Appendix 1
8) Airborne Weather Radar Another significant aspect of weather radar use is attenuation.
The use of airborne weather radar Attenuation is caused by heavy to detect convective cells should rainfall reducing the ability of De considered a matter of rou- the radar signal to penetrate, tine. Weather radar provides causing the radar to present an extremely useful information for incomplete picture of the weather the avoidance of thunderstorms in area. In the terminal area, comthe airport terminal area, but parison of ground returns to cannot directly detect windshear. weather echoes is a useful tech- Pilots have become adept at avoid- nique to identify when attenuation ing thunderstorms while enroute is occurring. Tilt the antenna and at altitude. However, rela- down and observe ground returns tively little emphasis has been around the radar echo. With very placed on their use near the heavy intervening rain, ground reterminal area. Most heavy rain turns behind the echo will not be De thunderstorms near the airport can detected with conventional peturns is referred to as a shadow This area lacking ground weather radar by a careful use of and may indicate a larger area of tilt control to scan above the precipitation than is shown on the intended flight altitude (15,000 indicator. Areas of shadowing to 20,000 feet). The subject of should be avoided.
the proper use of tilt control for this purpose should be studied in Turbulence Doppler radars starting available radar manuals and to become available to flight bulletins. crews provide an additional clue to the presence of microbursts.
Pilots should understand that If, in the departure/arrival segneavy precipitation, as seen on ment of the airport vicinity, turtheir radar and associated with bulence indications are present in onvective clouds indicates the mid-levels of convective cloud ossibility of microbursts; now- systems (e.g., 15,000 to 20,000 ever, the absence of strong re- feet) and low humidity conditions indicate a safe situation. turns must not be depended upon to Poten- spread), the situation is pilots exist (large temperature/dewpoint prime tially hazardous dry microburst for microburst formation.
conditions may only produce weak should be particularly cautious radar returns. when they observe this indication.
11/25/88
2.4.2 AVOID KNOWN WINDSHEAR The importance of avoiding severe windshear and microbursts cannot be over-emphasized. Microburst windshears have been measured which are beyond the capability of transport category airplanes and the most highly skilled pilots. Recall from Figure 11 that even windshears which were within the performance capability of the airplane have caused accidents. Avoidance may only involve delaying departure or approach for 10 to 20 minutes since this is the typical time required for microburst dissipation.
Even though significant emphasis on simulator training is recommended in ilot training curriculums, avoidance nust be the first line of defense.
Simulators are valuable for teaching windshear recognition and recovery.
However, pilots are cautioned not to develop the impression that real-world windshear encounters can be successfully negotiated simply because they AC 00-54 Appendix 1 have received simulator training. In an airplane, complicating factors
(l.e. turbulence, precipitation noise, instrument errors, etc.) may make shears much more difficult than in a simulator. In addition, simulator motion systems are limited in their capability to reproduce all the dynamics of an actual windshear encounter.
Remember, some windshears cannot be escaped using any known techniques.
Therefore, above all, AVOID, AVOID, AVOID:
Unfortunately, there are no universal quantitative windshear avoidance criterno-go thecision guidelineambiquere assured detection and warning system in operation which can measure windshear intensity along a specific the weather evaluation factors which factors which can be helpful in avoiding windshear is shown in Table 1 on the following Page 35
11/25/88 AC 00-54 Appendix 1 TABLE 1
MICROBURST WINDSHEAR PROBABILITY GUIDELINES
OBSERVATION PROBABILITY
OF WINDSHEAR PRESENCE OF CONVECTIVE WEATHER NEAR INTENDED FLIGHT PATH:
With localized strong winds (Tower reports or observed blowing dust, rings of dust,
tornado-like features, etc.) ....HIGH
With heavy precipitation (Observed or radar indications of contour, red or attenuation shadow).. HIGH With rainshower MEDIUM With lightning MEDIUM with virga MEDIUM With moderate or greater turbulence (reported or radar indications) MEDIUM with temperature/dew point spread between 30 and 50 degrees fahrenheit. MEDIUM ONBOARD WINDSHEAR DETECTION SYSTEM ALERT (Reported or observed). HIGH PIREP OF AIRSPEED LOSS OR GAIN:
15 knots or greater HIGH Less than 15 knots MEDIUM
LLWAS ALERT/WIND VELOCITY CHANGE 20 knots or greater HIGH Less than 20 knots MEDIUM
FORECAST OF CONVECTIVE WEATHER LON NOTE: These guidelines apply to operations in the airport vicinity (within patien de ere he d is oved the prostity ed ring should be increased. The hazard increases with proximity to the convective weather. Weather assessment should be made continuously.
