20040919023319I

Incident · Minor damage

FAA incident report · Frchld F-27F · Las Vegas, NV · September 19, 2004

Date
September 19, 2004 · 18:40 local
Place
Las Vegas, NV
Airport
North Las Vegas Air Terminal
Phase of flight
Ground Taxi, Other Airplane
Operating rules
General operating rules (Part 91)
Operator
B89M
Damage
Minor damage
Aircraft
N366SB
Reported as
Frchld F27F
Reported engine
Rolls-Royce DART5297H
People aboard
16
Fatal injuries
0
Pilot’s flight hours
18,065 total5,600 in this make and model45 in the last 90 days

From the FAA’s Accident/Incident Data System (AIDS), through its Aviation Safety Information Portal, as reported. The NTSB investigates accidents separately, and its record of an accident is the fuller one. The aircraft is matched to the registry by N-number and event date, checked against the reported make and model; the registry’s history has gaps, so older matches can be wrong. Compare the reported make and model.

What happened

The FAA’s narrative, in sentence case. The FAA writes it in capitals and removes private details.

(-23) The flight originated at brown field in san diego area (sdm). On arrival there was a windstorm out of the south. The company's standard procedure is to pull straight-in in tight quarters between two hangars. Arrival time was at dusk; dark conditions prevailed, but not dark enough to trigger hangar exterior lighting. No movement/parking marks are painted on surface in this area. PIC made decision to do a non-standard right 180 degree turn so as to park a/c into the strong southerly wind. Port engine had been secured after leaving runway as SOP for deplaning passenger safety. Crew was being marshalled by an FBO employee who is reportedly not trained/qualified as a marshaller and who was not using lighted wands. As a/c was in the right turn, PIC crew was distracted by concern for safety of the ground crewman, and by the need to closely monitor brake pressure gauge on right side of cockpit. Aircraft was turning into the operating engine, and arc was insufficient. The tip of port wing contacted a closed hangar door. The damage to the hangar door was minor, consisting of a horizontal dent and adjacent puncture approx. 12' x 18'. Damage to tip of left wing appeared to be superficial. According to a/w inspector, "damage includes left hand wing tip and forward spar from wintip attachment to approximately 12" inboard of wingtip. Skin and associated plumbing for fuel vent also damaged." The a/c has undergone a standard repair iaw the repair manual. No 337 is necessary according to the a/w inspector and a local der. PIC krueger has mailed photos of the open wing and damage detail to NTSB in effort to make the case that this is not an accident.

As the FAA filed it

(-23) THE FLIGHT ORIGINATED AT BROWN FIELD IN SAN DIEGO AREA (SDM). ON ARRIVAL THERE WAS A WINDSTORM OUT OF THE SOUTH. THE COMPANY'S STANDARD PROCEDURE IS TO PULL STRAIGHT-IN IN TIGHT QUARTERS BETWEEN TWO HANGARS. ARRIVAL TIME WAS AT DUSK; DARK CONDITIONS PREVAILED, BUT NOT DARK ENOUGH TO TRIGGER HANGAR EXTERIOR LIGHTING. NO MOVEMENT/PARKING MARKS ARE PAINTED ON SURFACE IN THIS AREA. PIC MADE DECISION TO DO A NON-STANDARD RIGHT 180 DEGREE TURN SO AS TO PARK A/C INTO THE STRONG SOUTHERLY WIND. PORT ENGINE HAD BEEN SECURED AFTER LEAVING RUNWAY AS SOP FOR DEPLANING PASSENGER SAFETY. CREW WAS BEING MARSHALLED BY AN FBO EMPLOYEE WHO IS REPORTEDLY NOT TRAINED/QUALIFIED AS A MARSHALLER AND WHO WAS NOT USING LIGHTED WANDS. AS A/C WAS IN THE RIGHT TURN, PIC CREW WAS DISTRACTED BY CONCERN FOR SAFETY OF THE GROUND CREWMAN, AND BY THE NEED TO CLOSELY MONITOR BRAKE PRESSURE GAUGE ON RIGHT SIDE OF COCKPIT. AIRCRAFT WAS TURNING INTO THE OPERATING ENGINE, AND ARC WAS INSUFFICIENT. THE TIP OF PORT WING CONTACTED A CLOSED HANGAR DOOR. THE DAMAGE TO THE HANGAR DOOR WAS MINOR, CONSISTING OF A HORIZONTAL DENT AND ADJACENT PUNCTURE APPROX. 12' X 18'. DAMAGE TO TIP OF LEFT WING APPEARED TO BE SUPERFICIAL. ACCORDING TO A/W INSPECTOR, "DAMAGE INCLUDES LEFT HAND WING TIP AND FORWARD SPAR FROM WINTIP ATTACHMENT TO APPROXIMATELY 12" INBOARD OF WINGTIP. SKIN AND ASSOCIATED PLUMBING FOR FUEL VENT ALSO DAMAGED." THE A/C HAS UNDERGONE A STANDARD REPAIR IAW THE REPAIR MANUAL. NO 337 IS NECESSARY ACCORDING TO THE A/W INSPECTOR AND A LOCAL DER. PIC KRUEGER HAS MAILED PHOTOS OF THE OPEN WING AND DAMAGE DETAIL TO NTSB IN EFFORT TO MAKE THE CASE THAT THIS IS NOT AN ACCIDENT.