Page D - 5
(1) The approved specifications required by this rule may either be established government/industry specifications such as MIL, AISI, ASIM, or SAE; or the specifications may be company-developed proprietary specifications. Sufficient data should be provided to the FAA/AUTHORITY aircraft engineering offices to show that the desired features are provided by the process specification. In addition, sufficient process controls, inspections, and tests should be coordinated with FAA/AUTHORITY manufacturing inspection personnel to ensure that continued quality of the process is provided.
(2) In addition to the examples given by the rule; i.e., gluing, spot welding, and heat treating process, specifications should also be prepared for types of welding other than spot welding, for platings of metals, for protective finishes (other than decorative), for sealing, and for unique fabrication methods such as those used for composite materials.
(3) The required test programs should c onsider static strength effects, fatigue strength effects, and environmental effects as appropriate to the processes.
AC 27.607. § 27.607 (Am endment 27-4) FASTENERS.
a. Explanation . Section 27.607 of Amendment 27-4 requires dual locking removable fasteners in critical locations. A nonfriction locking device is specifically required in any bolt subject to rotation, as stated in the rules.
b. Procedures . Advisory Circular 20-71 contains information, procedures, and means of complying with § 27.607 of Amendment 27-4.
AC 27.609. § 27.609 PROTECTION OF STRUCTURE .
a. Explanation . The structure should be suitably protected as specified in the rule to maintain its design strength. Ventilation and drainage provisions must be provided as specified in the rule. Overboard drains should be furnished for corrosive or waste liquids. Drains for flammable fluids are specified in other rules such as §§ 27.999 and
27.1193.
b. Procedures .
(1) The structure may be preserved, painted, or treated with chemical films to protect it from strength deterioration. An approved process specification should be used for these types of treatments.
(2) Parts may be plated or chemically tr eated, such as anodized, for protection.
An evaluation and substantiation may be required to ensure the structure or parts are not adversely affected during, or as a result of, the plating or treatment process.
(§ 27.605 concerns approval of process specifications and fabrication methods.)
Page D - 6
(3) Plating or material surface har dness or composition changes may require fatigue substantiation to ensure the fatigue strength is not altered or is otherwise properly assessed. An approved process specification should be used for these types of treatments.
(4) To prevent water accumulation, drain holes should be placed at possible dams such as bulkheads and at low points in the fuselage and in the stabilizing surfaces.
(5) Control tubes and tubes used as primary mount structures (i.e., transmission support structure and engine mount structure) should be designed to prevent entry and collection of corrosive fluids or vapor, including water.
(i) A closed insert in each tube end may be used.
(ii) A sealant applied arou nd the tube ends and around each rivet head may be used.
(6) Overboard drains should discharge clear of the entire rotorcraft. Dyed water discharged in flight may be used to ensure fluids are properly drained.
(7) Drains or vents which handle corrosi ve fumes (such as battery case vent line) may incorporate a container with an agent to neutralize the fumes prior to venting overboard.
(8) Welded tubes should be flushed and sealed after welding in accordance with an approved process specification.
(9) Refer to AC 43-4, “Corrosion Cont rol for Aircraft,“ for further procedures.
AC 27.610. § 27.610 (Amendment 27-21) LIGHTNING PROTECTION.
a. Background. During the initial development and promulgation of the standards concerning the airworthiness of rotorcraft, it was not necessary to specify design features that would protect the rotorcraft from the meteorological phenomenon of lightning. This was due, in part, to the fact that rotorcraft were primarily operated in a VFR and nonicing environment. Also, a prudent pilot avoided thunderstorms where the possibility of encountering severe weather and a lightning strike was much greater. The construction, design, and operating environment of civil rotorcraft have changed markedly within the past two decades. Many rotorcraft are now authorized to fly IFR in all types of weather environment. One transport design has been approved for flight into known icing conditions. Additionally, many rotorcraft now use the same advanced technologies in structures and systems as do airplanes. Because of these facts, a specific rule on lightning protection of rotorcraft was adopted in Amendment 27-21. For further information, see the preamble of Amendment 27-21 (49 FR 44433; 11/6/84), Proposal 2-14. Section 27.610 is similar to § 25.581 which applies to the protection of
Page D - 7 structures of transport airplanes. However, the standard provides for specific protection of the aircraft structures as well as the systems of the rotorcraft. Section 27.610 is the standard referenced in the requirement for lightning protection of systems in § 27.1309(d) (see paragraph AC 27.1309). In addition, the protection of fuel systems from the effects of lightning is found and referenced in Report DOT/FAA/CT-83/3, User Manual for AC 20-53A, Protection of Airplane Fuel Systems Against Fuel Vapor Ignition Due to Lightning, dated April 12, 1985.
b. Explanation .