CAUTION: CURRENTLY NO QUANTITATIVE MEANS EXISTS FOR DETERMINING THE PRESENCE OR INTENSITY OF MICROBURST WINDSHEAR. PILOTS ARE URGED TO EXERCISE CAUTION IN DETERMINING A COURSE OF ACTION.
11/25/88 AC 00-54 Appendix 1 Table 1, designed specifically for in off pates surel convective weather (thunderstorm, terms path, such enraves evaluation of roarious suerva- counters may present other significant evaluation various observa- weather related risks. Pilots are tional clues to aid in making appro- therefore urged to exercise cautior priate real time avoidance decisions. The observation weighting is categor- when determining as course of actione Use of Table should not replace ized according to the following scale: sound judgement in making avoidance decisions.
HIGH PROBABILITY:
Windshear clues should be considered Critical attention need be given to cumulative. The probability for each this observation. A decision to avoid single observation is given. However,
(e.g. divert or delay) is appropriate. if more than one windshear clue is observed, the total probability rating MEDIUM PROBABILITY: may be increased to reflect the total set of observations.
Consideration should be given to avoiding. Precautions are appropriate. Example:
LOW PROBABILITY: Nearing destination based clouds over VIRGA is seen descending from high Consideration should be given to this the airfield (MEDIUM PROBABILITY).
observation, but a decision to avoid Commencing approach, a PIREP is reis not generally indicated. ceived indicating that another flight just experienced a 10 knot airspeed The guidelines in Table 1 apply to airport (MEDIUM approach loss on final to the same operations in the airport vicinity PROBABILITY). There- (within 3 miles of takeoff or landing tore, it would be appropriate to raise along the intended flight path below the total avoidance decision weighting 1000 feet AGL). Although encountering to HIGH PROBABILITY (indicating a weather conditions described in Table decision to avoid is appropriate).
Appendix 1
2.4.3 CONSIDER PRECAUTIONS altitude available for recovery if required. Lastly, full thrust takeoffs Avoidance is the best precaution. may eliminate resetting thrust in a However, there are situations when recovery, thereby maximizing accelerawindshear clues do not clearly dictate tion capability and reducing crew delaying, but can be interpreted to workload.
mean that conditions are right for windshear activity. In these in- • Runway Selection stances, pilots should consider the next step of flight crew actions, the Use the longest suitable runway that use of precautions. avoids suspected areas of windshear.
The choice of a suitable runway in- A number of precautionary techniques volves consideration of exposure to have been developed which crews can obstacles after liftoff and crosswind take to lessen the effect of windshear and tailwind limitations.
should an unsuspected severe windshear sures maximum runway available to acbe encountered on takeoff or ap- celerate to rotation speed and may reproach. These precautions include sult in more ground clearance at the consideration of thrust setting, run- end of the runway and during the climb way selection, flap selection, air- profile. Should the decision be made speed, use of autopilot, autothrottle to reject the takeoff, more runway is and flight director. They were devel- available on which to stop the airoped by detailed analysis and piloted plane.
simulation of several microburst windshear encounters. In many cases, • Takeoff Flap Selection tradeoffs were involved and no "best" recommendation for all conditions The choice of takeoff flap setting is could be developed. dependent on the airplane type. The following flap settings should be con- Use of precautions along with even the sidered unless limited by obstacle best recovery piloting skills cannot clearance and/or climb gradient:
guarantee a successful escape from any microburst windshears. It is im- Airplane Takeoff ortant to realize that the recom- Type Flap Setting mended precautions each have a relatively small effect on the outcome of B727 15 an inadvertent windshear encounter. B737 5 to 15 Therefore, use of precautions should B747 20 not replace sound pilot judgment in B757 20 deciding whether or not it is safe to B767 20 proceed. Use of precautions should not bias a go/no-go decision in the go 10 or 20 direction. DC-9-20, -30,-40,-50 5 or 15 MD-80 5 to 15
2.4.3.1 TAKEOFF PRECAUTIONS DC-10 5 to 20
• Thrust Setting L-1011 10 to 22 Maximum rated takeoff thrust should be Studies of available takeoff flap setused for takeoff. This shortens the tings showed that the greater flap takeoff roll and reduces overrun ex- setting provided best performance for posure. Full thrust also provides the windshear encounters on the runway.
best rate of climb, thus increasing However, lesser flap settings showed Page 38
Appendix 1 the best performance for in-air wind- 1) Determine 'actual and Vz shear encounters. The takeoff flap speeds for airplane settings in the table offered somewhat gross weight and flap setting.
better performance over a wide range Set airspeed bugs to these of conditions; however, it must be values in the normal manner.
pointed out that the performance difference between flap settings is small. 2) Determine field length limit maximum weight and correspondo Increased airspeed ing Vp for selected runway.
