What happened
The FAA’s narrative, in sentence case. The FAA writes it in capitals and removes private details.
(-23) Right fuel tank ran dry during cruise at 4000'. Pilot could see the Boyne Falls airport about 4 miles ahead and figured he could make the airport. The emergency checklist was not initiated for engine out in flight. The left fuel tank with fuel remaining was not selected. When the pilot realized he would not make the airport he landed in a pasture going through two fence rows. After the landing the left fuel tank was selected and the pilot was able to start the engine.
As the FAA filed it
(-23) RIGHT FUEL TANK RAN DRY DURING CRUISE AT 4000'. PILOT COULD SEE THE BOYNE FALLS AIRPORT ABOUT 4 MILES AHEAD AND FIGURED HE COULD MAKE THE AIRPORT. THE EMERGENCY CHECKLIST WAS NOT INITIATED FOR ENGINE OUT IN FLIGHT. THE LEFT FUEL TANK WITH FUEL REMAINING WAS NOT SELECTED. WHEN THE PILOT REALIZED HE WOULD NOT MAKE THE AIRPORT HE LANDED IN A PASTURE GOING THROUGH TWO FENCE ROWS. AFTER THE LANDING THE LEFT FUEL TANK WAS SELECTED AND THE PILOT WAS ABLE TO START THE ENGINE.