(1) The regulation require s that the rotorcraft must be protected against the catastrophic effects of lightning. This means that a lightning strike encounter should not prevent the continued safe operation of the rotorcraft.
(2) Paragraph AC 27.1309 addresses the protection required for systems. The protection of the rotorcraft structures may be accomplished in a similar fashion.
(3) The structural com ponents of the rotorcraft should be designed in such a manner that the lightning current may be safely diverted or conducted through the rotorcraft without damaging any critical structure or without causing damage to noncritical structure, the failure of which would preclude the continued safe flight and landing of the rotorcraft. A radome or fin cap which explodes due to a lightning strike and results in catastrophic damage to main or tail rotors is a scenario of lightning damage to a noncritical structure which has catastrophic results.
(4) This type of strike e ffect on the rotorcraft is generally referred to as direct effects. Direct effects are damage which includes the burning, eroding, blasting, or structural deformation produced by the high currents of the lightning flash passing through the rotorcraft structure.
c. Procedures .
(1) Certification Plan . Although not a regulatory requirement, it is recommended that a formal written certification plan be used to assure regulatory compliance. The use of this plan is beneficial to both the applicant and the FAA/AUTHORITY because it identifies and defines an acceptable resolution to the critical issues early in the certification process. These are the usual steps to be followed when utilizing a certification plan:
(i) Prepare a certification plan wh ich describes the analytical procedures and/or the qualification tests to be utilized to demonstrate protection effectiveness. Test proposals should describe the rotorcraft and system to be utilized, test drawing(s) as required, the method of installation that simulates the production installation, the lightning zone(s) applicable, the lightning simulation method(s), test voltage or current waveforms to be used, diagnostic methods, and the appropriate schedules and location(s) of proposed test(s).
Page D - 8
NOTE: The recommended reference for quantificat ion of the lightning environment, the determination of the aircraft lightning strike zones, and the determination of appropriate test methods is SAE AE4L Committee Report, dated June 20, 1978, Lightning Test Waveforms and Techniques for Aerospace Vehicles and Hardware. Additionally, information may also be found in the NASA publication No. RP-1008, Lightning Protection of Aircraft.
(ii) Obtain FAA/AUTHORITY concu rrence that the certification plan is adequate.
(iii) Obtain FAA/AUTHORITY detail par t conformity of the test articles and installation conformity of applicable portions of the test setup. Obtain FAA/AUTHORITY approval of the test proposal. A comprehensive test proposal may be used.
(iv) Schedule FAA/AUTHORITY witne ssing of the test or tests proposed.
(v) Submit a test report describing all results and obtain FAA/AUTHORITY approval of each report prepared.
(2) Test Conditions . Refer to SAE AE4L Committee Report, dated June 20, 1978, and the NASA publication noted in paragraph c(1)(i) to determine the appropriate test parameters.
Page D - 9
(3) Aircraft Design Features and Criteria . MIL-B-5087B, Amendment 2 or later amendment, contains valuable information to assist the designer. Figure 6 in the specification contains fault current versus bond resistance information. Refer to the NASA publication noted above also.
(i) Aluminum wire screen or mesh applied to the control or stabilizing surface and electrically bonded at each joint or juncture has been successful in conducting the current without serious damage.
(ii) Metal skin surfaces combined with surface wire screen or mesh have been successful. Also, successful use of surface treatment has been reported. For composites, treatments such as the following have been used: flame spray coatings, aluminized glass, metal foil, metallized fabrics, and conductive paint.
(iii) Ball or roller bearings may be used to conduct the current at rotating joints. However, increased friction or possible seizure of the bearing may occur. The potential for this should be evaluated. Inspection and replacement criteria for possible damage should be addressed in the manual for continued airworthiness. Bearings are especially susceptible to pitting and internal arcing.
(iv) Report DOT/FAA/CT-86/8, Ap ril 1987, Determination of Electrical Properties of Grounding, Bonding, and Fastening Techniques for Composite Materials, may assist the applicant.
(4) Fuel Systems. Refer to R eport DOT/FAA/CT-83/3 referenced in paragraph AC 27.610a. For additional information on the lightning protection requirements for fuel systems for rotorcraft with a certification basis which includes Amendment 27-23 refer to paragraph AC 27.954.