Increased airspeed rotation 3) If field length limit VR is proves the ability of the airplane to greater windshear weight VR, after liftoff. Increased airspeed im- Vr lup to 20 knots in excess proves the flight path, reduces poten- actual weight VR) flight takeot be Airseted speeds, and reduces pilot work- should to the higher speeds.
Delaying rotation to a higher airspeed 4) Rotate to normal initial climb may appear to increase the risk of attitude at the increased attitude. VR overrunning available runway. How- and maintain this ever, Decause of the manner in which This technique produces increased rotation speed is calcu- higher initial climb speed lated, it is simply using the runway which slowly bleeds off to the as if the aircraft was loaded to the normal initial climb speed.
field length limit weight for that runway limit conditions, If the takeoff is at field WARNING: If windshear is encountered length the risk of beyond the actual overrunning the available runway is gross weight (bug) YR, do increased because there is no extra not attempt to accelerate to runway available. The overrun expo- the increased VR, but rosure is also increased if the wind- tate without hesitation. In shear reduces the airspeed below the no case should rotation be minimum airspeed required for liftoff delayed beyond 2,000 feet at the maximum available (body con- from the end of the usable tact) attitude. However, initiating runway surface. ( See Secrotation no later than 2000 feet from tion 2.4.5 Recovery Techthe end of the usable runway surface niques) reduces the probability of overrun and liftoff. maximizes the available energy after If increased than normal accelerating liftoff, airspeed was not used airspeed If increased Vp is to be used, the Reducing technique for scheduling and using in- pitch attitude creased rotation airspeed is:
windshear is encountered.
Appendix 1
• Flight Director rectors must be disregarded if a recovery is required not use speed-referenced flight and, time permitting, directors unless they equipped switched off by the Pilot with windshear recovery guidance. Not Flying (PNF).
WARNING: speed-referenced flight Some flight directors are equipped director which does not have with a selectable pitch attitude windshear recovery guidance mode. feature, the If normal procedures utilize may command a pitch attitude this selectable pitch change to follow target attitude mode may be effectively used airspeeds regardless of in a windshear encounter provided the flight path degradation. selected attitude is within the ac- This guidance may be in ceptable range. However, if an atticonflict with the proper tude other then the selected attitude procedures for windshear becomes necessary, the flight director recovery. Such flight di- should be disregarded, and time permitting, switched off by the PNF.
Takeoff Precautions
• Use maximum rated takeoff thrust
• Use longest suitable runway
• Consider using recommended flap setting
• Consider using increased rotation airspeed
• Do not use speed referenced flight director Page 40
Appendix 1
2.4.3.2 APPROACH PRECAUTIONS considered:
• Stabilized Approach Airplane Landing During some normal operations achieved stabi- Type Flap Setting lized prior to 500 feet AGL. environment, approaches However, in a B727 B737 30 30 potential windshear a B747 25 or 30 stabilized approach should be estab- B757 30 lished no later than 1,000 feet AGL to B767 30 improve windshear recognition capability. DC-9 * MD-80 28
• Thrust Management DC-70 35 Minimize thrust reductions. L-1011 33 than immediately compensating for an airspeed increase by reducing * Minimum flap setting authorized for a brief pause to evaluate speed trends particular model.
occurs and recovery is initiated, thr is prudent.
Studies of windshear encounters using additional airspeed and earlier avail- a11 available landing flap settings ability of thrust (due to engines ac- showed that the flap settings recomcelerating from a higher RPM) will be mended above provided the best overall advantageous. recovery performance for a wide range assure inappropriate thrust of windshears.
reductions do not occur.
sence of a tailwind shear, • Increased Airspeed cedure may result in a higher Increased airspeed on approach imto be accounted for on landing. proves climb performance capability and reduces the potential for flight
• Runway Selection at stick shaker during recovery from an inadvertent windshear encounter.
avoids the area of suspected windshear If available landing field length perand is compatible with mits, airspeed may be increased up to A longer runway a maximum of 20 knots. This increased provides the greatest margin for in- fouchdown must emar wathin the flamai speed should be maintained to creased ground roll due pated winds and speed Possible to unantici- resulting touchdown zone--do not allow the airplane to float down the runway.
