What happened
The FAA’s narrative, in sentence case. The FAA writes it in capitals and removes private details.
Experimental aircraft N524CK was flying back to witham field, stuart, Florida, when he smelled a strong fuel odor, engine sputtered and then stopped. Pilot was unsuccessful in attempts to restart engine and could not make it back to the airport at which point he made the decision to ditch aircraft in shallow water approximately 4.5 feet deep. Aircraft was recovered and engine removed and sent to aircraft manufacturer for inspection and overhaul. Aircraft inspected by FAA certificated a&p/ia after recovery. Suspected fuel pump failure which cannot be confirmed until after manufacturer’s inspection. During recovery inspection, a broken safety wire tab on a header tank fitting and loose nut was discovered. Fuel from main tank is sucked into header tank through two fuel filters and into fuel pump and then pushed to carburetor. An air leak in fitting on this tank would allow the fuel pump to suck air instead of fuel. Owner posted information on yak website to inform all yak operators of possibility of the broken safety wire tabs on header tank which could possibly cause engine failure.
As the FAA filed it
EXPERIMENTAL AIRCRAFT N524CK WAS FLYING BACK TO WITHAM FIELD, STUART, FLORIDA, WHEN HE SMELLED A STRONG FUEL ODOR, ENGINE SPUTTERED AND THEN STOPPED. PILOT WAS UNSUCCESSFUL IN ATTEMPTS TO RESTART ENGINE AND COULD NOT MAKE IT BACK TO THE AIRPORT AT WHICH POINT HE MADE THE DECISION TO DITCH AIRCRAFT IN SHALLOW WATER APPROXIMATELY 4.5 FEET DEEP. AIRCRAFT WAS RECOVERED AND ENGINE REMOVED AND SENT TO AIRCRAFT MANUFACTURER FOR INSPECTION AND OVERHAUL. AIRCRAFT INSPECTED BY FAA CERTIFICATED A&P/IA AFTER RECOVERY. SUSPECTED FUEL PUMP FAILURE WHICH CANNOT BE CONFIRMED UNTIL AFTER MANUFACTURER’S INSPECTION. DURING RECOVERY INSPECTION, A BROKEN SAFETY WIRE TAB ON A HEADER TANK FITTING AND LOOSE NUT WAS DISCOVERED. FUEL FROM MAIN TANK IS SUCKED INTO HEADER TANK THROUGH TWO FUEL FILTERS AND INTO FUEL PUMP AND THEN PUSHED TO CARBURETOR. AN AIR LEAK IN FITTING ON THIS TANK WOULD ALLOW THE FUEL PUMP TO SUCK AIR INSTEAD OF FUEL. OWNER POSTED INFORMATION ON YAK WEBSITE TO INFORM ALL YAK OPERATORS OF POSSIBILITY OF THE BROKEN SAFETY WIRE TABS ON HEADER TANK WHICH COULD POSSIBLY CAUSE ENGINE FAILURE.