What happened
The FAA’s narrative, in sentence case. The FAA writes it in capitals and removes private details.
While cruising at 5,000 ft AGL, 5 miles se of the Guntersville Municipal Airport, the engine quit. The pilot attempted to restart the engine and established a glide in an attempt to make the Guntersville airport. Failing to conduct engine out emergency procedures, the pilot continued to glide towards the Guntersville airport, only to soft land a quarter mile short of runway 21 in Guntersville lake. Aircraft was recovered and had only minor damage. Left fuel cell had 19 gallons of 100LL and right tank, fuel strainer, and carburator were void of fuel. Fuel selector was in the right fuel cell (tank) position.
As the FAA filed it
WHILE CRUISING AT 5,000 FT AGL, 5 MILES SE OF THE GUNTERSVILLE MUNICIPAL AIRPORT, THE ENGINE QUIT. THE PILOT ATTEMPTED TO RESTART THE ENGINE AND ESTABLISHED A GLIDE IN AN ATTEMPT TO MAKE THE GUNTERSVILLE AIRPORT. FAILING TO CONDUCT ENGINE OUT EMERGENCY PROCEDURES, THE PILOT CONTINUED TO GLIDE TOWARDS THE GUNTERSVILLE AIRPORT, ONLY TO SOFT LAND A QUARTER MILE SHORT OF RUNWAY 21 IN GUNTERSVILLE LAKE. AIRCRAFT WAS RECOVERED AND HAD ONLY MINOR DAMAGE. LEFT FUEL CELL HAD 19 GALLONS OF 100LL AND RIGHT TANK, FUEL STRAINER, AND CARBURATOR WERE VOID OF FUEL. FUEL SELECTOR WAS IN THE RIGHT FUEL CELL (TANK) POSITION.