20240704021999A

Accident · Substantial damage

FAA accident report · Globe GC-1B · Sherman, TX · July 4, 2024

Date
July 4, 2024 · 19:15 local
Place
Sherman, TX
Airport
Finnlly Airport
Phase of flight
Takeoff: Departure Roll
Operating rules
General operating rules (Part 91)
Damage
Substantial damage
Aircraft
N80740
NTSB investigation
NTSBCEN24LA256
Reported as
Globe GC-1B
Reported engine
Continental C125 series
People aboard
2
Fatal injuries
0
Other injuries
1
Pilot’s certificate
Airline transport
Pilot’s flight hours
17,842 total78 in this make and model

From the FAA’s Accident/Incident Data System (AIDS), through its Aviation Safety Information Portal, as reported. The NTSB investigates accidents separately, and its record of an accident is the fuller one. The aircraft is matched to the registry by N-number and event date, checked against the reported make and model; the registry’s history has gaps, so older matches can be wrong. Compare the reported make and model.

What happened

The FAA’s narrative, in sentence case. The FAA writes it in capitals and removes private details.

T47 aka finney field, is a private airstrip outside Sherman, TX. Property line lays next to hwy 82, which has a slightly higher elevation than the grass runway 36 when departing to the south. This area also has five hangars located on the right side.

There is a dirt road that leads to the hangars from the highway entrance which is approximately 12 feet wide. Centerline of the runway from the edge of the hangar hard top is approximately 61 feet, which includes the dirt road of 12 feet, with the runway itself being approximately 33 feet wide.

On this fourth of July 2024, multiple families were gathered around the hangars grilling and watching fireworks. The pilot has completed multiple take offs and landings that day. On this particular take off, the aircraft had past mid field point and was still accelerating for takeoff. One of the hangars tenants started to move their aircraft to the hangar hard top.

Pilot saw an aircraft being moved by hand by the hangars and as a precaution drifted more to the left side of the runway 36, where there is more grass. This uncalculated maneuver caused the aircraft to slow down, which in turn caused take off speed not to be achieved at the end of the runway. Instead of aborting takeoff, because he had past mid field, the pilot elected to continue thinking that he might can make up lost speed. Then at the end of the runway 36 he was faced with two choices. One, to hit the fence head on while on the ground or two, pull pitch and get air born and try to avoid the fence. With not enough air speed to complete a proper takeoff, the landing gear struck the fence which in turn caused the nose of the aircraft to pitch down and strike the road hwy 82. Aircraft slid on the road to the other side coming to an abrupt stop in the ditch.

As the FAA filed it

T47 AKA FINNEY FIELD, IS A PRIVATE AIRSTRIP OUTSIDE SHERMAN, TX. PROPERTY LINE LAYS NEXT TO HWY 82, WHICH HAS A SLIGHTLY HIGHER ELEVATION THAN THE GRASS RUNWAY 36 WHEN DEPARTING TO THE SOUTH. THIS AREA ALSO HAS FIVE HANGARS LOCATED ON THE RIGHT SIDE.

THERE IS A DIRT ROAD THAT LEADS TO THE HANGARS FROM THE HIGHWAY ENTRANCE WHICH IS APPROXIMATELY 12 FEET WIDE. CENTERLINE OF THE RUNWAY FROM THE EDGE OF THE HANGAR HARD TOP IS APPROXIMATELY 61 FEET, WHICH INCLUDES THE DIRT ROAD OF 12 FEET, WITH THE RUNWAY ITSELF BEING APPROXIMATELY 33 FEET WIDE.

ON THIS FOURTH OF JULY 2024, MULTIPLE FAMILIES WERE GATHERED AROUND THE HANGARS GRILLING AND WATCHING FIREWORKS. THE PILOT HAS COMPLETED MULTIPLE TAKE OFFS AND LANDINGS THAT DAY. ON THIS PARTICULAR TAKE OFF, THE AIRCRAFT HAD PAST MID FIELD POINT AND WAS STILL ACCELERATING FOR TAKEOFF. ONE OF THE HANGARS TENANTS STARTED TO MOVE THEIR AIRCRAFT TO THE HANGAR HARD TOP.

PILOT SAW AN AIRCRAFT BEING MOVED BY HAND BY THE HANGARS AND AS A PRECAUTION DRIFTED MORE TO THE LEFT SIDE OF THE RUNWAY 36, WHERE THERE IS MORE GRASS. THIS UNCALCULATED MANEUVER CAUSED THE AIRCRAFT TO SLOW DOWN, WHICH IN TURN CAUSED TAKE OFF SPEED NOT TO BE ACHIEVED AT THE END OF THE RUNWAY. INSTEAD OF ABORTING TAKEOFF, BECAUSE HE HAD PAST MID FIELD, THE PILOT ELECTED TO CONTINUE THINKING THAT HE MIGHT CAN MAKE UP LOST SPEED. THEN AT THE END OF THE RUNWAY 36 HE WAS FACED WITH TWO CHOICES. ONE, TO HIT THE FENCE HEAD ON WHILE ON THE GROUND OR TWO, PULL PITCH AND GET AIR BORN AND TRY TO AVOID THE FENCE. WITH NOT ENOUGH AIR SPEED TO COMPLETE A PROPER TAKEOFF, THE LANDING GEAR STRUCK THE FENCE WHICH IN TURN CAUSED THE NOSE OF THE AIRCRAFT TO PITCH DOWN AND STRIKE THE ROAD HWY 82. AIRCRAFT SLID ON THE ROAD TO THE OTHER SIDE COMING TO AN ABRUPT STOP IN THE DITCH.

NTSB investigation

The NTSB’s investigation of this event, with its probable cause and findings. Matched to this report by N-number and date.