20220216002079A

Accident · Substantial damage

FAA accident report · Stinson 108-3 · Pahokee, FL · February 16, 2022

Date
February 16, 2022 · 11:18 local
Place
Pahokee, FL
Airport
Pahokee
Phase of flight
Takeoff: Departure Roll
Operating rules
General operating rules (Part 91)
Damage
Substantial damage
Aircraft
N6493M
Reported as
Stinson 108-3
Reported engine
Franklin 6A4165 series
People aboard
2
Fatal injuries
0
Other injuries
0
Pilot’s certificates
Airline transport, flight instructor
Pilot’s flight hours
20,100 total825 in this make and model300 in the last 90 days

From the FAA’s Accident/Incident Data System (AIDS), through its Aviation Safety Information Portal, as reported. The NTSB investigates accidents separately, and its record of an accident is the fuller one. The aircraft is matched to the registry by N-number and event date, checked against the reported make and model; the registry’s history has gaps, so older matches can be wrong. Compare the reported make and model.

What happened

The FAA’s narrative, in sentence case. The FAA writes it in capitals and removes private details.

FAA inspectors statement ? Accident investigation

NTSB # ERA22LA128

Atqa no.: ASO1922029

Registration: N6493M

Sas activity id: SO19202208805

Make: 1948 Stinson

Model: 108-3

Serial number: 108-4493

Annual aircraft/engine/propeller condition inspection:

Most recent annual inspection

Dated 05/20/2021 most recent 100 hour inspections

Dated 05/20/2021

Total time airframe ? 3075.1 hours

Total time engine ? 3075.1 hours

Total time propeller ? 2738.5 (since 5/20/2021)

Total time tbo ? 1432.1 hours total time airframe ? 3075.1 hours

Total time engine ? 3075.1 hours

Total time propeller ? 2738.5 (since 5/20/2021)

When: February 16, 2022 1118 EST

Where: 1948 Stinson 108-3, registration N6493M with two people on board flying, took off from palm beach county glades, Pahokee (phk) airport. Aircraft last track was at 0 feet on a heading of 360° on the west side of runway 36 at palm beach county glades (phk) Pahokee Airport, Florida. The aircraft was found on February 16, 2022 at around 1:00 p.m by inspectors from the south Florida FSDO.

What: part 91 operation, N6493M was operated and flight instruction was provided. The aircraft was operating under VFR departing Pahokee in the grass, west of runway 36.

The following statement from given from the pilot in command / CFI:

During take off, early on the roll, tail began to fly and raise up w/ the assist of fwd elevator prssure. The tail started to settle a little and more fwd pressure was applied, too much. Not sure if brakes were applied by pilot flying. Pilot flying does not recall. Instructor was unable to keep the aircraft from nosing over before the prop tips made contact with the grass. Aircraft was at approximately 25 mph and the fwd momentum raised the tail, tail over nose while the propeller decelerated the aircraft. Pilot flying the aircraft was receiving tailwheel training and was not yet endorsed.

The following statement from given from the pilot receiving instruction:

Taking off rwy 36 in the grass. The aircraft tail lifted off the ground too much. The propeller struck the ground. The airplane flipped over

Onto the wings

During the investigation it was learned that the airman receiving instruction did not have a tailwheel endorsement and was unable to act as pilot in command, hence the reason for instruction.

It is this inspector?s opinion that late, or a lack of instructional intervention from the CFI to the pilot receiving instruction, was not able to provide a timely correction to prevent the aircraft from flipping over its nose and not maintaining proper elevator pressure and application of brakes from pilot flying.

