What happened
The FAA’s narrative, in sentence case. The FAA writes it in capitals and removes private details.
(-5)During takeoff of runway 36 at Murfreesboro Municipal Airport (mbt) at rotation speed the pilot noticed a deer in his path slightly left of center line. The pilot lifted off and as the aircraft climbed out it struck the deer. The pilot noticed a slight vibration but the aircraft was making power and was climbing well so he opted to climb out and go around for a landing. Another pilot at the airport took off to reundeview with N7090F to see if there was any gear damage. Upon arriving in a distant formation with the aircraft he reported that there was no apparent gear failure which was consistent with the gear indication in the cockpit. The pilot returned and landed safely. Upon engine shut down the pilot noticed a small piece of the left propeller tip missing (approximately 1" x 2").
As the FAA filed it
(-5)DURING TAKEOFF OF RUNWAY 36 AT MURFREESBORO MUNICIPAL AIRPORT (MBT) AT ROTATION SPEED THE PILOT NOTICED A DEER IN HIS PATH SLIGHTLY LEFT OF CENTER LINE. THE PILOT LIFTED OFF AND AS THE AIRCRAFT CLIMBED OUT IT STRUCK THE DEER. THE PILOT NOTICED A SLIGHT VIBRATION BUT THE AIRCRAFT WAS MAKING POWER AND WAS CLIMBING WELL SO HE OPTED TO CLIMB OUT AND GO AROUND FOR A LANDING. ANOTHER PILOT AT THE AIRPORT TOOK OFF TO REUNDEVIEW WITH N7090F TO SEE IF THERE WAS ANY GEAR DAMAGE. UPON ARRIVING IN A DISTANT FORMATION WITH THE AIRCRAFT HE REPORTED THAT THERE WAS NO APPARENT GEAR FAILURE WHICH WAS CONSISTENT WITH THE GEAR INDICATION IN THE COCKPIT. THE PILOT RETURNED AND LANDED SAFELY. UPON ENGINE SHUT DOWN THE PILOT NOTICED A SMALL PIECE OF THE LEFT PROPELLER TIP MISSING (APPROXIMATELY 1" X 2").