Par 2-5 Page 7 standardization and the quality of upset recovery training, but it will also reduce the risk of negative training that could easily occur with an untrained instructor.
(2) Instructors should learn to brief and debrief pilots on these limitations.
(3) Negative transfer of training has previously occurred as a result of the instructor’s lack of knowledge of the limitations of the FSTD. FSTD instructors must be aware that valid training may be limited to the parameters to which the FSTD has been programmed and evaluated to conduct. Operating outside of these parameters may result in the FSTD responding differently than the airplane would to a pilot’s control inputs. Motion cueing information may not always accurately simulate the associated forces and rates that could be felt in an airplane.
(4) Instructors must have a clear understanding of the FSTD limitations that may influence UPRT, including:
• The FSTD’s acceptable training envelope;
• G loading awareness/accelerated stall—factors absent from the FSTD’s motion cueing that could be experienced in flight and the effect on airplane behavior and recovery considerations; and
• Significant deviations from the FSTD’s validation envelope could result in an inaccurate FSTD response. While minor excursions from the FSTD’s validation envelope may not necessarily invalidate the training, instructors should be aware that the airplane’s response in an actual upset condition may deviate from what is experienced in the FSTD. Particular upset scenarios should be selected and evaluated before training takes place to reduce the likelihood of significant excursions outside of the FSTD’s validation envelope.
(5) Refer to Appendix 3-D, Flight Simulator Information, of the Airplane Upset Recovery Training Aid (AURTA) Revision 2 for more information.
b. Instructor Operating Station (IOS) Use (§ 121.414). Instructors must complete training on the proper operation of the controls, systems, and environmental and fault panels for each specific FSTD used for UPRT. This includes the specific IOS indications and controls that will be used to provide training and feedback during UPRT events.
c. Minimum FSTD Equipment (§ 121.414). Instructors must complete training on the minimum FSTD equipment required by parts 60 and 121 for each UPRT event. Instructors must understand that UPRT must only be conducted if the minimum FSTD equipment is functional;
otherwise, negative transfer of training could occur.
d. Review of Loss of Control In-Flight (LOC-I) Events, Incidents, and Accidents.
Training and review of LOC-I events, incidents, and accidents increases knowledge and skill development to recognize and to recover from an airplane upset. A review of LOC-I events will provide pilots with a focus and a context for the consequences of allowing the airplane to develop into an upset.
Par 2-5 Page 8
e. Energy Management.
(1) It is important that instructors not only understand energy management but also be able to apply it as a means of upset prevention. UPRT instructors should be trained on specific techniques and maneuvers to demonstrate and train energy management principles effectively.
(2) An improper understanding of airplane energy state has contributed to a pilot’s poor understanding of airplane control. This poor understanding influenced the previous improper training of stall recovery. It is therefore important that instructors understand how energy management is a factor in all phases of flight, as well as in UPRT.
f. Spatial Disorientation. Instructors should be trained in a variety of causes of disorientation, prevention strategies, recognition cues, and recovery from disorientation, because spatial disorientation training may not be effectively represented in an FSTD.
g. Distraction. UPRT instructors should have an awareness of how distractions can lead to an airplane upset and how to effectively use distractions in training. Appropriate use of distractions can also assist the instructor in creating a situation to induce startle. UPRT instructors should learn about different distractions that can affect a flightcrew, such as:
• Communication,
• Heads-down work,
• Responding to abnormal/unexpected events,
• Searching for traffic,
• Flight deck ergonomics,
• Flight deck noise level,
• English language proficiency (from both the pilots and air traffic control (ATC)),
• Airport infrastructure, and
• Flightcrew fatigue.
h. Recognition and Recovery Strategies. Instructors should be able to convey how to recognize upset conditions and to apply appropriate recovery strategies. Training should include specific examples, in both academic discussion and practical demonstration.
i. Recognition and Correction of Pilot Errors. Errors may occur in flight operations if the errors are not identified and corrected during training. Instructors should be aware of the consequences of failing to recognize and correct pilot errors. Instructors should be familiar with common pilot errors, be able to identify the root cause, and provide training to avoid errors and incorrect inputs that can create undesired aircraft states (such as over controlling for Traffic Alert and Collision Avoidance System (TCAS) Resolution Advisories).
j. Type-Specific Characteristics. Original Equipment Manufacturers (OEM) have recognized that different airplanes have unique characteristics that may both assist in, or deter from, the recognition and recovery of an airplane upset. UPRT instructors should know specific unique characteristics regarding airplane handling and recognition, such as how the airplane responds while approaching stall buffet or the effects of envelope protection.
