20000604004749A

Accident · Destroyed

FAA accident report · Bell UH-1H · Ft. Myers, FL · June 4, 2000

Date
June 4, 2000 · 10:40 local
Place
Ft. Myers, FL
Phase of flight
Normal Cruise
Operating rules
General operating rules (Part 91)
Damage
Destroyed
Aircraft
N127FC
NTSB investigation
NTSBMIA00GA184
Reported as
Bell UH1H
Reported engine
Lycoming T53L13B
People aboard
1
Fatal injuries
1
Pilot’s flight hours
4,000 total91 in this make and model400 in the last 90 days

From the FAA’s Accident/Incident Data System (AIDS), through its Aviation Safety Information Portal, as reported. The NTSB investigates accidents separately, and its record of an accident is the fuller one. The aircraft is matched to the registry by N-number and event date, checked against the reported make and model; the registry’s history has gaps, so older matches can be wrong. Compare the reported make and model.

What happened

The FAA’s narrative, in sentence case. The FAA writes it in capitals and removes private details.

(-23) On June 4, 2000, at 1040EST a Bell UH-1H helicopter, N-127FC, registered to the Florida forrestry division, collided with the ground while conducting water bucket operations in the Ft. Myers area. Visual meterological conditions prevailed at the time of the accident. No flight pla was filed but flight following was conducted with fire base control. The aircraft was demolished as a result and the pilot was killed as a result. The flight originated from buckingham airport on Ft. Myers Florida on June 4 2000 at 0830 hours. During level flight at approximately 300 feet, aircraft was observed to initate a right roll until it was at a high bank angle at which time it entered a pronaunced nose low attitude and collided with the ground. (.4) during a fire-fighting flight, witnesses observed the helicopter heading back towards the fire with an external bucket of water. The helicopter was seen in level flight heading in a northeasterly direction away from the lake were the bucket was refilled. A witness said the helicopter banked steeply and went into a nose-low attitude until it disappeared behind trees. Shortly after disappearing behind the trees, the witnesses heard the sound o f impact. An aircraft mechanic, who saw the pilot before the flight stated, "...[the pilot]...complained that someone...at 1230 am...woke him up to tell him they wanted him in at 8:00 am. He mumbled something about sleepwalking. That he couldn't get back to sleep...I cautioned him about the heat and told him not to overwork himself." On Saturday June 3, 2000, the day before the accident the pilot had put in a 14 hour 20 minute workday, and 3 hours of that was flight time after 1800. According to the pilot's medical records he had been under treatment for chronic hepatitis c, and had been taking interferon for his disease. According to the pilot's girlfriend's statement, "...[the pilot] stopped taking all medications prior to August 1998...during the period of August 1998-June 2000, [the pilot] did not see a doctor for any reason, [the pilot] knew his condition was worsening...the [pilot] would have his good days and his bad, but would still push himself to the limit of almost shear exhaustion, and then almost collapse and rest on days off to maintain his physical ability to work for the state......[the pilot] was an alcoholic and would not drink for any reason...[the pilot] was extremely tired the morning of June 4, 2000, when she dropped him off at...[the] airport...[he] had a poor night sleep and was still aggravated from receiving the midnight phone call from the...dispatch." A search of the pilot's last FAA flight physical, dated November 9, 1999, did not indicate any pre-exiting disease. However medical records obtained from the tallahassee, Florida, veterans administration, out patient clinic, revealed the following; "[patient] on interferon for hep c [hepatitis...advised to continue medication, interferon...results showed some changes...and...to continue interferon as ordered...family member took message that labs ok to continue rx as ordered." The pilot was transferred to fort Myers on November 1, 1999, and the VA out patient clinic at fort Myers had no record of the pilot at their facility. The following medical information it was extracted from the medical records maintained on the pilot by the FAA civil aeromedical institute aeromedical certification division: applications for 2nd class airman medical certificates on November 25, 1997, November 9, 1998, and November 9, 1999 each indicate "no" under item 17 ("do you currently use any medication") and under item 18 ("have you ever had or have you now any of the following") for sections ("stomach, liver, or intestinal trouble") and x ("other illness, disability, or surgery"). The following information was extracted by the NTSB medical officer, from the report of autopsy performed on the pilot by the office of the district medical examiner in fort Myers, Florida: - under "microscopic examination" is noted, "liver: cirrhosis, portal triads with chronic inflammatory cells, micro and macrovesicular steatosis and focal areas of congestion." The most common symptom of chronic hepatitis c is fatigue. Interferon therapy is often used in individuals with hepatitis c, and had been prescribed by the VA for the pilot. There were, however, no recent medical records to suggest that the pilot had continued that therapy or to indicate how his liver was functioning at or near the time of the accident. The autopsy findings indicate that his disease had progressed to cirrhosis, but the cirrhosis was not noted to be severe. FAA aviation medical examiners are instructed to deny or defer medical certification to the FAA aeromedical certification division for any airmen who have chronic hepatitis with impaired liver function. Examination and test on the collective servo actuator, the cyclic servo actuator, the hydraulic pump, the hydraulic shut-off valve, the engine, and the bambi (water) bucket, revealed no discrepancies other then impact damage.

