20200903017769A

Accident · Substantial damage

FAA accident report · Cessna 170A · Morrisville, VT · September 3, 2020

Date
September 3, 2020 · 11:21 local
Place
Morrisville, VT
Airport
Morrisville-Stowe State Airpor
Phase of flight
Takeoff: Climb Out
Operating rules
General operating rules (Part 91)
Damage
Substantial damage
Aircraft
N170JS
NTSB investigation
NTSBERA20CA307
Reported as
Cessna 170A
Reported engine
Continental C145 series
People aboard
2
Fatal injuries
0
Other injuries
2
Pilot’s certificate
Private pilot
Pilot’s flight hours
2,200 total1,400 in this make and model55 in the last 90 days

From the FAA’s Accident/Incident Data System (AIDS), through its Aviation Safety Information Portal, as reported. The NTSB investigates accidents separately, and its record of an accident is the fuller one. The aircraft is matched to the registry by N-number and event date, checked against the reported make and model; the registry’s history has gaps, so older matches can be wrong. Compare the reported make and model.

What happened

The FAA’s narrative, in sentence case. The FAA writes it in capitals and removes private details.

privacy data omitted Arrived at the Morrisville-Stowe State airport (kmvl) at approximately 1000 hours on 09/03/2020 in a 1950 Cessna 170A N170JS.

The accident flight was preceded by a series of normal takeoffs and landings (touch and goes) on the grass runway adjacent to runway 01/19. The final take-off was to the north. The accident site was between runway 10/19 and the parallel grass runway approximately at the midpoint of runway 01/19.

Video from security camera:

? 11:21:07 N170JS is seen entering the frame in a steep banking left-hand turn

? 11:21:09 N170JS?s left wing impacts the ground while in a steep left-hand turn of approximately 110°

? 11:21:10 N170JS impacts the ground with damage occurring to the cowl, main gear, and cabin section

? 11:21:12 N170JS?s right wing impacts the ground with accompanying fuel burst from left tank rupture

? 11:21:14 N170JS tail comes down on tailwheel on the east side of runway. Empennage does not touch the earth except for tailwheel.

privacy data omitted Statement:

?Last Thursday, I flew to Morrisville airport to help provide demonstration to a friend who had started taking lessons in the 170 with a tailwheel certified instructor. He was having difficulties with take offs and landings and I thought by seeing repetitions of the ?vision? It might be helpful for his next lesson. Winds were light out of the north. I utilized the grass landing area for several take-offs, all without incident. During this particular take off (a short field procedure with two notches of flaps, brakes, aft yoke and full power), after releasing the brakes, the airplane veered toward the ditch in between the grass and the asphalt. I attempted to steer away from the ditch with rudder, but was unable and with the ditch looming ahead and with what I thought was sufficient airspeed I rotated and then stalled to the left.?

N170JS came to rest facing an easterly direction on the west edge of runway 01/19. A significant amount of fuel was leaking from the left tank and from the underside of the engine. Both occupants were initially unresponsive and injured.

The main gear was crushed backwards and the forward section of the fuselage belly dented in. There was rotational damage to the propeller and damage to the engine cowl and compartment. The left wingtip was crumpled up and the root was torn and crumpled. The right wing tip was crumpled down. The aft fuselage area and empennage appeared undamaged.

As the FAA filed it

^PRIVACY DATA OMITTED^ ARRIVED AT THE MORRISVILLE-STOWE STATE AIRPORT (KMVL) AT APPROXIMATELY 1000 HOURS ON 09/03/2020 IN A 1950 CESSNA 170A N170JS.

THE ACCIDENT FLIGHT WAS PRECEDED BY A SERIES OF NORMAL TAKEOFFS AND LANDINGS (TOUCH AND GOES) ON THE GRASS RUNWAY ADJACENT TO RUNWAY 01/19. THE FINAL TAKE-OFF WAS TO THE NORTH. THE ACCIDENT SITE WAS BETWEEN RUNWAY 10/19 AND THE PARALLEL GRASS RUNWAY APPROXIMATELY AT THE MIDPOINT OF RUNWAY 01/19.

VIDEO FROM SECURITY CAMERA:

? 11:21:07 N170JS IS SEEN ENTERING THE FRAME IN A STEEP BANKING LEFT-HAND TURN

? 11:21:09 N170JS?S LEFT WING IMPACTS THE GROUND WHILE IN A STEEP LEFT-HAND TURN OF APPROXIMATELY 110°

? 11:21:10 N170JS IMPACTS THE GROUND WITH DAMAGE OCCURRING TO THE COWL, MAIN GEAR, AND CABIN SECTION

? 11:21:12 N170JS?S RIGHT WING IMPACTS THE GROUND WITH ACCOMPANYING FUEL BURST FROM LEFT TANK RUPTURE

? 11:21:14 N170JS TAIL COMES DOWN ON TAILWHEEL ON THE EAST SIDE OF RUNWAY. EMPENNAGE DOES NOT TOUCH THE EARTH EXCEPT FOR TAILWHEEL.

^PRIVACY DATA OMITTED^ STATEMENT:

?LAST THURSDAY, I FLEW TO MORRISVILLE AIRPORT TO HELP PROVIDE DEMONSTRATION TO A FRIEND WHO HAD STARTED TAKING LESSONS IN THE 170 WITH A TAILWHEEL CERTIFIED INSTRUCTOR. HE WAS HAVING DIFFICULTIES WITH TAKE OFFS AND LANDINGS AND I THOUGHT BY SEEING REPETITIONS OF THE ?VISION? IT MIGHT BE HELPFUL FOR HIS NEXT LESSON. WINDS WERE LIGHT OUT OF THE NORTH. I UTILIZED THE GRASS LANDING AREA FOR SEVERAL TAKE-OFFS, ALL WITHOUT INCIDENT. DURING THIS PARTICULAR TAKE OFF (A SHORT FIELD PROCEDURE WITH TWO NOTCHES OF FLAPS, BRAKES, AFT YOKE AND FULL POWER), AFTER RELEASING THE BRAKES, THE AIRPLANE VEERED TOWARD THE DITCH IN BETWEEN THE GRASS AND THE ASPHALT. I ATTEMPTED TO STEER AWAY FROM THE DITCH WITH RUDDER, BUT WAS UNABLE AND WITH THE DITCH LOOMING AHEAD AND WITH WHAT I THOUGHT WAS SUFFICIENT AIRSPEED I ROTATED AND THEN STALLED TO THE LEFT.?

N170JS CAME TO REST FACING AN EASTERLY DIRECTION ON THE WEST EDGE OF RUNWAY 01/19. A SIGNIFICANT AMOUNT OF FUEL WAS LEAKING FROM THE LEFT TANK AND FROM THE UNDERSIDE OF THE ENGINE. BOTH OCCUPANTS WERE INITIALLY UNRESPONSIVE AND INJURED.

THE MAIN GEAR WAS CRUSHED BACKWARDS AND THE FORWARD SECTION OF THE FUSELAGE BELLY DENTED IN. THERE WAS ROTATIONAL DAMAGE TO THE PROPELLER AND DAMAGE TO THE ENGINE COWL AND COMPARTMENT. THE LEFT WINGTIP WAS CRUMPLED UP AND THE ROOT WAS TORN AND CRUMPLED. THE RIGHT WING TIP WAS CRUMPLED DOWN. THE AFT FUSELAGE AREA AND EMPENNAGE APPEARED UNDAMAGED.

NTSB investigation

The NTSB’s investigation of this event, with its probable cause and findings. Matched to this report by N-number and date.