20041208030759A

Accident · Substantial damage

FAA accident report · Beech B200 · Tulsa, OK · December 8, 2004

Date
December 8, 2004 · 18:31 local
Place
Tulsa, OK
Airport
Tulsa International
Phase of flight
Forced Landing
Operating rules
General operating rules (Part 91)
Damage
Substantial damage
Aircraft
N6PE
NTSB investigation
NTSBDFW05LA031
Reported as
Beech B200
Fatal injuries
0
Pilot’s flight hours
2,089 total469 in this make and model60 in the last 90 days

From the FAA’s Accident/Incident Data System (AIDS), through its Aviation Safety Information Portal, as reported. The NTSB investigates accidents separately, and its record of an accident is the fuller one. The aircraft is matched to the registry by N-number and event date, checked against the reported make and model; the registry’s history has gaps, so older matches can be wrong. Compare the reported make and model.

What happened

The FAA’s narrative, in sentence case. The FAA writes it in capitals and removes private details.

(-23) On December 8, 2004, at approximately 1831 CST, a BE-200 crashed landed on 86th st. north, 4 miles north of Tulsa International Airport (tul). The pilot had departed lacrosse Wisconsin (lse) at approximately 1605 CST bound for tul. When nearing his destination the pilot contacted tul approach for landing instructions, shortly after that he contacted them again to declare an emergency stating that he had lost both engines. ATC directed the pilot to land on rwy 18L and asked him how many were on board and what was his fuel quantity. The pilot stated one on board and fuel ok, then corrected himself and said fuel empty. Shortly thereafter the pilot decided he could not make it to the airport, he then spotted an east/west road and made a right turn and continued to descend. When nearing the road the right wing contacted power lines and the left wing began to impact tree limbs, shortly after landing with the gear up the aircraft slid with the left engine propeller impacting a tree and the nose impacting an embankment on the south side of the road. The aircraft continued to slide and spin with the right wing also hitting the south embankment. The aircraft came to rest facing north with the nose contacting the embankment on the north side of the road. The engines, propellers, wings and tail were substantially damaged. The tail was mostly separated at the rear bulkhead and the nose had major damage also. The left/right wing inboard main, nacelle, and aux fuel sumps were drained, and it was discovered that the only tank with usable fuel was the left nacelle, it had approx 4 gallons. After reporting the emergency to ATC, the pilot was questioned by ATC as to amount of fuel on board, to which his reply was "its reading empty." Also, it was initially discovered the fuel crossfeed flow switch was in the left position. The aircraft traveled approximately 360 feet from initial contact with the power lines and trees until it came to stop. There was no post impact fire and only very limited traces of fuel could be found at the scene. The pilot was the only one on board and he only sustained minor injuries.

As the FAA filed it

(-23) ON DECEMBER 8, 2004, AT APPROXIMATELY 1831 CST, A BE-200 CRASHED LANDED ON 86TH ST. NORTH, 4 MILES NORTH OF TULSA INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT (TUL). THE PILOT HAD DEPARTED LACROSSE WISCONSIN (LSE) AT APPROXIMATELY 1605 CST BOUND FOR TUL. WHEN NEARING HIS DESTINATION THE PILOT CONTACTED TUL APPROACH FOR LANDING INSTRUCTIONS, SHORTLY AFTER THAT HE CONTACTED THEM AGAIN TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY STATING THAT HE HAD LOST BOTH ENGINES. ATC DIRECTED THE PILOT TO LAND ON RWY 18L AND ASKED HIM HOW MANY WERE ON BOARD AND WHAT WAS HIS FUEL QUANTITY. THE PILOT STATED ONE ON BOARD AND FUEL OK, THEN CORRECTED HIMSELF AND SAID FUEL EMPTY. SHORTLY THEREAFTER THE PILOT DECIDED HE COULD NOT MAKE IT TO THE AIRPORT, HE THEN SPOTTED AN EAST/WEST ROAD AND MADE A RIGHT TURN AND CONTINUED TO DESCEND. WHEN NEARING THE ROAD THE RIGHT WING CONTACTED POWER LINES AND THE LEFT WING BEGAN TO IMPACT TREE LIMBS, SHORTLY AFTER LANDING WITH THE GEAR UP THE AIRCRAFT SLID WITH THE LEFT ENGINE PROPELLER IMPACTING A TREE AND THE NOSE IMPACTING AN EMBANKMENT ON THE SOUTH SIDE OF THE ROAD. THE AIRCRAFT CONTINUED TO SLIDE AND SPIN WITH THE RIGHT WING ALSO HITTING THE SOUTH EMBANKMENT. THE AIRCRAFT CAME TO REST FACING NORTH WITH THE NOSE CONTACTING THE EMBANKMENT ON THE NORTH SIDE OF THE ROAD. THE ENGINES, PROPELLERS, WINGS AND TAIL WERE SUBSTANTIALLY DAMAGED. THE TAIL WAS MOSTLY SEPARATED AT THE REAR BULKHEAD AND THE NOSE HAD MAJOR DAMAGE ALSO. THE LEFT/RIGHT WING INBOARD MAIN, NACELLE, AND AUX FUEL SUMPS WERE DRAINED, AND IT WAS DISCOVERED THAT THE ONLY TANK WITH USABLE FUEL WAS THE LEFT NACELLE, IT HAD APPROX 4 GALLONS. AFTER REPORTING THE EMERGENCY TO ATC, THE PILOT WAS QUESTIONED BY ATC AS TO AMOUNT OF FUEL ON BOARD, TO WHICH HIS REPLY WAS "ITS READING EMPTY." ALSO, IT WAS INITIALLY DISCOVERED THE FUEL CROSSFEED FLOW SWITCH WAS IN THE LEFT POSITION. THE AIRCRAFT TRAVELED APPROXIMATELY 360 FEET FROM INITIAL CONTACT WITH THE POWER LINES AND TREES UNTIL IT CAME TO STOP. THERE WAS NO POST IMPACT FIRE AND ONLY VERY LIMITED TRACES OF FUEL COULD BE FOUND AT THE SCENE. THE PILOT WAS THE ONLY ONE ON BOARD AND HE ONLY SUSTAINED MINOR INJURIES.

NTSB investigation

The NTSB’s investigation of this event, with its probable cause and findings. Matched to this report by N-number and date.