Par 2-5 Page 9
k. OEM-Specific Recommendations. Evidence indicates that training programs using operating procedures from one airplane type may have a detrimental effect if carried over to a different airplane type. This can lead to an upset. Training should use airplane-specific OEM recommendations and air carrier procedures developed from OEM recommendations for prevention and recovery from an upset.
l. Operating Environment. Current training does not always take into consideration the different handling characteristics in all areas of the operating envelope. Instructors should be trained in how to demonstrate the effects of the operating environment, as well as how these will affect the airplane handling characteristics and potentially lead to an airplane upset. This should include how changes in the environmental conditions will affect the airplane. An example is showing how thrust available varies significantly with altitude by timing how long it takes to change speed by 25 knots during level flight at low and high altitude.
m. Startle or Surprise. Because upsets that occur in normal flight operations are unplanned and inadvertent, pilots may be startled or surprised, adversely impacting recognition or recovery. Instructors need to plan scenarios to balance potential for startle or surprise while applying sound judgment with respect to realism and fidelity, and respecting the capabilities and limitations of the FSTD. It is crucial for the instructor to adopt and foster a spirit of collaborative learning when inducing startle or surprise so as not to inappropriately attempt to trap a pilot or destroy confidence in the training session.
n. Benefits of Demonstration in an FSTD. Some elements of UPRT may be more assessable, trainable, and effective when FSTD instructors demonstrate them from a pilot seat.
o. Assessing Pilot Performance to Completion Standards. Instructors should be able to assess when an appropriate level of proficiency is achieved. Instructors should be trained on how to judge pilot performance on the UPRT events and determine whether the required learning objectives have been met.
2-6. INSTRUCTOR STANDARDIZATION.
a. Initial Standardization Validation. Following completion of UPRT instructor training, and before providing unsupervised instruction, instructors should complete an Instructor Standardization validation to ensure readiness to provide accurate UPRT, to include evaluation of:
• UPRT knowledge and skills applicable to the UPRT for which they are being standardized.
• Ability to teach, brief, assess, and debrief the elements included in the UPRT for which they are being standardized.
• FSTD instructor ability to effectively operate the device and all of its available debriefing capabilities.
• Effective recognition of pilot errors, identification of root cause, and adjustments to training to correct errors and achieve the required level of proficiency.
• Assess the achievement of an appropriate level of proficiency in accordance with the completion criteria.
Par 2-6 Page 10
b. Continuing Standardization. Each air carrier should have a control system in place to ensure its instructors continuously deliver standardized UPRT. Instructors who do not follow the curriculum may provide pilots with negative training.
Par 3-1 Page 11 CHAPTER 3. TRAINING METHODOLOGY 3-
1. GENERAL. The training methodology for UPRT should follow the building block approach of first introducing essential concepts and academic understanding before progressing to the practical application of those skills in a flight simulation training device (FSTD).
Similarly, familiarity with airplane characteristics and development of basic recovery skills through maneuver-based training should precede their application in scenario-based training.
This progressive approach will lead to a more complete appreciation of how to recognize a developing flightpath divergence, respond appropriately in situations of surprise or startle, and recover effectively when required. Air carriers should develop training curriculums that provide pilots with the knowledge and skills to prevent, recognize, and recover from unexpected flightpath divergences and upset events. These training curriculums should contain the elements and events described in Appendix 1.
3-2. COMPREHENSIVE AIR CARRIER UPRT PROGRAM.
a.
General. The FAA strongly recommends incorporation of the Airplane Upset Recovery Training Aid (AURTA) Revision 2 into air carrier UPRT programs. The AURTA Revision 2 has extensive discussion and considerations for both the academic and flight training portion of an air carrier’s training program. The AURTA Revision 2 is available online at http://www.faa.gov/ other_visit/aviation_industry/airline_operators/training/media/AP_UpsetRecovery_Book.pdf.
b. Flight Standardization Board (FSB) Reports. When developing UPRT programs, air carriers should consult the FSB report, if available, for the specific airplane type. The Training Areas of Special Emphasis, and any other recommendations pertaining to in-flight aircraft handling, should be reviewed.
c. Academic Knowledge. Academic instruction establishes the foundation from which situational awareness, insight, knowledge, and skills are developed, and therefore must be accomplished prior to training the associated flight events in an FSTD. To ensure sufficient retention, FSTD training should occur within a reasonable time after academic training.