(instrument) other aids to glide path monitoring As many variables are involved, it is (VASI, etc.) are desirable as not practical to provide exact guidthey can enhance windshear recognition ance on the effect of 20 knots extra providing timely, speed actual stopping distance.
path deviation information. Wind can be a major factor since stopping distance is affected by ground-
• Landing Flap Selection speed rather than airspeed. If increased airspeed is used and an in- The choice of landing flap setting is creasing performance shear is encoundependent on airplane туре. The tered, a go-around may be necessary following flap settings should be due insufficient landing field Page 41
Appendix 1 length for the higher approach speed. 25 percent and in some cases Furthermore, if a pilot can be reason- may exceed brake energy ably certain that wind changes (due to limits.
topography or unique local conditions) will not result in decreasing perform- • Flight Director and/or Autopilot ance, it may be inappropriate and Autothrottles increased approach speed.
During approach it is desirable to Other factors affecting stopping dis- utilize the flight director, autopilot tance such as availability and effec- and autothrottles to the maximum extiveness of thrust reversers, tire and tent practical. These systems may rebrake condition, runway surface conditions, etc., must also be taken into crew more time to monitor instruments consideration. On a dry runway with and weather conditions.
field length may accorresete 20 knots of autoflight systems, and in particuthe autothrottle, only extra speed benefits if properly monitored.
cases greater field length may be absence of proper monitoring, in doubt, these systems may mask onset of shear longest suitable runway which does not awareness of expose the airplane to greater hazard control inputs being made.
from possible shear.
Furthermore, not all autoflight sys- WARNING: Increased touchdown tems perform well in gusty or turbuincrease stopping distance. lent conditions. The autopilot and/or additional knots at the autothrottle should be discontouchdown can increase stop- nected when continued use appears ping distance by as much as counter-productive.
Approach Precautions
• Stabilize approach no later than 1000 ft AGL
• Minimize thrust reductions
• Use most suitable runway
• Consider using recommended flap setting
• Consider using increased approach speed
• Use autoflight systems during approach Page 42
11/25/88 AC 00-54 Appendix 1
2.4.4 FOLLOW ESTABLISHED STANDARD shears that proved to be most deadly OPERATING TECHNIQUES are those which caught crews by surprise.
In an effort to aid crews with the early recognition of a windshear en- Crews should be aware of normal verti- Care formulateres were series of recommendations under the general cal windshear induced deviations are more flight path indications so that On takeoff, rate, heading niques (SOT's). of Standard Operating These SOT's fall into Tech- would readily recognized. include attitude, on approach, climb this two general headings of crew awareness and airspeed buildup.
and crew coordination. airspeed, attitude, descent rate and throttle position provide valuable in- The need for emphasis on SOT's came formation. Awareness of these indicafrom recognition that in most takeoff tions assures that flight path degradation is recognized as soon as pospitch attitude was reduced below the sible.
attitude that would maintain level flight. This was done when the air- During takeoff and approach, be alert plane was already descending toward for airspeed fluctuations. Such flucthe ground tuations may be the first indication flight path awareness on the part of of windshear. Control column forces the crews involved. This lack of significantly different than those exwas also observed during pected during a normal takeoff or piloted simulator studies of windshear go-around may result if airspeed is encounters. Traditional training pro- below target or airspeed buildup is grams and routine flying may not have low during rotation and liftoff. Verreinforced proper flight path control tical flight path displays should be for altitude loss. used to crosscheck flight director commands.
focus when dealing with During takeoff while at relatively low ADHERENCE TO AIRSPEED MUST BE MODIFIED altitude (below 1000 feet), the SOT':
IN FAVOR OF MAINTAINING FLIGHT PATH BY equire awareness and use of norma CONTROLLING PITCH ATTITUDE. climbout pitch attitude and less em- The SOT's that follow emphasize flight Rhow the all engine initial climb all-engine initial climb path and pitch attitude for operations pitch attitude. Rotate at the normal near the ground. Following SOT's re- rotation rate to this attitude for all sults in better crew performance dur- takeoffs. Minimize pitch attitude reing day-to-day operations, as well as ductions in response to low airspeed case an ordination ding viest until terrain and obstruction clearance is assured.
for timely windshear recognition, par- On approach, avoid large thrust reducticularly at night or in marginal tions or trim changes in response to weather conditions. airspeed increases as an airspeed decrease follow.
o Crew Awareness monitor vertical flight path instruments, such as vertical speed, altime- It is important for crews to remain ters and glideslope displacement.
alert for any change in conditions, addition, comparison of groundspeed remembering that windshear can be and airspeed indications can provide quick to form and to dissipate. The additional information Page 43
Appendix 1 windshear recognition. When potential asses judgment to determine the sarent assessing the situation for windshear exists, achieve a stabilized approach no later than 1,000 course of action.
feet AGL.