As the FAA filed it

(-23) ON JUNE 4, 2000, AT 1040EST A BELL UH-1H HELICOPTER, N-127FC, REGISTERED TO THE FLORIDA FORRESTRY DIVISION, COLLIDED WITH THE GROUND WHILE CONDUCTING WATER BUCKET OPERATIONS IN THE FT. MYERS AREA. VISUAL METEROLOGICAL CONDITIONS PREVAILED AT THE TIME OF THE ACCIDENT. NO FLIGHT PLA WAS FILED BUT FLIGHT FOLLOWING WAS CONDUCTED WITH FIRE BASE CONTROL. THE AIRCRAFT WAS DEMOLISHED AS A RESULT AND THE PILOT WAS KILLED AS A RESULT. THE FLIGHT ORIGINATED FROM BUCKINGHAM AIRPORT ON FT. MYERS FLORIDA ON JUNE 4 2000 AT 0830 HOURS. DURING LEVEL FLIGHT AT APPROXIMATELY 300 FEET, AIRCRAFT WAS OBSERVED TO INITATE A RIGHT ROLL UNTIL IT WAS AT A HIGH BANK ANGLE AT WHICH TIME IT ENTERED A PRONAUNCED NOSE LOW ATTITUDE AND COLLIDED WITH THE GROUND. (.4) DURING A FIRE-FIGHTING FLIGHT, WITNESSES OBSERVED THE HELICOPTER HEADING BACK TOWARDS THE FIRE WITH AN EXTERNAL BUCKET OF WATER. THE HELICOPTER WAS SEEN IN LEVEL FLIGHT HEADING IN A NORTHEASTERLY DIRECTION AWAY FROM THE LAKE WERE THE BUCKET WAS REFILLED. A WITNESS SAID THE HELICOPTER BANKED STEEPLY AND WENT INTO A NOSE-LOW ATTITUDE UNTIL IT DISAPPEARED BEHIND TREES. SHORTLY AFTER DISAPPEARING BEHIND THE TREES, THE WITNESSES HEARD THE SOUND O F IMPACT. AN AIRCRAFT MECHANIC, WHO SAW THE PILOT BEFORE THE FLIGHT STATED, "...[THE PILOT]...COMPLAINED THAT SOMEONE...AT 1230 AM...WOKE HIM UP TO TELL HIM THEY WANTED HIM IN AT 8:00 AM. HE MUMBLED SOMETHING ABOUT SLEEPWALKING. THAT HE COULDN'T GET BACK TO SLEEP...I CAUTIONED HIM ABOUT THE HEAT AND TOLD HIM NOT TO OVERWORK HIMSELF." ON SATURDAY JUNE 3, 2000, THE DAY BEFORE THE ACCIDENT THE PILOT HAD PUT IN A 14 HOUR 20 MINUTE WORKDAY, AND 3 HOURS OF THAT WAS FLIGHT TIME AFTER 1800. ACCORDING TO THE PILOT'S MEDICAL RECORDS HE HAD BEEN UNDER TREATMENT FOR CHRONIC HEPATITIS C, AND HAD BEEN TAKING INTERFERON FOR HIS DISEASE. ACCORDING TO THE PILOT'S GIRLFRIEND'S STATEMENT, "...[THE PILOT] STOPPED TAKING ALL MEDICATIONS PRIOR TO AUGUST 1998...DURING THE PERIOD OF AUGUST 1998-JUNE 2000, [THE PILOT] DID NOT SEE A DOCTOR FOR ANY REASON, [THE PILOT] KNEW HIS CONDITION WAS WORSENING...THE [PILOT] WOULD HAVE HIS GOOD DAYS AND HIS BAD, BUT WOULD STILL PUSH HIMSELF TO THE LIMIT OF ALMOST SHEAR EXHAUSTION, AND THEN ALMOST COLLAPSE AND REST ON DAYS OFF TO MAINTAIN HIS PHYSICAL ABILITY TO WORK FOR THE STATE......[THE PILOT] WAS AN ALCOHOLIC AND WOULD NOT DRINK FOR ANY REASON...[THE PILOT] WAS EXTREMELY TIRED THE MORNING OF JUNE 4, 2000, WHEN SHE DROPPED HIM OFF AT...[THE] AIRPORT...