AC 27.610A. § 27.610 (Amendment 27-37) LIGHTNING AND STATIC ELECTRICITY PROTECTION.
a. Explanation .
(1) The title of § 27.610 has been revi sed to include protection from static electricity.
(2) A new § 27.610(d) has been added that specifies requirements for electrical bonding and protection against lightning and static electricity.
b. Procedures. The procedures of paragraph AC 27.610 still apply. In addition, the following procedures apply.
(1) Lightning Protection .
AC 27-1B, Chg 1 2/12/03
Page D - 10
(i) General. The rotorcraft stru cture should be provided with means to conduct lightning so that the rotorcraft and its occupants will not be endangered.
(ii) Rotors and Control Systems.
(A) It should be established t hat an adequate primary bonding path exists between the rotors and the airframe, such that a lightning strike on a rotor will not result in damage to or seizure of gearbox or swashplate bearings, control jacks, etc.
(B) Each hinge and bearing of ro tor blades and control surfaces should either:
( 1 ) Be of a type that is capable of withstanding a lightning discharge without damage or seizure leading to loss of function, or
( 2 ) Be provided with at least one primary bonding conductor. Where bonding conductors are provided, they should be as flexible and short as possible and should be installed so that there is no danger of the conductor jamming the hinge or bearing, particularly if partially disrupted by a lightning strike.
(iii) External Non-metallic Parts.
(A) Where non-metallic parts are fitt ed externally to the rotorcraft (e.g., rotors, radomes, composite skin panels) and are subjected to lightning, they should be protected against the following risks:
( 1 ) The disruption of the materials bec ause of rapid expansion of gases within them (e.g., water vapor);
( 2 ) The rapid build-up of pressure in vo ids or in the enclosure provided by the parts resulting in mechanical disruption of the parts themselves or of the structure enclosed by them;
( 3 ) Fire caused by the ignition of the materials themselves or of the materials contained within the enclosures.
(B) Materials used for external non-metallic parts should have low waterabsorption characteristics, should not occlude gases, and should be of high dielectric strength in order to encourage surface flashover rather than puncture.
(C) Rotors and other external parts of nonmetallic construction should be provided with effective lightning diverters and/or primary conductors, which are capable of safely carrying lightning discharges, unless it can be shown that damage due to lightning discharge will not endanger the rotorcraft or its occupants. Bonding straps/leads are not required for small gaps between metallic structure and diverters in non-conducting panels in order to comply with the lightning protection criteria.
Page D - 11 However, an electrical bonding path may be required to achieve static electricity protection.
(D) In some cases (e.g., radomes and rotors), confirmatory tests may be required to check the adequacy of the lightning protection provided.
(2) Characteristics of Lightning Discharges . The data contained in FAA AC 20-53 should be used for the purpose of assessing the adequacy of lightning discharge protection of rotorcraft.
(3) Protection Against the Accumulation of Static Charges.
(i) General. All items, which by the accumulation and discharge of static charges may cause a danger of electrical shock, ignition of flammable vapors, or interference with essential equipment (e.g., radio communications and navigational aids) should be adequately bonded to the main aircraft grounding system.
(ii) Intermittent Contact. The design should ensure that random intermittent contact between metallic and/or metallized parts (such as could cause unwanted radio interference or degradation of the components due to sparking) will not occur.
(iii) High Pressure Refueling and Fuel Transfer. Where provision is made for high pressure refueling and/or high rates of fuel transfer, it should be established, by test, or by consultation with the appropriate fuel manufacturers, that dangerously high voltages will not be induced within the fuel system. If compliance with this requirement involves any restriction on the types of fuel to be used or on the use of additives, an appropriate operating limitation should be established under FAR 27.1501(a). The critical refueling rates are related to the rotorcraft refueling installations, and the designer should seek the advice of fuel suppliers on this problem.
(A) With standard refueling equipm ent and standard aircraft turbine fuels, voltages high enough to cause sparking may be induced between the surface of the fuel and metal parts of the tank at refueling rates above approximately 250 gal/min. These induced voltages may be increased by the presence of additives and contaminants
(e.g., anti-corrosion inhibitors, lubricating oil, free water) and by splashing or spraying of the fuel in the tank.
(B) The static charge can be reduced as follows:
( 1 ) By means taken in the refueling equipment such as increasing the diameter of refueling lines and designing filters to give the minimum of electrostatic charging, or
AC 27-1B, Chg 1 2/12/03
Page D - 12 ( 2 ) By changing the electrical properties of the fuel by the use of antistatic additives and thus reducing the accumulation of static charge in the tank to a negligible amount.