Academic knowledge should proceed from the general to the specific.
d. FSTD Training. Section 121.423 requires extended envelope training, which consists of the following maneuvers to be conducted in a Level C or higher full flight simulator (FFS):
manually controlled slow flight, manually controlled loss of reliable airspeed, manually controlled instrument departure and arrival, and upset recovery maneuvers. Other flight training that is part of UPRT, but not required by regulation to be conducted in an FFS may be conducted in another type of FSTD; however, the FSTD should have the level of fidelity required to meet the learning objective. Training providers are encouraged to use the highest level FFS available when developing their UPRT curriculums. The primary emphasis is to provide the pilot with the most realistic environment possible during UPRT. Motion in an FFS should be used when those cues influence recognition or recovery.
Par 3-2 Page 12
(1) FSTD flight training should follow a logical progression where pilots are introduced to the airplane’s capabilities within the operating limits prior to training at the edge of the normal flight envelope, or beyond. While exceeding the normal flight envelope in an FFS is possible, all UPRT maneuvers contained in this AC can typically be conducted inside the FFS’s intended training envelope where the performance and handling qualities of the FFS are at their highest accuracy. Training that exceeds the airplane envelope or the aerodynamic modeling envelope could increase the risk of negative transfer of training. Significant sustained accelerations and rates are not possible in an FFS, and instructors should be able to explain to pilots how the actual aircraft behavior may differ. See Appendix 3 for detailed FSTD considerations.
(2) FSTD training should include both maneuver-based and scenario-based training. Air carriers are encouraged to consult with the airplane manufacturer during the development of the FSTD training.
(a) Maneuver-Based Training. This training focuses on task mastery.
Maneuver-based training should include prevention and recovery training with an emphasis on the development of required motor skills to satisfactorily accomplish upset recovery. Limited emphasis should be placed on decisionmaking skills during maneuver-based training.
(b) Scenario-Based Training (SBT). The goal of SBT is to develop perception and decisionmaking skills relating to upset prevention, recognition, and recovery, while providing the pilot with an opportunity to use the skills learned in maneuver-based training in a realistic scenario. SBT would normally be used after maneuver-based training, during the later stages of an initial, transition, or upgrade training curriculum, and during recurrent training.
1. Realistic Scenarios. UPRT scenarios should be realistic events that could be encountered in operational conditions. When possible, scenarios should include accident, incident, Aviation Safety Action Program (ASAP), Flight Operational Quality Assurance (FOQA), and/or Aviation Safety Reporting System (ASRS) data to convey how threat situations may develop and how they should be managed. Sample SBT lesson plans are provided in Appendix 2.
2. Briefing. Pilots should not normally be briefed that they are receiving SBT.
The concept allows pilots to recognize and manage upset threats as they develop during normal operations.
3-3. KEY UPRT CONSIDERATIONS.
a. Awareness and Prevention. Training with an emphasis on awareness and prevention provides pilots with the skills to recognize conditions that increase the likelihood of an upset event if not effectively managed. Training must include the air carrier’s standard operating procedures (SOP) and Crew Resource Management (CRM) techniques for the most effective prevention and threat mitigation strategies. Desired goals for awareness and prevention training include the following:
(1) Recognition of operational and environmental conditions that increase the likelihood of an upset event occurring;
Par 3-3 Page 13
(2) Aeronautical decisionmaking skills to prevent upsets (e.g., effective analysis, awareness, resource management, mitigation strategies, and breaking the error chain through airmanship and sound judgment);
(3) Early detection of flightpath divergences;
(4) Timely and appropriate intervention;
(5) The effects of autoflight including mode confusion, flight envelope protection in normal and degraded modes, and unexpected disconnects of the autopilot or autothrottle/autothrust;
(6) Recognition of when the flight condition has transitioned from the prevention phase into the recovery phase; and
(7) Effective verbal and nonverbal communication regarding the airplane state.
b. Manual Flight Operations Knowledge, Skills, and Utilization. Modern aircraft are commonly operated using autoflight systems (e.g., autopilot or autothrottle/autothrust) during most of a flight. Autoflight systems have improved safety, reduced workload, and enabled more precise operations; however, continuous use of autoflight systems could lead to degradation of the pilot’s manual handling skills and ability to recover the aircraft from an upset.
