20260909013199I

Incident · Minor damage

FAA incident report · Piper PA-32RT-300 · Tiffin, OH · September 9, 2026

Date
September 9, 2026 · 09:30 local
Place
Tiffin, OH
Airport
Seneca County
Phase of flight
Landing: Approach
Operating rules
General operating rules (Part 91)
Damage
Minor damage
Aircraft
N2217E
Reported as
Piper PA-32RT-300
Reported engine
Lycoming IO-540 series
People aboard
2
Fatal injuries
0
Other injuries
0
Pilot’s certificate
Commercial pilot
Pilot’s flight hours
5,500 total

From the FAA’s Accident/Incident Data System (AIDS), through its Aviation Safety Information Portal, as reported. The NTSB investigates accidents separately, and its record of an accident is the fuller one. The aircraft is matched to the registry by N-number and event date, checked against the reported make and model; the registry’s history has gaps, so older matches can be wrong. Compare the reported make and model.

What happened

The FAA’s narrative, in sentence case. The FAA writes it in capitals and removes private details.

The pilot in command (PIC) of the aircraft and maintenance service manager departed runway 24 on a routine return to service flight after completion of an annual inspection. Prior to departure they confirmed all documentation was satisfactory, briefed with the mechanics, and performed a detailed pre-flight. After rotation the pilot climbed to 5,500 feet MSL to perform the necessary air work. Maintenance service manager had the checklist and confirming numbers, temps, etc. During the flight. Upon reaching altitude the pilot slowed to confirm the gear horn was operating correctly, and the auto gear deploy was operating. During this inspection the pilot was able to receive (2) green landing gear lights (both the mains) and unable to get the nose to drop. At this point they assumed the nose gear down spring needed adjustment, and they would have this looked at once on the ground. The pilot performed an emergency gear extend with the same results. Again (2) green, the mains and no nose light. The assumption had not changed, and they believe this to be the gear spring and adjustment needed to be made. The pilot continued the test flight with no issues and entered the downwind leg for landing. When selecting gear down there were (2) green main landing gear lights and no nose light. They could hear the hydraulic pump continuing to run and never received the green nose gear light, and the gear unsafe light never went out. In fear of damaging the pump, the pilot selected gear up and gained a safe altitude to see if the pilot could yaw, shake, rattle, etc. To get the nose to drop which did not work.

The pilot radioed the office through the UNICOM frequency (123.00) and communicated with the ground crew to confirm whether they did or did not see a nose gear when performing a low pass. They informed the pilot that the gear was sagging and not extended. The pilot circled and attempted to bounce the aircraft on the runway using the mains to see if the pilot could knock the nose gear free. This did not work, and the pilot radioed for emergency personnel to be called and stand by.

The pilot circled the field and waited for the okay from the crew on the ground. At approximately 9:20 a.m. local the pilot landed with gear down selected (2) green , both the mains and no green nose light. Prior to touch down, the engine was shut down with mixture cut off, and the fuel selector was moved to the off position. The pilot held the nose up as long as possible until the aircraft fell just shy of the taxiway turn off on runway 24. Exited the aircraft unharmed with minor damage to the airframe and significant damage to the propeller.

As the FAA filed it

THE PILOT IN COMMAND (PIC) OF THE AIRCRAFT AND MAINTENANCE SERVICE MANAGER DEPARTED RUNWAY 24 ON A ROUTINE RETURN TO SERVICE FLIGHT AFTER COMPLETION OF AN ANNUAL INSPECTION. PRIOR TO DEPARTURE THEY CONFIRMED ALL DOCUMENTATION WAS SATISFACTORY, BRIEFED WITH THE MECHANICS, AND PERFORMED A DETAILED PRE-FLIGHT. AFTER ROTATION THE PILOT CLIMBED TO 5,500 FEET MSL TO PERFORM THE NECESSARY AIR WORK. MAINTENANCE SERVICE MANAGER HAD THE CHECKLIST AND CONFIRMING NUMBERS, TEMPS, ETC. DURING THE FLIGHT. UPON REACHING ALTITUDE THE PILOT SLOWED TO CONFIRM THE GEAR HORN WAS OPERATING CORRECTLY, AND THE AUTO GEAR DEPLOY WAS OPERATING. DURING THIS INSPECTION THE PILOT WAS ABLE TO RECEIVE (2) GREEN LANDING GEAR LIGHTS (BOTH THE MAINS) AND UNABLE TO GET THE NOSE TO DROP. AT THIS POINT THEY ASSUMED THE NOSE GEAR DOWN SPRING NEEDED ADJUSTMENT, AND THEY WOULD HAVE THIS LOOKED AT ONCE ON THE GROUND. THE PILOT PERFORMED AN EMERGENCY GEAR EXTEND WITH THE SAME RESULTS. AGAIN (2) GREEN, THE MAINS AND NO NOSE LIGHT. THE ASSUMPTION HAD NOT CHANGED, AND THEY BELIEVE THIS TO BE THE GEAR SPRING AND ADJUSTMENT NEEDED TO BE MADE. THE PILOT CONTINUED THE TEST FLIGHT WITH NO ISSUES AND ENTERED THE DOWNWIND LEG FOR LANDING. WHEN SELECTING GEAR DOWN THERE WERE (2) GREEN MAIN LANDING GEAR LIGHTS AND NO NOSE LIGHT. THEY COULD HEAR THE HYDRAULIC PUMP CONTINUING TO RUN AND NEVER RECEIVED THE GREEN NOSE GEAR LIGHT, AND THE GEAR UNSAFE LIGHT NEVER WENT OUT. IN FEAR OF DAMAGING THE PUMP, THE PILOT SELECTED GEAR UP AND GAINED A SAFE ALTITUDE TO SEE IF THE PILOT COULD YAW, SHAKE, RATTLE, ETC. TO GET THE NOSE TO DROP WHICH DID NOT WORK.

THE PILOT RADIOED THE OFFICE THROUGH THE UNICOM FREQUENCY (123.00) AND COMMUNICATED WITH THE GROUND CREW TO CONFIRM WHETHER THEY DID OR DID NOT SEE A NOSE GEAR WHEN PERFORMING A LOW PASS. THEY INFORMED THE PILOT THAT THE GEAR WAS SAGGING AND NOT EXTENDED. THE PILOT CIRCLED AND ATTEMPTED TO BOUNCE THE AIRCRAFT ON THE RUNWAY USING THE MAINS TO SEE IF THE PILOT COULD KNOCK THE NOSE GEAR FREE. THIS DID NOT WORK, AND THE PILOT RADIOED FOR EMERGENCY PERSONNEL TO BE CALLED AND STAND BY.

THE PILOT CIRCLED THE FIELD AND WAITED FOR THE OKAY FROM THE CREW ON THE GROUND. AT APPROXIMATELY 9:20 A.M. LOCAL THE PILOT LANDED WITH GEAR DOWN SELECTED (2) GREEN , BOTH THE MAINS AND NO GREEN NOSE LIGHT. PRIOR TO TOUCH DOWN, THE ENGINE WAS SHUT DOWN WITH MIXTURE CUT OFF, AND THE FUEL SELECTOR WAS MOVED TO THE OFF POSITION. THE PILOT HELD THE NOSE UP AS LONG AS POSSIBLE UNTIL THE AIRCRAFT FELL JUST SHY OF THE TAXIWAY TURN OFF ON RUNWAY 24. EXITED THE AIRCRAFT UNHARMED WITH MINOR DAMAGE TO THE AIRFRAME AND SIGNIFICANT DAMAGE TO THE PROPELLER.