20220211006499A

Accident · Destroyed

FAA accident report · Mooney M20J · Houston, TX · February 11, 2022

Date
February 11, 2022 · 19:25 local
Place
Houston, TX
Airport
West Houston
Phase of flight
Landing: Approach
Operating rules
General operating rules (Part 91)
Damage
Destroyed
Aircraft
N201VZ
NTSB investigation
NTSBCEN22LA118
Reported as
Mooney M20J
Reported engine
Lycoming IO-360-A3B6
People aboard
2
Fatal injuries
0
Other injuries
2
Pilot’s certificate
Private pilot
Pilot’s flight hours
387 total229 in this make and model24 in the last 90 days

From the FAA’s Accident/Incident Data System (AIDS), through its Aviation Safety Information Portal, as reported. The NTSB investigates accidents separately, and its record of an accident is the fuller one. The aircraft is matched to the registry by N-number and event date, checked against the reported make and model; the registry’s history has gaps, so older matches can be wrong. Compare the reported make and model.

What happened

The FAA’s narrative, in sentence case. The FAA writes it in capitals and removes private details.

On 02/11/2022, pilot departed from castroville, (cvb), TX for destination to West Houston Airport (iws), Texas. While on short final airplane was lined up with rwy 15 at iws, the airplane hit the top of a tree (approximately 45-55 ft tall). The tree was approximately 612 ft from runway 15 threshold. Iaw flightaware ADS-B information the airplane was traveling at approximately between 54-59 KTS. A witness saw the airplane prior to the strike. He saw the airplane going slow and low and tipped the wings left and right as if the pilot saw the tree at the last second. It looks like most likely the pilot pulled up causing the airplane to stall due to the low speed and tree branches slowing down airplane. The left wing went up over and the right wing dipped down to an inverted position and crashed at hole 8 of the golf course, approximately 50 to 75 yards from impacted tree. The right wing leading edge had damage marks from the tree branches. The nose of the airplane and the left wing outer 1/3 of the wing were crushed from initial impact. Flaps were set to 15 degrees. The empennage settled down after initial impact. There were signs of fuel dripping from both tanks as it was venting out. Fuel port covers were not opened due to airplane being up side down. Fuel sample was taken after airplane was flipped upright. Fuel was not contaminated and both tanks had plenty of fuel. There was no post crash fire. The passenger had several fractures in her legs and pelvis, she received two pints of blood before she was air lifted. Pilot had fractures in his lower extremities one was his femur, he received one pint of blood before being airlifted. Both pilot and passenger were airlifted to privacy data omitted. Checked status on 2/14/2022, they were both in icu and intubated. Update of pilot and privacy data omitted, on 5/18/2022-pilot is starting to stand and work on his legs, privacy data omitted-is only feeling her shoulders and head, she is feeling her elbow on the right arm. Examination of N201VZ was conducted by the NTSB on may 4, 2022, at privacy data omitted of dallas, Texas. No evidence of preimpact mechanical malfunction was noted during the examination of recovered airframe and engine. Status update 7/26/2022, pilot is able to walk with cane and still attending physical therapy, privacy data omitted is able to feel down to her fingers but has no feeling from waist down.

As the FAA filed it

ON 02/11/2022, PILOT DEPARTED FROM CASTROVILLE, (CVB), TX FOR DESTINATION TO WEST HOUSTON AIRPORT (IWS), TEXAS. WHILE ON SHORT FINAL AIRPLANE WAS LINED UP WITH RWY 15 AT IWS, THE AIRPLANE HIT THE TOP OF A TREE (APPROXIMATELY 45-55 FT TALL). THE TREE WAS APPROXIMATELY 612 FT FROM RUNWAY 15 THRESHOLD. IAW FLIGHTAWARE ADS-B INFORMATION THE AIRPLANE WAS TRAVELING AT APPROXIMATELY BETWEEN 54-59 KTS. A WITNESS SAW THE AIRPLANE PRIOR TO THE STRIKE. HE SAW THE AIRPLANE GOING SLOW AND LOW AND TIPPED THE WINGS LEFT AND RIGHT AS IF THE PILOT SAW THE TREE AT THE LAST SECOND. IT LOOKS LIKE MOST LIKELY THE PILOT PULLED UP CAUSING THE AIRPLANE TO STALL DUE TO THE LOW SPEED AND TREE BRANCHES SLOWING DOWN AIRPLANE. THE LEFT WING WENT UP OVER AND THE RIGHT WING DIPPED DOWN TO AN INVERTED POSITION AND CRASHED AT HOLE 8 OF THE GOLF COURSE, APPROXIMATELY 50 TO 75 YARDS FROM IMPACTED TREE. THE RIGHT WING LEADING EDGE HAD DAMAGE MARKS FROM THE TREE BRANCHES. THE NOSE OF THE AIRPLANE AND THE LEFT WING OUTER 1/3 OF THE WING WERE CRUSHED FROM INITIAL IMPACT. FLAPS WERE SET TO 15 DEGREES. THE EMPENNAGE SETTLED DOWN AFTER INITIAL IMPACT. THERE WERE SIGNS OF FUEL DRIPPING FROM BOTH TANKS AS IT WAS VENTING OUT. FUEL PORT COVERS WERE NOT OPENED DUE TO AIRPLANE BEING UP SIDE DOWN. FUEL SAMPLE WAS TAKEN AFTER AIRPLANE WAS FLIPPED UPRIGHT. FUEL WAS NOT CONTAMINATED AND BOTH TANKS HAD PLENTY OF FUEL. THERE WAS NO POST CRASH FIRE. THE PASSENGER HAD SEVERAL FRACTURES IN HER LEGS AND PELVIS, SHE RECEIVED TWO PINTS OF BLOOD BEFORE SHE WAS AIR LIFTED. PILOT HAD FRACTURES IN HIS LOWER EXTREMITIES ONE WAS HIS FEMUR, HE RECEIVED ONE PINT OF BLOOD BEFORE BEING AIRLIFTED. BOTH PILOT AND PASSENGER WERE AIRLIFTED TO ^PRIVACY DATA OMITTED^. CHECKED STATUS ON 2/14/2022, THEY WERE BOTH IN ICU AND INTUBATED. UPDATE OF PILOT AND ^PRIVACY DATA OMITTED^, ON 5/18/2022-PILOT IS STARTING TO STAND AND WORK ON HIS LEGS, ^PRIVACY DATA OMITTED^-IS ONLY FEELING HER SHOULDERS AND HEAD, SHE IS FEELING HER ELBOW ON THE RIGHT ARM. EXAMINATION OF N201VZ WAS CONDUCTED BY THE NTSB ON MAY 4, 2022, AT ^PRIVACY DATA OMITTED^ OF DALLAS, TEXAS. NO EVIDENCE OF PREIMPACT MECHANICAL MALFUNCTION WAS NOTED DURING THE EXAMINATION OF RECOVERED AIRFRAME AND ENGINE. STATUS UPDATE 7/26/2022, PILOT IS ABLE TO WALK WITH CANE AND STILL ATTENDING PHYSICAL THERAPY, ^PRIVACY DATA OMITTED^ IS ABLE TO FEEL DOWN TO HER FINGERS BUT HAS NO FEELING FROM WAIST DOWN.

NTSB investigation

The NTSB’s investigation of this event, with its probable cause and findings. Matched to this report by N-number and date.