19990703008259A

Accident · Substantial damage

FAA accident report · Hughes 369D · Oakdale, CA · July 3, 1999

Date
July 3, 1999 · 10:00 local
Place
Oakdale, CA
Phase of flight
Autorot Descent (Rotorcraft)
Operating rules
Rotorcraft external load (Part 133)
Operator
ESDL
Damage
Substantial damage
Aircraft
N8661F
NTSB investigation
NTSBLAX99LA245
Reported as
Hughes 369D
Reported engine
Allison 250C20B
People aboard
3
Fatal injuries
0
Pilot’s flight hours
15,000 total11,000 in this make and model217 in the last 90 days

From the FAA’s Accident/Incident Data System (AIDS), through its Aviation Safety Information Portal, as reported. The NTSB investigates accidents separately, and its record of an accident is the fuller one. The aircraft is matched to the registry by N-number and event date, checked against the reported make and model; the registry’s history has gaps, so older matches can be wrong. Compare the reported make and model.

What happened

The FAA’s narrative, in sentence case. The FAA writes it in capitals and removes private details.

Hughes 369D helicopter experienced a partial loss of engine power while performing work at a construction site, went into auto-rotation, made a hard landing in a corn field, and the main rotor cut off the tail boom, other circumstances are unknown. (.4)the pilot experienced a partial loss of engine power while established in an out of ground effect hover at 150 feet AGL and landed hard in the resulting autorotation. Postcrash examination of the engine revealed that the turbine had experienced oil starvation due to a failure of the oil pump. The aft bearing (gear case cover) of the fcu/oil pump drive spur gear had disintegrated due to failure of the ribbon-type ball separator, which was found in the bottom of the gearbox in two pieces and deformed. The balls were ejected into the gear case and one was ingested by the oil pump, which caused internal jamming and the resultant shearing of the splined adapter which drives the oil pump. The ball separator was manufactured from an austenitic stainless steel, instead of aisi 1010 as specified by the manufacturer, and the material exceeded allowable hardness specifications. Allison ceb 1228, issued November 20, 1985, calls for bearings with the ribbon-type, pressed steel separator, to be replaced with bearings that incorporate a one-piece machined steel separator. Compliance was due at the next accessory gearbox repair when the gearbox was opened. The mechanic reported that he had replaced the number 2.5 bearing and the spur adapter gear shaft 265 hours and 4 months before the accident, which would have provided access to the gearbox to accomplish the bulletin. (-23)on 7/3/99, at approximately 1030AM PDT, N8661F, Hughes 369D, piloted by a commerical pilot lost partial power of the engine, autorotated, impact terrain soft turf cornfield. The main rotor blades cut off the tailboom. The FAR part 133 flight was conducted for powerline maintenance under VFR VMC. No injuries to the pilot or two passengers. Maintenance personnel found the engine oil pump spur bearing liner failed.

As the FAA filed it

HUGHES 369D HELICOPTER EXPERIENCED A PARTIAL LOSS OF ENGINE POWER WHILE PERFORMING WORK AT A CONSTRUCTION SITE, WENT INTO AUTO-ROTATION, MADE A HARD LANDING IN A CORN FIELD, AND THE MAIN ROTOR CUT OFF THE TAIL BOOM, OTHER CIRCUMSTANCES ARE UNKNOWN. (.4)THE PILOT EXPERIENCED A PARTIAL LOSS OF ENGINE POWER WHILE ESTABLISHED IN AN OUT OF GROUND EFFECT HOVER AT 150 FEET AGL AND LANDED HARD IN THE RESULTING AUTOROTATION. POSTCRASH EXAMINATION OF THE ENGINE REVEALED THAT THE TURBINE HAD EXPERIENCED OIL STARVATION DUE TO A FAILURE OF THE OIL PUMP. THE AFT BEARING (GEAR CASE COVER) OF THE FCU/OIL PUMP DRIVE SPUR GEAR HAD DISINTEGRATED DUE TO FAILURE OF THE RIBBON-TYPE BALL SEPARATOR, WHICH WAS FOUND IN THE BOTTOM OF THE GEARBOX IN TWO PIECES AND DEFORMED. THE BALLS WERE EJECTED INTO THE GEAR CASE AND ONE WAS INGESTED BY THE OIL PUMP, WHICH CAUSED INTERNAL JAMMING AND THE RESULTANT SHEARING OF THE SPLINED ADAPTER WHICH DRIVES THE OIL PUMP. THE BALL SEPARATOR WAS MANUFACTURED FROM AN AUSTENITIC STAINLESS STEEL, INSTEAD OF AISI 1010 AS SPECIFIED BY THE MANUFACTURER, AND THE MATERIAL EXCEEDED ALLOWABLE HARDNESS SPECIFICATIONS. ALLISON CEB 1228, ISSUED NOVEMBER 20, 1985, CALLS FOR BEARINGS WITH THE RIBBON-TYPE, PRESSED STEEL SEPARATOR, TO BE REPLACED WITH BEARINGS THAT INCORPORATE A ONE-PIECE MACHINED STEEL SEPARATOR. COMPLIANCE WAS DUE AT THE NEXT ACCESSORY GEARBOX REPAIR WHEN THE GEARBOX WAS OPENED. THE MECHANIC REPORTED THAT HE HAD REPLACED THE NUMBER 2.5 BEARING AND THE SPUR ADAPTER GEAR SHAFT 265 HOURS AND 4 MONTHS BEFORE THE ACCIDENT, WHICH WOULD HAVE PROVIDED ACCESS TO THE GEARBOX TO ACCOMPLISH THE BULLETIN. (-23)ON 7/3/99, AT APPROXIMATELY 1030AM PDT, N8661F, HUGHES 369D, PILOTED BY A COMMERICAL PILOT LOST PARTIAL POWER OF THE ENGINE, AUTOROTATED, IMPACT TERRAIN SOFT TURF CORNFIELD. THE MAIN ROTOR BLADES CUT OFF THE TAILBOOM. THE FAR PART 133 FLIGHT WAS CONDUCTED FOR POWERLINE MAINTENANCE UNDER VFR VMC. NO INJURIES TO THE PILOT OR TWO PASSENGERS. MAINTENANCE PERSONNEL FOUND THE ENGINE OIL PUMP SPUR BEARING LINER FAILED.

NTSB investigation

The NTSB’s investigation of this event, with its probable cause and findings. Matched to this report by N-number and date.