20200820014309A

Accident · Destroyed

FAA accident report · Miller Stuart E LANCAIR SUPER ES · Ely, MN · August 20, 2020

Date
August 20, 2020 · 23:04 local
Place
Ely, MN
Airport
Ely Municipal Airport
Phase of flight
Takeoff: Climb Out
Operating rules
General operating rules (Part 91)
Damage
Destroyed
Aircraft
N997S
NTSB investigation
NTSBCEN20LA354
Reported as
Miller Stuart E Lancair Super ES
Reported engine
Continental IO-550-N
People aboard
1
Fatal injuries
1
Other injuries
0
Pilot’s certificate
Private pilot
Pilot’s flight hours
400 total70 in this make and model

From the FAA’s Accident/Incident Data System (AIDS), through its Aviation Safety Information Portal, as reported. The NTSB investigates accidents separately, and its record of an accident is the fuller one. The aircraft is matched to the registry by N-number and event date, checked against the reported make and model; the registry’s history has gaps, so older matches can be wrong. Compare the reported make and model.

What happened

The FAA’s narrative, in sentence case. The FAA writes it in capitals and removes private details.

2020-08-20, N997S, Lancair Super Es diverted for weather to Ely, MN kelo while attempting to get to grand marais, MN kckc. This was approximately noon, 1200CST. Kckc was socked in all day for low ceilings and fog along the lake superior coast.

The PIC got a vehicle from the kelo FBO and spent the day visiting in Ely. At 1700L he returned to the kelo FBO and asked if he could keep the vehicle. The FBO approved as they were closing and had no need for it. The PIC departed the airport.

The PIC was at a friends house, the friend had stepped out and returned sometime after 2200L to find that the PIC was not there. The metars at desired destination, kckc, showed a lift of the fog and low ceilings just after 2200L (2215L 7SM clear)(2235L 10SM clear). The PIC was airborne from kelo for his 15 min flight to kckc at 2301L. Kelo current METAR was sct 032 bkn 041 TEMP17 DP16. However, within 30 minutes it was BKN007, so weather was deteriorating. There was a valid AIRMET in the area for coastal weather moving inland with IFR, which is in the direction of kelo. It was a dark, no moon night.

N997S took off and climbed heading north 2301 local time. At 1500 ft AGL the aircraft started maneuvering laterally, yet generally moving north. Airspeed then became decreasing, at the final adsb report the aircraft was 1700 ft AGL 57 KTS.

Witness had been sitting on the dock watching the stars for over an hour. At the time they initially heard the aircraft they could no longer see stars due to a cloud layer overhead. The aircraft came out of the clouds, with a steep descent, it's lights and silohouette were visible southeast from the dock. The aircraft then did a steep climb and disappeared into the clouds above. Seconds later the noise was louder and the aircraft appeared to be diving at them on the dock, they thought it was going to hit the water in front of them; it was very loud and pulled up in another steep climb, climbing away from them and back into the clouds. The aircraft came down a final time just south of them, this time it did not pull up, it made a loud noise on impact, and everything instantly became silent. From the first time they heard and saw, the aircraft to the crash was less than 3 minutes. They called 911 at 2306 local time, getting their phones out immediately after witnessing the crash.

The flight path was substantiated with security video.

The aircraft was found in this location, approximately 5 miles north of kelo airport, in white iron lake.

As the FAA filed it

2020-08-20, N997S, LANCAIR SUPER ES DIVERTED FOR WEATHER TO ELY, MN KELO WHILE ATTEMPTING TO GET TO GRAND MARAIS, MN KCKC. THIS WAS APPROXIMATELY NOON, 1200CST. KCKC WAS SOCKED IN ALL DAY FOR LOW CEILINGS AND FOG ALONG THE LAKE SUPERIOR COAST.

THE PIC GOT A VEHICLE FROM THE KELO FBO AND SPENT THE DAY VISITING IN ELY. AT 1700L HE RETURNED TO THE KELO FBO AND ASKED IF HE COULD KEEP THE VEHICLE. THE FBO APPROVED AS THEY WERE CLOSING AND HAD NO NEED FOR IT. THE PIC DEPARTED THE AIRPORT.

THE PIC WAS AT A FRIENDS HOUSE, THE FRIEND HAD STEPPED OUT AND RETURNED SOMETIME AFTER 2200L TO FIND THAT THE PIC WAS NOT THERE. THE METARS AT DESIRED DESTINATION, KCKC, SHOWED A LIFT OF THE FOG AND LOW CEILINGS JUST AFTER 2200L (2215L 7SM CLEAR)(2235L 10SM CLEAR). THE PIC WAS AIRBORNE FROM KELO FOR HIS 15 MIN FLIGHT TO KCKC AT 2301L. KELO CURRENT METAR WAS SCT 032 BKN 041 TEMP17 DP16. HOWEVER, WITHIN 30 MINUTES IT WAS BKN007, SO WEATHER WAS DETERIORATING. THERE WAS A VALID AIRMET IN THE AREA FOR COASTAL WEATHER MOVING INLAND WITH IFR, WHICH IS IN THE DIRECTION OF KELO. IT WAS A DARK, NO MOON NIGHT.

N997S TOOK OFF AND CLIMBED HEADING NORTH 2301 LOCAL TIME. AT 1500 FT AGL THE AIRCRAFT STARTED MANEUVERING LATERALLY, YET GENERALLY MOVING NORTH. AIRSPEED THEN BECAME DECREASING, AT THE FINAL ADSB REPORT THE AIRCRAFT WAS 1700 FT AGL 57 KTS.

WITNESS HAD BEEN SITTING ON THE DOCK WATCHING THE STARS FOR OVER AN HOUR. AT THE TIME THEY INITIALLY HEARD THE AIRCRAFT THEY COULD NO LONGER SEE STARS DUE TO A CLOUD LAYER OVERHEAD. THE AIRCRAFT CAME OUT OF THE CLOUDS, WITH A STEEP DESCENT, IT'S LIGHTS AND SILOHOUETTE WERE VISIBLE SOUTHEAST FROM THE DOCK. THE AIRCRAFT THEN DID A STEEP CLIMB AND DISAPPEARED INTO THE CLOUDS ABOVE. SECONDS LATER THE NOISE WAS LOUDER AND THE AIRCRAFT APPEARED TO BE DIVING AT THEM ON THE DOCK, THEY THOUGHT IT WAS GOING TO HIT THE WATER IN FRONT OF THEM; IT WAS VERY LOUD AND PULLED UP IN ANOTHER STEEP CLIMB, CLIMBING AWAY FROM THEM AND BACK INTO THE CLOUDS. THE AIRCRAFT CAME DOWN A FINAL TIME JUST SOUTH OF THEM, THIS TIME IT DID NOT PULL UP, IT MADE A LOUD NOISE ON IMPACT, AND EVERYTHING INSTANTLY BECAME SILENT. FROM THE FIRST TIME THEY HEARD AND SAW, THE AIRCRAFT TO THE CRASH WAS LESS THAN 3 MINUTES. THEY CALLED 911 AT 2306 LOCAL TIME, GETTING THEIR PHONES OUT IMMEDIATELY AFTER WITNESSING THE CRASH.

THE FLIGHT PATH WAS SUBSTANTIATED WITH SECURITY VIDEO.

THE AIRCRAFT WAS FOUND IN THIS LOCATION, APPROXIMATELY 5 MILES NORTH OF KELO AIRPORT, IN WHITE IRON LAKE.

NTSB investigation

The NTSB’s investigation of this event, with its probable cause and findings. Matched to this report by N-number and date.