What happened
The FAA’s narrative, in sentence case. The FAA writes it in capitals and removes private details.
Narrative: the private pilot preflighted his newly purchased aircraft and by visual inspection of the fuel level in relation to the first stringer, determined his fuel to be about 20 gallons. The pilot was relying on other RV-4 owners for this estimate, no fueling tests had been conducted by this pilot. The pilot reported that he left the carb heat on due to the outside air temperature being 42 degrees. While returning to the departure airport the engine quit, which the pilot felt was due to carb. Ice. After the officer on scene contacted the inspector on duty, the amount of fuel on board was checked. Fuel did flow from the drains but it was not possible to determine quantity due to uneven terrain. The pilot reported that 3/4 of a gallon was drained when the wings were removed. Subsequent fueling tests of the aircraft showed that this aircraft has much smaller tanks than the RV-4S owned by the pilots friends.
As the FAA filed it
NARRATIVE: THE PRIVATE PILOT PREFLIGHTED HIS NEWLY PURCHASED AIRCRAFT AND BY VISUAL INSPECTION OF THE FUEL LEVEL IN RELATION TO THE FIRST STRINGER, DETERMINED HIS FUEL TO BE ABOUT 20 GALLONS. THE PILOT WAS RELYING ON OTHER RV-4 OWNERS FOR THIS ESTIMATE, NO FUELING TESTS HAD BEEN CONDUCTED BY THIS PILOT. THE PILOT REPORTED THAT HE LEFT THE CARB HEAT ON DUE TO THE OUTSIDE AIR TEMPERATURE BEING 42 DEGREES. WHILE RETURNING TO THE DEPARTURE AIRPORT THE ENGINE QUIT, WHICH THE PILOT FELT WAS DUE TO CARB. ICE. AFTER THE OFFICER ON SCENE CONTACTED THE INSPECTOR ON DUTY, THE AMOUNT OF FUEL ON BOARD WAS CHECKED. FUEL DID FLOW FROM THE DRAINS BUT IT WAS NOT POSSIBLE TO DETERMINE QUANTITY DUE TO UNEVEN TERRAIN. THE PILOT REPORTED THAT 3/4 OF A GALLON WAS DRAINED WHEN THE WINGS WERE REMOVED. SUBSEQUENT FUELING TESTS OF THE AIRCRAFT SHOWED THAT THIS AIRCRAFT HAS MUCH SMALLER TANKS THAN THE RV-4S OWNED BY THE PILOTS FRIENDS.