(4) Primary and Secondary Bonding Paths .
(i) Primary bonding paths are those paths that are required to carry lightning discharge currents. These paths should be of as low an electrical impedance as is practicable. Secondary bonding paths are those paths provided for other forms of bonding.
(ii) Where additional conductors are required to provide or supplement the inherent primary bonding paths provided by the structure or equipment, the crosssectional area of such primary conductors made from copper should be not less than 3mm2 except that, where a single conductor is likely to carry the whole discharge from an isolated section, the cross-sectional area should be not less than 6mm2 . Aluminum primary conductors should have a cross-sectional area giving an equivalent surge carrying capacity.
(iii) Primary bonding paths should be used for—
(A) Connecting together the main grounding points of separable major components which may carry lightning discharges,
(B) Connecting engines to the main aircraft ground,
(C) Connecting to the main airc raft ground all metal parts presenting a surface on or outside of the external surface of the rotorcraft, and
(D) Conductors and lightning divert ers on external non-metallic parts.
(iv) Where additional conductors are required to provide or supplement the inherent secondary bonding paths provided by the structure or equipment, the cross-sectional area of such secondary conductors made from copper should be not less than 1mm2.
(5) Resistance and Continuity Measurements . Measurements should be made to determine the efficacy of the bonding and connection between at least the following:
(i) Primary Bonding Paths.
(A) The extremities of the fixed por tions of the rotorcraft and such fixed external panels and components where the method of construction and/or assembly leads to doubt as to the repeatability of the bond, e.g., removable panels.
(B) The engines and the main aircraft ground.
Page D - 13
(C) External movable metal surf aces or components and the main aircraft ground.
(D) The bonding conductors of exte rnal non-metallic parts and the main aircraft ground.
(E) Internal components for which a primary bond is specified and the main aircraft ground.
(ii) Secondary Bonding Paths.
(A) Metallic parts, normally in c ontact with flammable fluids, and the main aircraft ground.
(B) Isolated conducting parts subject to appreciable electrostatic charging and the main aircraft ground.
(C) Electrical panels and other equi pment accessible to the occupants of the rotorcraft and the main aircraft ground.
(D) Grounding connections that norma lly carry the main electrical supply and the main electrical return. The test on these connections should be such as to ensure that the connections can carry, without risk of fire or damage to the bond, or excessive volt drop, such continuous normal currents and intermittent fault currents as are applicable.
(E) Electrical and electron ic equipment and the main earth, where applicable, and as specified by the rotorcraft manufacturer.
(F) Static dischargers and t he main rotorcraft structure.
AC 27.611. § 27.611 INSPECTION PROVISIONS .
a. Explanation . The rotorcraft must have access panels or openings that will allow for proper maintenance and/or adjustment of the rotorcraft systems.
(1) The rule states: “There must be means to allow close examination of each part that requires recurring inspection, adjustment for proper alignment and functioning, or lubrication.”
(2) “Structural” or load-carrying a ccess panels may be used to comply with the rule. Structural panels should have stencils or permanent labels (§ 27.1541(a)(2)) stating the panels must be installed prior to ground or flight operation.
(3) Holes or “nonstructural” access panels should be used whenever possible.
Page D - 14
b. Procedures .
(1) The determination of compliance can be accomplished in conjunction with the following activities:
(i) Reviewing type design drawings.
(ii) Conformity inspections a ccomplished during certification testing.
(iii) Be evaluated during the control system proof and operation tests (§§ 27.681 and 27.683).
(iv) During type inspection test s and functioning and reliability testing.
(2) Equipment requiring frequent inspec tions (at less than 25-hour intervals), lubrication, or adjustments should be accessible through “nonstructural” doors. Areas or items requiring daily attention should be accessible through “nonstructural” doors since properly rated maintenance personnel are required to “open and close” or reinstall structural panels, and special design features, such as multiple pins and latches, are generally necessary for structural doors.
AC 27.613. § 27.613 (Am endment 27-16) MATERIAL STRENGTH PROPERTIES AND DESIGN VALUES.
a. Explanation . The rule requires the use of materials that have a known minimum strength value. The structure must not be understrength and must be designed to minimize fatigue failure.
(1) Material design values in certai n specified documents may be used. The FAA/AUTHORITY may approve other material design values thus allowing the applicant greater flexibility in selection of materials by proving their strength properties and design values as stated in § 27.613(d).