As the FAA filed it

FAA INSPECTORS STATEMENT ? ACCIDENT INVESTIGATION

NTSB # ERA22LA128

ATQA NO.: ASO1922029

REGISTRATION: N6493M

SAS ACTIVITY ID: SO19202208805

MAKE: 1948 STINSON

MODEL: 108-3

SERIAL NUMBER: 108-4493

ANNUAL AIRCRAFT/ENGINE/PROPELLER CONDITION INSPECTION:

MOST RECENT ANNUAL INSPECTION

DATED 05/20/2021 MOST RECENT 100 HOUR INSPECTIONS

DATED 05/20/2021

TOTAL TIME AIRFRAME ? 3075.1 HOURS

TOTAL TIME ENGINE ? 3075.1 HOURS

TOTAL TIME PROPELLER ? 2738.5 (SINCE 5/20/2021)

TOTAL TIME TBO ? 1432.1 HOURS TOTAL TIME AIRFRAME ? 3075.1 HOURS

TOTAL TIME ENGINE ? 3075.1 HOURS

TOTAL TIME PROPELLER ? 2738.5 (SINCE 5/20/2021)

WHEN: FEBRUARY 16, 2022 1118 EST

WHERE: 1948 STINSON 108-3, REGISTRATION N6493M WITH TWO PEOPLE ON BOARD FLYING, TOOK OFF FROM PALM BEACH COUNTY GLADES, PAHOKEE (PHK) AIRPORT. AIRCRAFT LAST TRACK WAS AT 0 FEET ON A HEADING OF 360° ON THE WEST SIDE OF RUNWAY 36 AT PALM BEACH COUNTY GLADES (PHK) PAHOKEE AIRPORT, FLORIDA. THE AIRCRAFT WAS FOUND ON FEBRUARY 16, 2022 AT AROUND 1:00 P.M BY INSPECTORS FROM THE SOUTH FLORIDA FSDO.

WHAT: PART 91 OPERATION, N6493M WAS OPERATED AND FLIGHT INSTRUCTION WAS PROVIDED. THE AIRCRAFT WAS OPERATING UNDER VFR DEPARTING PAHOKEE IN THE GRASS, WEST OF RUNWAY 36.

THE FOLLOWING STATEMENT FROM GIVEN FROM THE PILOT IN COMMAND / CFI:

DURING TAKE OFF, EARLY ON THE ROLL, TAIL BEGAN TO FLY AND RAISE UP W/ THE ASSIST OF FWD ELEVATOR PRSSURE. THE TAIL STARTED TO SETTLE A LITTLE AND MORE FWD PRESSURE WAS APPLIED, TOO MUCH. NOT SURE IF BRAKES WERE APPLIED BY PILOT FLYING. PILOT FLYING DOES NOT RECALL. INSTRUCTOR WAS UNABLE TO KEEP THE AIRCRAFT FROM NOSING OVER BEFORE THE PROP TIPS MADE CONTACT WITH THE GRASS. AIRCRAFT WAS AT APPROXIMATELY 25 MPH AND THE FWD MOMENTUM RAISED THE TAIL, TAIL OVER NOSE WHILE THE PROPELLER DECELERATED THE AIRCRAFT. PILOT FLYING THE AIRCRAFT WAS RECEIVING TAILWHEEL TRAINING AND WAS NOT YET ENDORSED.

THE FOLLOWING STATEMENT FROM GIVEN FROM THE PILOT RECEIVING INSTRUCTION:

TAKING OFF RWY 36 IN THE GRASS. THE AIRCRAFT TAIL LIFTED OFF THE GROUND TOO MUCH. THE PROPELLER STRUCK THE GROUND. THE AIRPLANE FLIPPED OVER

ONTO THE WINGS

DURING THE INVESTIGATION IT WAS LEARNED THAT THE AIRMAN RECEIVING INSTRUCTION DID NOT HAVE A TAILWHEEL ENDORSEMENT AND WAS UNABLE TO ACT AS PILOT IN COMMAND, HENCE THE REASON FOR INSTRUCTION.

IT IS THIS INSPECTOR?S OPINION THAT LATE, OR A LACK OF INSTRUCTIONAL INTERVENTION FROM THE CFI TO THE PILOT RECEIVING INSTRUCTION, WAS NOT ABLE TO PROVIDE A TIMELY CORRECTION TO PREVENT THE AIRCRAFT FROM FLIPPING OVER ITS NOSE AND NOT MAINTAINING PROPER ELEVATOR PRESSURE AND APPLICATION OF BRAKES FROM PILOT FLYING.