NOTE: Air carriers are encouraged to take an integrated approach by incorporating manual flight operations into both line operations and training (initial, transition, upgrade, requalification, and recurrent).
(1) Training. Several maneuvers are included in Appendix 1 specifically to develop and maintain a pilot’s manual flight operations knowledge and skills.
(2) Operations. Air carriers should develop policies that encourage manual flight operations when appropriate. Operational policies should be developed or reviewed to ensure there are appropriate opportunities for pilots to exercise manual flying skills, such as in non-Reduced Vertical Separation Minimum (RVSM) airspace and during low workload conditions. In addition, policies should be developed or reviewed to ensure that pilots understand when to use the automated systems, such as during high workload conditions or for airspace procedures that require precise operations. Augmented crew operations may also limit the ability of some pilots to obtain practice in manual flight operations. Airline operational policies should ensure that all pilots have the appropriate opportunities to exercise manual flight knowledge and skills in flight operations.
(3) Use of Autopilot and/or Autothrottle/Autothrust for Upset Recovery. Leaving the autopilot or autothrottle/autothrust connected may result in inadvertent changes or adjustments that may not be easily recognized or appropriate, especially during high workload situations.
c. Availability of Visual References. The CAST study of 18 accidents and incidents resulting from pilot loss of airplane state awareness determined that 17 accidents and incidents
Par 3-3 Page 14 occurred when pilots did not have visual references available (i.e., instrument meteorological conditions (IMC) or night). In the past, unusual attitude training was commonly conducted in visual meteorological conditions, giving the pilot considerable advantage in determining the appropriate recovery. To develop a pilot’s ability to recover from an upset, FSTD maneuvers training should be done in both visual and instrument conditions, as well as in day and night.
This allows pilots to practice recognition and recovery under all conditions in order to experience important physiological factors.
d. Pilot Monitoring. Evidence shows that in many loss of control in-flight (LOC-I) incidents and accidents the pilot(s) monitoring (PM) may have been more aware of the airplane state than the pilot flying (PF). Training should emphasize crew interaction (including augmented flightcrews) to vocalize a divergence from the intended flightpath. A progressive intervention strategy is initiated by communicating a flightpath deviation (alert), then suggesting a course of action (advocacy and assertion), and then directly intervening, if necessary, by taking the controls to prevent an incident or accident. A pilot taking control should announce the transfer of control.
e. Startle or Surprise. Startle or surprise has been a factor in LOC-I incidents and accidents as upsets that occur in normal operations are unplanned and inadvertent, adversely impacting recognition or recovery. Instructors should plan upset scenarios emphasizing those event conditions and variables likely to result in startle/surprise while minimizing potential for negative transfer of training. The potential for negative transfer of training can be minimized through applying sound judgment with respect to realism and fidelity, as well as respecting the capabilities and limitations of the FSTD. The following points should be considered:
• Many possible events should be available for use during training. Otherwise, pilots will anticipate the event and not be surprised.
• The events should be taught in a supportive learning environment without jeopardy.
Otherwise, incentives are introduced for pilots to share with other pilots what to expect.
• Even if incentives are not introduced, pilots should be discouraged from revealing information about the events to other pilots that have yet to experience them.
Divulging a surprise scenario removes the benefit of allowing a colleague to examine his or her thoughts and responses in critical situations that arise in training.
As such, the strategic objective of inserting these scenarios in training should be emphasized for the benefit of all.
• Instructors will have to be inventive and introduce various ploys to achieve a startle or surprise response in simulation. Managing expectations in this way can help achieve responses while surprised even in simulation environments when the fear of harm does not exist.
Par 4-1 Page 15 CHAPTER 4. UPSET RECOVERY TEMPLATE
4-1. METHODOLOGY. Airplane manufacturers (Airbus, ATR Aircraft, Boeing, Bombardier, and Embraer) contributed to the development of the following upset recovery templates that provide commonality among various airplanes.
4-2. UPSET RECOVERY TEMPLATES. Tables 1 and 2 show the Nose High and Nose Low Upset Recovery Templates that were developed with input from the above manufacturers.
Although the procedures apply to the majority of today’s airplanes, manufacturer-recommended procedures may deviate from those included in this advisory circular (AC) due to specific airplane characteristics. Manufacturer recommendations may deviate from this template if necessary due to airplane operating characteristics. For air carriers operating airplanes without manufacturer upset recovery procedures, the FAA recommends using the upset recovery templates as a reference when developing air carrier-specific upset recovery procedures.