(2) Other materials that may be new or are not included in the specified documents may be tested and design values established as provided by § 27.613(a) and (d).
(3) Section 27.613(d) requires the select ion of materials that will retain design values and properties in the type of service environment and for the length of service time intended for the structure.
(4) Section 27.613(c) is an objective ru le concerning minimizing fatigue failures and § 27.571 concerns quantitative fatigue substantiation requirements.
b. Procedures .
Page D - 15
(1) The properties and design values in the documents noted in the rule may be used.
(2) MIL-HDBK-5, Metallic Materials and Elements for Flight Vehicle Structure, Chapter 9, contains procedures for establishing design values of additional materials.
Uniform means of presenting the data are also contained in this chapter.
(3) Design values and properties must include effects of the service environment and service time. An example is exposure at elevated temperatures on the ultimate tensile strength of 7079-T6 aluminum alloys as found in figure 3.7.4.1.1(c) of MIL-HDBK-5.
(4) The probability of disastrous fatig ue failures must be minimized. This may be accomplished by using design features usually identified as fail-safe features, such as the following:
(i) Selection of materials with stre ss levels to provide a controlled slow rate of crack propagation combined with high residual strength after initiation of cracks (lightly loaded structures).
(ii) Use of multipath constructi on and the provision of crack stoppers to limit the growth of cracks.
(iii) Use of composite (multielement ) duplicate structures so that a fatigue crack or failure occurring in one element of the composite (multielement) member will be confined to that element and the remaining structure will still possess adequate load-carrying ability.
(iv) Use of backup structure wher ein one member carries all the load, with a second member available and capable of assuming the extra load if the primary member fails.
(v) Design to permit detection of cracks including the use of crack detection systems, in all critical structural elements before the cracks can become dangerous or result in appreciable strength loss, and to permit replacement or repair.
(5) Acceptable standards for pressuriz ed containers or cylinders, such as cylinders of nitrogen, used to inflate emergency floats may be found in 49 CFR 178, Subpart C, §§ 178.36 through 178.68. Specifically, § 178.44 concerns standards for steel cylinders used in aircraft that are subjected to at least 900 PSI service pressure.
This standard includes strength, test, material property, inspection, quality, design features, identification, and inspection report requirements. As an example, § 178.44-14, entitled “Hydrostatic Test,” requires that each cylinder must be (proof) tested to at least 5/3 times the service pressure. Section 178.44-16, entitled “Burst
AC 27-1B, Chg 1 2/12/03
Page D - 16 Test,” also states that one cylinder taken at random out of each lot of cylinders shall be hydrostatically tested to destruction.
(6) Other design criteria may be dev eloped and approved under the provisions of FAR Part 27 as a unique part of the aircraft type design.
AC 27.613A. § 27.613 (A mendment 27-26) MATERIAL STRENGTH PROPERTIES AND DESIGN VALUES.
a. Explanation . Amendment 27-26 added explicit probability standards criteria to § 27.613(b). This amendment also provided for testing or proving the strength of selected individual items rather than conducting coupon tests to develop generic material strength properties that would be used for design purposes.
b. Procedures . The basic procedures of paragraph AC 27.613 still apply, except:
(1) Probability criteria common with MIL-HDBK-5D are explicitly allowed to determine strengths for metallic materials whose data are not available in MIL-HDBK-5D. These specific probability criteria should be used in conjunction with MIL-HDBK-17B whenever determining material strength properties for non-metallics.
(Also, reference paragraph AC 27 MG 8).
(2) New § 27.613(e) provides for the premium selection of materials. The premium selection of materials method uses a specimen from each individual item (part) to determine its properties before its use is allowed. This is a highly specialized and possibly costly method which applies only to parts that have areas available from which specimens can be obtained without destroying the part. The rotorcraft type design data of those parts made from premium selection should have the necessary information, such as a minimum allowable strength, on the drawing.
AC 27.619. § 27.619 SPECIAL FACTORS .
a. Explanation .
(1) This is a general rule to comple ment other rules. Special factors are employed for reasons cited in the rule to ensure an airworthy aircraft structure. The
1.5 ultimate load factor in § 27.303 is multiplied by a special factor as specified in the rule.
(2) Specific factors are prescribed fo r castings and fittings in §§ 27.621 and
27.625, respectively. Factors may be prescribed for bearings with free clearance as stated in § 27.623. In addition, any other factor may be prescribed “to ensure that the probability of the part being understrength because of the uncertainties specified in § 27.619(a) is extremely remote.”
b. Procedures .