20020130007709A

Accident · No damage

FAA accident report · Piper PA42720 · Ames, IA · January 30, 2002

Date
January 30, 2002 · 18:10 local
Place
Ames, IA
Airport
Ames Municipal Airport
Operating rules
General operating rules (Part 91)
Damage
No damage
Aircraft
N66MT
NTSB investigation
NTSBCHI02LA075
Reported as
Piper PA42720

From the FAA’s Accident/Incident Data System (AIDS), through its Aviation Safety Information Portal, as reported. The NTSB investigates accidents separately, and its record of an accident is the fuller one. The aircraft is matched to the registry by N-number and event date, checked against the reported make and model; the registry’s history has gaps, so older matches can be wrong. Compare the reported make and model.

What happened

The FAA’s narrative, in sentence case. The FAA writes it in capitals and removes private details.

(-23) A Piper cheyenne PA-42-720, N66MT, piloted by Mr. William dougherty and the owner Mr. Henry manatt both rated pilots, sustained substantial damage during an ILS approach for landing on runway 01 at the Ames Municipal Airport, Ames, Iowa. The airplane struck a power pole, subsequent power lines, and then impacted the terrain short of the airport. This was the fourth and next to the last flight leg for the day that began with a scheduled departure time of 0700 that morning. The crew left newton, IA, with Mr. Manatt as PIC for the first two legs to goodland, KS, and scottsdale, AZ. Mr. Dougherty was PIC for the nest legs to denver, co and Ames, IA. They flew over 2057 nautical miles that day. The weather conditions at Ames, IA, were IMC with visibility better than a 1 1/4 mile. Mr. Dougherty states that he had ground contact for most of the approach, he also says he was on the glide slope. The aircraft first impacted a telephone pole along a north/south road approximately 3/4 nautical mile south of the runway. This was the cheyenne's right wing at 26 foot above the ground. Then the aircraft descended underneath the next set of wires approximately 800 feet further north that ran along an east/west road. This set of wires contacted the vertical stabilizer and acted as an arresting cable placing the aircraft in nose high landing attitude. The initial ground contact was not hard enough to damage the main gear but the tracks in the snow indicate the nose gear collapsed with initial contact. Shortly thereafter, the right main collapsed and caused the aircraft to yaw to the right, coming to rest on a heading of approximately 160 degrees and 0.5 nautical mile south of the runway.

As the FAA filed it

(-23) A PIPER CHEYENNE PA-42-720, N66MT, PILOTED BY MR. WILLIAM DOUGHERTY AND THE OWNER MR. HENRY MANATT BOTH RATED PILOTS, SUSTAINED SUBSTANTIAL DAMAGE DURING AN ILS APPROACH FOR LANDING ON RUNWAY 01 AT THE AMES MUNICIPAL AIRPORT, AMES, IOWA. THE AIRPLANE STRUCK A POWER POLE, SUBSEQUENT POWER LINES, AND THEN IMPACTED THE TERRAIN SHORT OF THE AIRPORT. THIS WAS THE FOURTH AND NEXT TO THE LAST FLIGHT LEG FOR THE DAY THAT BEGAN WITH A SCHEDULED DEPARTURE TIME OF 0700 THAT MORNING. THE CREW LEFT NEWTON, IA, WITH MR. MANATT AS PIC FOR THE FIRST TWO LEGS TO GOODLAND, KS, AND SCOTTSDALE, AZ. MR. DOUGHERTY WAS PIC FOR THE NEST LEGS TO DENVER, CO AND AMES, IA. THEY FLEW OVER 2057 NAUTICAL MILES THAT DAY. THE WEATHER CONDITIONS AT AMES, IA, WERE IMC WITH VISIBILITY BETTER THAN A 1 1/4 MILE. MR. DOUGHERTY STATES THAT HE HAD GROUND CONTACT FOR MOST OF THE APPROACH, HE ALSO SAYS HE WAS ON THE GLIDE SLOPE. THE AIRCRAFT FIRST IMPACTED A TELEPHONE POLE ALONG A NORTH/SOUTH ROAD APPROXIMATELY 3/4 NAUTICAL MILE SOUTH OF THE RUNWAY. THIS WAS THE CHEYENNE'S RIGHT WING AT 26 FOOT ABOVE THE GROUND. THEN THE AIRCRAFT DESCENDED UNDERNEATH THE NEXT SET OF WIRES APPROXIMATELY 800 FEET FURTHER NORTH THAT RAN ALONG AN EAST/WEST ROAD. THIS SET OF WIRES CONTACTED THE VERTICAL STABILIZER AND ACTED AS AN ARRESTING CABLE PLACING THE AIRCRAFT IN NOSE HIGH LANDING ATTITUDE. THE INITIAL GROUND CONTACT WAS NOT HARD ENOUGH TO DAMAGE THE MAIN GEAR BUT THE TRACKS IN THE SNOW INDICATE THE NOSE GEAR COLLAPSED WITH INITIAL CONTACT. SHORTLY THEREAFTER, THE RIGHT MAIN COLLAPSED AND CAUSED THE AIRCRAFT TO YAW TO THE RIGHT, COMING TO REST ON A HEADING OF APPROXIMATELY 160 DEGREES AND 0.5 NAUTICAL MILE SOUTH OF THE RUNWAY.

NTSB investigation

The NTSB’s investigation of this event, with its probable cause and findings. Matched to this report by N-number and date.