• Crew Coordination High workload and distractions in the approach phase, particularly in mar- The PF should focus attention on flyginal weather, attention ing the airplane. In a windshear eninstruments provide counter, appropriate action should be early recognition of flight path de- taken in response to callouts.
terioration. Additionally, application of thrust on approach may The PNF should focus attention on airmask a decreasing airspeed trend. speed, vertical speed, altitude, pitch attitude,,& any sionificant deviations glidepath deviation and Crews should be prepared to execute thrust.
the recommended recovery procedure im- from normal indications are detected, mediately if deviations from target the PNF should immediately call out conditions in excess of the following the deviation. Callouts in the cockoccur: pit should be standardized and easy to understand to ensure timely recogni- Takeoff/Approach tion.
1) +15 knots indicated airspeed EXAMPLE:
2) +500 FPM vertical speed low. " decreasing--glideslope "Vertical speed 1200 down--airspeed one dot
3) +5° pitch attitude Approach STANDARD OPERATING TECHNIQUES SUMMARY
1) +l dot glideslope displacement • Takeoff
2) Unusual throttle position for a significant period of time. o Know normal attitudes, climb rates, airspeed build-uP initial
• Know/use ail-engine These values should be considered as climb attitude.
guidelines only. • Make continuous rotation at certain in- normal rate.
significant • Crosscheck flight director cominitiate recover me ore necessary the recovery before any of o Minimize pitch attitude reduc- mands.
are exceeded. tions.
situations may exist where brief ex- • Monitor vertical flight path particularly in airspeed, instruments, call out deviafrom known or anticipated tions (PNF).
local wind effects may not be an indi- o Know recovery decision guidesignificant lines.
pilot flying (PF) is responsible for Page 44
Appendix 1 o Approach initial target pitch attitude for both takeoff and approach. Additional o Know normal attitudes, descent vantages of 15 initial target pitch rates airspeeds, throttle attitude are that it is easily reosition. called in emergency situations and it
• Crosscheck flight director com- is prominently displayed on attitude mands. director indicators.
Avoid large thrust reductions.
Monitor vertical flight path Note: 1) L-1011 target attitudes:
instruments, call out devia- Takeoff = 17.5° tions (PNF). Approach = 15° o Know recovery decision guidelines. 2) Operators lated target pitch attitudes such as all-engine attitude
2.4.5 WINDSHEAR RECOVERY TECHNIQUE takeoffs go-arounds may use these at- The primary recovery technique objec- titudes in place of the rective is to keep the airplane flying as ommended initial target relong as possible in hope of exiting covery attitude.
the shear. A wide variety of techniques were considered to establish While other more complex techniques the one best meeting this objective. may make slightly better use of air- The best results were achieved by plane performance, these techniques do itching toward an initial target at not meet simplicity and ease of recall titude while using necessary thrust. requirements. Evaluations showed that Several factors were considered in the recommended technique provides a developing this technique. simple, effective means of recovering from a windshear encounter.
Studies show windshear encounters occur infrequently and that only a few A detailed discussion of the recomsuccessful seconds are recovery situations available to initiate a Additionally, Recovery both recovery during takeoff technique during high stress pilot and during approach is disinstrument scan typically becomes very cussed together in the following seclimited--in extreme cases, to only one tion since the technique for both sitinstrument. Lastly, recovery skills uations is identical. The recovery will not be exercised on a day-to-day technique for encounters during takebasis. These factors dictated that off on runway is presented later.
the recovery technique must not only be effective, but simple, easily re- 2.4.5.1/3 ENCOUNTER DURING TAKEOFF - called, and have general applicability. AFTER LIFTOFF and Extensive analysis and pilot evalua- ENCOUNTER ON APPROACH conducted. Al though range of recovery attitudes (including Windshear recognition is crucial to and the range of all-engine ini- making a timely recovery decision.
tial climb attitudes) provides good The recommended recovery procedure recovery capability for a wide variety should be initiated any time the of windshears, 15 was chosen as the flight path is threatened below 1000 Page 45