19991102038569I

Incident

FAA incident report · Doug DC-9-32 · Milwaukee, WI · November 2, 1999

Date
November 2, 1999 · 20:35 local
Place
Milwaukee, WI
Airport
General Mitchell Field
Phase of flight
Climb
Operating rules
Air carrier (Part 121)
Operator
MWEA
Aircraft
N215ME
Reported as
Doug DC932
Reported engine
Pratt & Whitney JT8D9A
Pilot’s flight hours
7,500 total2,500 in this make and model233 in the last 90 days

From the FAA’s Accident/Incident Data System (AIDS), through its Aviation Safety Information Portal, as reported. The NTSB investigates accidents separately, and its record of an accident is the fuller one. The aircraft is matched to the registry by N-number and event date, checked against the reported make and model; the registry’s history has gaps, so older matches can be wrong. Compare the reported make and model.

What happened

The FAA’s narrative, in sentence case. The FAA writes it in capitals and removes private details.

The aircraft over nighted in cyyz where a hard rain driven by gusty winds hitting the aircraft from the rear for quite a period of time. Upon departure from cyyz and while climbing to altitude the aircraft elevator froze and was uncontroable. An emergency was declared into mke and as the aircraft came down into warmer air the elevator control was regained by the flight crew. An inspection of the aircraft by mwea at mke did not find any definitive cause for this problem. This is the 4th time mwea has had this condition happen to one of thier aircraft. They all experienced the same preflight conditions;ie, driving wind 30MPH and hard rain. Horizontal stabilizer rub seals were replaced as precautionary but there was no evidence showing that this would correct the problem. In the investigation, type 4 anti-ice fluid was noted as a problem since it will get into pulley areas and became dry then as water hits is placed on top of the dried type 4 it became particalley reactive but then freezes at altitude. Mwea is putting in place during their "a" check inspections a hot type 1 deicing fluid wash to clean out any remaining dried type 4 fluid. This type 4 fluid has been identified as part of the problem. privacy data omitted This recommendation was part of a Boeing aircraft company recommendation which was part of the findings.

As the FAA filed it

THE AIRCRAFT OVER NIGHTED IN CYYZ WHERE A HARD RAIN DRIVEN BY GUSTY WINDS HITTING THE AIRCRAFT FROM THE REAR FOR QUITE A PERIOD OF TIME. UPON DEPARTURE FROM CYYZ AND WHILE CLIMBING TO ALTITUDE THE AIRCRAFT ELEVATOR FROZE AND WAS UNCONTROABLE. AN EMERGENCY WAS DECLARED INTO MKE AND AS THE AIRCRAFT CAME DOWN INTO WARMER AIR THE ELEVATOR CONTROL WAS REGAINED BY THE FLIGHT CREW. AN INSPECTION OF THE AIRCRAFT BY MWEA AT MKE DID NOT FIND ANY DEFINITIVE CAUSE FOR THIS PROBLEM. THIS IS THE 4TH TIME MWEA HAS HAD THIS CONDITION HAPPEN TO ONE OF THIER AIRCRAFT. THEY ALL EXPERIENCED THE SAME PREFLIGHT CONDITIONS;IE, DRIVING WIND 30MPH AND HARD RAIN. HORIZONTAL STABILIZER RUB SEALS WERE REPLACED AS PRECAUTIONARY BUT THERE WAS NO EVIDENCE SHOWING THAT THIS WOULD CORRECT THE PROBLEM. IN THE INVESTIGATION, TYPE 4 ANTI-ICE FLUID WAS NOTED AS A PROBLEM SINCE IT WILL GET INTO PULLEY AREAS AND BECAME DRY THEN AS WATER HITS IS PLACED ON TOP OF THE DRIED TYPE 4 IT BECAME PARTICALLEY REACTIVE BUT THEN FREEZES AT ALTITUDE. MWEA IS PUTTING IN PLACE DURING THEIR "A" CHECK INSPECTIONS A HOT TYPE 1 DEICING FLUID WASH TO CLEAN OUT ANY REMAINING DRIED TYPE 4 FLUID. THIS TYPE 4 FLUID HAS BEEN IDENTIFIED AS PART OF THE PROBLEM. ^PRIVACY DATA OMITTED^ THIS RECOMMENDATION WAS PART OF A BOEING AIRCRAFT COMPANY RECOMMENDATION WHICH WAS PART OF THE FINDINGS.