[HE] HAD A POOR NIGHT SLEEP AND WAS STILL AGGRAVATED FROM RECEIVING THE MIDNIGHT PHONE CALL FROM THE...DISPATCH." A SEARCH OF THE PILOT'S LAST FAA FLIGHT PHYSICAL, DATED NOVEMBER 9, 1999, DID NOT INDICATE ANY PRE-EXITING DISEASE. HOWEVER MEDICAL RECORDS OBTAINED FROM THE TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA, VETERANS ADMINISTRATION, OUT PATIENT CLINIC, REVEALED THE FOLLOWING; "[PATIENT] ON INTERFERON FOR HEP C [HEPATITIS...ADVISED TO CONTINUE MEDICATION, INTERFERON...RESULTS SHOWED SOME CHANGES...AND...TO CONTINUE INTERFERON AS ORDERED...FAMILY MEMBER TOOK MESSAGE THAT LABS OK TO CONTINUE RX AS ORDERED." THE PILOT WAS TRANSFERRED TO FORT MYERS ON NOVEMBER 1, 1999, AND THE VA OUT PATIENT CLINIC AT FORT MYERS HAD NO RECORD OF THE PILOT AT THEIR FACILITY. THE FOLLOWING MEDICAL INFORMATION IT WAS EXTRACTED FROM THE MEDICAL RECORDS MAINTAINED ON THE PILOT BY THE FAA CIVIL AEROMEDICAL INSTITUTE AEROMEDICAL CERTIFICATION DIVISION: APPLICATIONS FOR 2ND CLASS AIRMAN MEDICAL CERTIFICATES ON NOVEMBER 25, 1997, NOVEMBER 9, 1998, AND NOVEMBER 9, 1999 EACH INDICATE "NO" UNDER ITEM 17 ("DO YOU CURRENTLY USE ANY MEDICATION") AND UNDER ITEM 18 ("HAVE YOU EVER HAD OR HAVE YOU NOW ANY OF THE FOLLOWING") FOR SECTIONS ("STOMACH, LIVER, OR INTESTINAL TROUBLE") AND X ("OTHER ILLNESS, DISABILITY, OR SURGERY"). THE FOLLOWING INFORMATION WAS EXTRACTED BY THE NTSB MEDICAL OFFICER, FROM THE REPORT OF AUTOPSY PERFORMED ON THE PILOT BY THE OFFICE OF THE DISTRICT MEDICAL EXAMINER IN FORT MYERS, FLORIDA: - UNDER "MICROSCOPIC EXAMINATION" IS NOTED, "LIVER: CIRRHOSIS, PORTAL TRIADS WITH CHRONIC INFLAMMATORY CELLS, MICRO AND MACROVESICULAR STEATOSIS AND FOCAL AREAS OF CONGESTION." THE MOST COMMON SYMPTOM OF CHRONIC HEPATITIS C IS FATIGUE. INTERFERON THERAPY IS OFTEN USED IN INDIVIDUALS WITH HEPATITIS C, AND HAD BEEN PRESCRIBED BY THE VA FOR THE PILOT. THERE WERE, HOWEVER, NO RECENT MEDICAL RECORDS TO SUGGEST THAT THE PILOT HAD CONTINUED THAT THERAPY OR TO INDICATE HOW HIS LIVER WAS FUNCTIONING AT OR NEAR THE TIME OF THE ACCIDENT. THE AUTOPSY FINDINGS INDICATE THAT HIS DISEASE HAD PROGRESSED TO CIRRHOSIS, BUT THE CIRRHOSIS WAS NOT NOTED TO BE SEVERE. FAA AVIATION MEDICAL EXAMINERS ARE INSTRUCTED TO DENY OR DEFER MEDICAL CERTIFICATION TO THE FAA AEROMEDICAL CERTIFICATION DIVISION FOR ANY AIRMEN WHO HAVE CHRONIC HEPATITIS WITH IMPAIRED LIVER FUNCTION. EXAMINATION AND TEST ON THE COLLECTIVE SERVO ACTUATOR, THE CYCLIC SERVO ACTUATOR, THE HYDRAULIC PUMP, THE HYDRAULIC SHUT-OFF VALVE, THE ENGINE, AND THE BAMBI (WATER) BUCKET, REVEALED NO DISCREPANCIES OTHER THEN IMPACT DAMAGE.

NTSB investigation

The NTSB’s investigation of this event, with its probable cause and findings. Matched to this report by N-number and date.