NOTE: The manufacturer’s procedures take precedence over the recommendations in this AC.
NOTE: These techniques assume the airplane is not stalled. If the airplane is stalled, recovery from the stall must be accomplished first in accordance with the current edition of AC 120-109, Stall Prevention and Recovery Training, or manufacturer procedures.
a. The following techniques represent a logical progression for recovering the airplane.
While not strictly procedural, the templates represent a consensus view of actions for recovery.
b. If needed, use pitch trim sparingly. Careful use of rudder to aid roll control should be considered only if roll control is ineffective.
c. This section uses the following acronyms: AP for autopilot and A/THR for autothrottle/autothrust.
Par 4-2 Page 16 TABLE 1. NOSE HIGH RECOVERY TEMPLATE Either Pilot:
Recognize and confirm the developing situation. Announce: “Nose High” Pilot Flying Pilot Monitoring AP: DISCONNECT3 MONITOR airspeed and attitude throughout the recovery and ANNOUNCE any continued divergence. A/THR: OFF PITCH: Apply as much nose-down control input as required to obtain a nose-down pitch rate.
THRUST: Adjust (if required) When airspeed is sufficiently increasing:
RECOVER to level flight4 NOTE: Recovery to level flight may require use of pitch trim.
NOTE: If necessary, consider reducing thrust in airplanes with underwing-mounted engines to aid in achieving nose-down pitch rate.
WARNING: Excessive use of pitch trim or rudder may aggravate the upset situation or may result in high structural loads.
3 A large out-of-trim condition could be encountered when the AP is disconnected.
4 Avoid stall because of premature recovery or excessive G loading.
Par 4-2 Page 17 TABLE 2. NOSE LOW RECOVERY TEMPLATE Either Pilot:
Recognize and confirm the developing situation. Announce: “Nose Low” Pilot Flying Pilot Monitoring AP: DISCONNECT5 MONITOR airspeed and attitude throughout the recovery and ANNOUNCE any continued divergence. A/THR: OFF RECOVER from stall if required ROLL6 in the shortest direction to wings level.
THRUST and DRAG: Adjust (if required) RECOVER to level flight7 NOTE: Recovery to level flight may require use of pitch trim.
WARNING: Excessive use of pitch trim or rudder may aggravate the upset situation or may result in high structural loads.
5 A large out-of-trim condition could be encountered when the AP is disconnected.
6 It may be necessary to reduce the G loading by applying forward control pressure to improve roll effectiveness.
7 Avoid stall because of premature recovery or excessive G loading.
Par 4-2 Page 18 TABLE 3. NOSE HIGH RECOVERY TEMPLATE WITH EXPLANATION Either Pilot: Recognize and confirm the developing situation. Announce: “Nose High” Explanation: A critical element in recognition and confirmation is to clearly understand the energy state and the rate to which it is changing because this will have an effect on how the PF handles the recovery.
Pilot Flying AP: DISCONNECT8 A/THR: OFF Explanation: Leaving the autopilot or autothrottle/autothrust connected may result in inadvertent changes or adjustments that may not be easily recognized or appropriate, especially during high workload situations.
PITCH: Apply as much nose-down control input as required to obtain a nose-down pitch rate.
Explanation: This may require as much as full nose-down input. If a sustained column force is required to obtain the desired response, use nose-down trim as needed to counter high stick forces.
If nose-down inputs are not successful in achieving a nose-down pitch rate, pitch may be controlled by rolling the airplane. A large bank angle is helpful in reducing excessively high pitch attitudes. The angle of bank should not normally exceed approximately 60°.
Continuous nose-down elevator pressure will keep the wing angle of attack low, which will make the normal roll controls effective. The rolling maneuver changes the pitch rate into a turning maneuver, allowing the pitch to decrease.
THRUST: Adjust (if required) Explanation: Combined with pitch trim, an additional effective method for achieving a nose-down pitch rate on airplanes with under-wing-mounted engines can be to reduce the power. Thrust should only be reduced to the point where control of the pitch is achieved.
This reduces the upward pitch moment. In fact, in some situations for some airplane models, it may be necessary to reduce thrust to prevent the angle of attack from continuing to increase.
If the pitch rate is being managed by trim and elevator inputs, it is not recommended to reduce thrust.
8 A large out-of-trim condition could be encountered when the AP is disconnected.