20150307005029A

Accident · Substantial damage

FAA accident report · Schupp Edward W SKY RANGER II · San Manuel, AZ · March 7, 2015

Date
March 7, 2015 · 08:45 local
Place
San Manuel, AZ
Airport
San Manuel
Phase of flight
Landing: Touchdown
Operating rules
General operating rules (Part 91)
Damage
Substantial damage
Aircraft
N132ES
NTSB investigation
NTSBGAA15CA003
Reported as
Schupp Edward W SKY Ranger II
Reported engine
ROTAX SEE BOMBADIER
People aboard
2
Fatal injuries
0
Other injuries
0
Pilot’s certificate
Sport pilot
Pilot’s flight hours
112 total6 in this make and model6 in the last 90 days

From the FAA’s Accident/Incident Data System (AIDS), through its Aviation Safety Information Portal, as reported. The NTSB investigates accidents separately, and its record of an accident is the fuller one. The aircraft is matched to the registry by N-number and event date, checked against the reported make and model; the registry’s history has gaps, so older matches can be wrong. Compare the reported make and model.

What happened

The FAA’s narrative, in sentence case. The FAA writes it in capitals and removes private details.

Received the following written statement from the pilot.

"Concerning the incident about the skyranger ii N132ES. I took off with one other person, [CFI name] my CFI, for training flying my three axis control plane. We were wheels up at 0800. We went to training area with an alt of about 5000FT. We did 360DEG turns both left and right and some slow flight at about 50MPH. Also we flew straight and level most of the time with me flying. Also did hands off with trim and straight and level, all was normal and we went back to E77 ray blair airport to enter down wind for 11 at a 45DEG angle at pattern alt. With normal radio com. Entered base leg I asked if he wanted to land the plane and he said I was doing fine and it was decided I would land, then turned to final. Airspeed was at 63 to 65 mph and a descent at 300 ft per min. Crossed the numbers at 63-65 mph did a normal round out and all was good. I was a little left of center, so I applied some right rudder to center up plane come down bounced and during this time the left landing gear was damaged and front landing gear and prop damaged. As for after I applied right rudder, and it came down, it happened so fast I could not give good details. We came to stop 10 or 15 foot left of the runway. We got out, fuel was turn off and electrical was turned off no one was injured this happed at about 08:45."

Received the following statemenet from the CFI:

"Prior to approach the decision was made to have [student] land the airplane. His control at altitude was the smoothest. The 45 deg. Entry, downwind, base and final were smooth (65 mph and 4400 RPM and 200-300 fpm descent). At about 5 ft. altitude just past the numbers I noticed the nose beginning to yaw slightly to the left. [Student] applied right rudder to correct the yaw but its effect resulted in a large yaw to the right. This was immediately followed by a pio with the nose gear impacting the runway first followed by a hard touchdown by the left main gear. At this point the left wheel assembly failed and the left wheel strut contacted the runway. This brought the nose gear down violently. It failed and lodged beneath the nose resulting in the propeller striking the runway. With the left wheel strut dragging on the runway and the nose gear folded under the nose, the aircraft began a skid to the left and came to a rest off the runway (tail 5-10 feet off the runway) approximately 1000 from the approach end of the runway. At this time we both exited the aircraft unhurt."

As the FAA filed it

RECEIVED THE FOLLOWING WRITTEN STATEMENT FROM THE PILOT.

"CONCERNING THE INCIDENT ABOUT THE SKYRANGER II N132ES. I TOOK OFF WITH ONE OTHER PERSON, [CFI NAME] MY CFI, FOR TRAINING FLYING MY THREE AXIS CONTROL PLANE. WE WERE WHEELS UP AT 0800. WE WENT TO TRAINING AREA WITH AN ALT OF ABOUT 5000FT. WE DID 360DEG TURNS BOTH LEFT AND RIGHT AND SOME SLOW FLIGHT AT ABOUT 50MPH. ALSO WE FLEW STRAIGHT AND LEVEL MOST OF THE TIME WITH ME FLYING. ALSO DID HANDS OFF WITH TRIM AND STRAIGHT AND LEVEL, ALL WAS NORMAL AND WE WENT BACK TO E77 RAY BLAIR AIRPORT TO ENTER DOWN WIND FOR 11 AT A 45DEG ANGLE AT PATTERN ALT. WITH NORMAL RADIO COM. ENTERED BASE LEG I ASKED IF HE WANTED TO LAND THE PLANE AND HE SAID I WAS DOING FINE AND IT WAS DECIDED I WOULD LAND, THEN TURNED TO FINAL. AIRSPEED WAS AT 63 TO 65 MPH AND A DESCENT AT 300 FT PER MIN. CROSSED THE NUMBERS AT 63-65 MPH DID A NORMAL ROUND OUT AND ALL WAS GOOD. I WAS A LITTLE LEFT OF CENTER, SO I APPLIED SOME RIGHT RUDDER TO CENTER UP PLANE COME DOWN BOUNCED AND DURING THIS TIME THE LEFT LANDING GEAR WAS DAMAGED AND FRONT LANDING GEAR AND PROP DAMAGED. AS FOR AFTER I APPLIED RIGHT RUDDER, AND IT CAME DOWN, IT HAPPENED SO FAST I COULD NOT GIVE GOOD DETAILS. WE CAME TO STOP 10 OR 15 FOOT LEFT OF THE RUNWAY. WE GOT OUT, FUEL WAS TURN OFF AND ELECTRICAL WAS TURNED OFF NO ONE WAS INJURED THIS HAPPED AT ABOUT 08:45."

RECEIVED THE FOLLOWING STATEMENET FROM THE CFI:

"PRIOR TO APPROACH THE DECISION WAS MADE TO HAVE [STUDENT] LAND THE AIRPLANE. HIS CONTROL AT ALTITUDE WAS THE SMOOTHEST. THE 45 DEG. ENTRY, DOWNWIND, BASE AND FINAL WERE SMOOTH (65 MPH AND 4400 RPM AND 200-300 FPM DESCENT). AT ABOUT 5 FT. ALTITUDE JUST PAST THE NUMBERS I NOTICED THE NOSE BEGINNING TO YAW SLIGHTLY TO THE LEFT. [STUDENT] APPLIED RIGHT RUDDER TO CORRECT THE YAW BUT ITS EFFECT RESULTED IN A LARGE YAW TO THE RIGHT. THIS WAS IMMEDIATELY FOLLOWED BY A PIO WITH THE NOSE GEAR IMPACTING THE RUNWAY FIRST FOLLOWED BY A HARD TOUCHDOWN BY THE LEFT MAIN GEAR. AT THIS POINT THE LEFT WHEEL ASSEMBLY FAILED AND THE LEFT WHEEL STRUT CONTACTED THE RUNWAY. THIS BROUGHT THE NOSE GEAR DOWN VIOLENTLY. IT FAILED AND LODGED BENEATH THE NOSE RESULTING IN THE PROPELLER STRIKING THE RUNWAY. WITH THE LEFT WHEEL STRUT DRAGGING ON THE RUNWAY AND THE NOSE GEAR FOLDED UNDER THE NOSE, THE AIRCRAFT BEGAN A SKID TO THE LEFT AND CAME TO A REST OFF THE RUNWAY (TAIL 5-10 FEET OFF THE RUNWAY) APPROXIMATELY 1000 FROM THE APPROACH END OF THE RUNWAY. AT THIS TIME WE BOTH EXITED THE AIRCRAFT UNHURT."

NTSB investigation

The NTSB’s investigation of this event, with its probable cause and findings. Matched to this report by N-number and date.