.B., PART 2."
If attachments are referred to, and are not present, please access them by logging into MyBoeingFleet
Service Requests application or contact your Boeing Field Service Representative.
https://myboeingfleet.boeing.com/servicerequests/index.html?entityId=1-
1549UXP&entityType=CommunicationMessage
Suppliers, please access attachments by logging into Boeing Partner Network Supplier Service Requests
application.
Michael Schmidt, Structures II - Service Bulletin Engineering - Everett
Ron Tropple - Manager

---
OpenAirDocs.org is an independent research project of [Contrail Labs](https://contraillabs.com/). It is not affiliated with the FAA or the NTSB. Source documents are U.S. government works in the public domain, except the copies of manufacturers’ service documents, which belong to their rights holders.
