MIA96FA051

The flight was cleared for the VOR/DME approach to runway 17 at the Marco Island Airport. The CVR recorded conversation between the pilot and co-pilot reference to the approach, specifically the MDA both in mean sea level and absolute altitude for a straight-in-approach to runway 17. The flight crew announced that the flight was landing on runway 35. The flight crew did not discuss the missed approach procedure nor the circling minimums. The flight continued and the co-pilot announced that the flight was 5 miles from the airport to descend to the MDA to visually acquire the airport. While descending about 8.5 feet of the left wing of the airplane was severed by a guy wire about 587 feet above ground level from an antenna that was 3.36 nautical miles from the threshold of runway 17. The tower is listed on the approach chart that was provided to the flight crew. The airplane then rolled left wing low, recovered to wings level, then was observed to roll to the left, pitch nose down, and impacted the ground. A fireball was then observed by witnesses. The altimeters, air data computer, and pilot's airspeed indicator were last calibrated about 8 months before the accident. The co-pilots altimeter was found set .01 high from the last known altimeter setting provided to the flight crew. The CVR did not record any conversation pertaining to failure or malfunction of either the pilot or co-pilot's HSI, the DME or Altimeters. There were no alarms from the VOR/DME monitoring equipment the day of the accident. The flight crew of another airplane executed the same approach about 30 minutes before the accident and they reported no discrepancies with the approach. The MDA for the segment of the approach between where the tower is located is no lower than 974 feet above ground level.

History of flight

On December 31, 1995, about 1225 eastern standard time, a Cessna 550, N91MJ, registered to and operated by Moran Foods, Inc., collided with a guy wire from an antenna then collided with the ground near East Naples, Florida. Instrument meteorological conditions prevailed at the time and an IFR flight plan was filed for the 14 CFR Part 91 corporate flight. The airplane was destroyed and the airline transport-rated pilot and copilot were fatally injured. The flight originated about 0824 central standard time from the St. Louis Downtown-Parks Airport, Cahokia/St. Louis, Illinois.

The flight from St. Louis to the descent while in range was uneventful. There were no reported discrepancies of altitudes or headings flown as requested by Air Traffic Control (ATC) facilities during the flight.

Readout of the aircraft cockpit voice recorder (CVR) revealed that at 1156.45, the flightcrew monitored the Naples Airport, Airport Terminal Information Service (ATIS).

At 1206.16, the copilot contacted Fort Myers Approach Control and the flightcrew was given the altimeter setting of 30.00 inHg and told to expect the VOR runway 17 approach to the Marco Island Airport. The copilot acknowledged this then stated, "one forty eights inbound, huh" and the pilot-in-command responded in the affirmative. At 1206.53, the CVR recorded the copilot to state "three fifty four on your doohickey over there." The flightcrew was later advised to descend to 7,000 and at 1209.29, the CVR recorded the copilot to state, "obviously try to land to the north if we can." The flight was later cleared to descend to 5,000 feet and to contact approach control on a different frequency. The copilot contacted the approach controller on the new frequency and at 1214.30, the controller advised the flightcrew to expect the VOR/DME approach to runway 17. The copilot acknowledged this.

At 1218.29, the copilot stated "got a capture" and at 1219.55, 5 minutes 25 seconds after the controller advised the flightcrew to expect the VOR approach, the CVR recorded the PIC to ask what the MDA for the approach was. The copilot stated "...three sixty." The copilot then stated "two thousand till established and once you pass the VOR you can come down to 1,600 maintain (to or possible for) 5 miles thence" and the PIC responded "down to three." At 1220.34, the copilot stated "after five miles come down" and the PIC stated "three sixty." The PIC then asked the copilot to contact the approach controller to inquire if the flight was cleared for the approach and the controller stated in part, "...very shortly." At 1221.41, the copilot stated "it, its more than five miles and it will be down to nine eighty."

At about 1221.51, the approach controller advised the flightcrew that the flight was 4 miles from TIOFF, maintain 1,600 until established final approach course, cleared for the VOR/DME runway 17 approach Marco Island. The copilot acknowledged the approach clearance with the approach controller and about 4 seconds later the PIC requested approach flaps. The copilot then stated "looks like we need about 10 right" followed by "one down at nine eighty" with a sound one second later similar to the altitude alert signal. At 1223.15, the flightcrew was advised that radar service was terminated and to contact to the airport advisory frequency which the copilot acknowledged. About 3 seconds later the co-pilot advised on the Marco Island Airport Common Traffic Frequency (CTAF) that the flight was "6 north inbound on the approach will be landing on runway 35. At 1223.34, the copilot stated "yeah you otta be in good shape if you don't mind sneaking around a little bit yeah within 5 miles of the airport there you can come on down to three sixty." At 1223.57, the copilot stated "ah the airports a little bit to your left" then "about ten left looks like about one fifty five heading will take you right to it four miles out get her right down so we can sees it." The copilot then stated "three miles" and 4 seconds later, a sound of impact was heard. Conversation between the flightcrew about controlling the airplane occurred and at 1224.39, the copilot stated "...gotta find somewhere to land this keep the power in" to which the PIC responded "I got it." At 1224. 54, the PIC stated "one hundred thirty knots" and at 1225.04, the copilot stated "its dropping on you Hal." There was no further pertinent conversation from the flightcrew and at no time during the time recorded by the CVR did they report seeing the ground. Further review of the CVR that stopped recording at 1225.07 hours revealed that the flightcrew did not discuss the missed approach procedure, nor the MDA and visibility minimums for a circle to land approach.

Numerous witnesses on the ground near the tower reported that the top of the tower was obscured by clouds and the airplane was observed to descend below the base of the clouds then collided with a guy wire of the antenna. A section of the airplane was observed to fall to the ground and the airplane rolled to left nearly inverted then rolled wings level while descending flying in an easterly direction. Witnesses closer to the accident site observed the airplane roll to the left, pitch nose down, then impact the ground and a fireball was observed.

Personnel information

Both pilots were issued an Airline-Transport Pilot certificate with a type rating in Cessna 500 aircraft. The first pilot's name was listed as the pilot in the IFR flight plan. Review of his pilot logbook revealed that he had logged 11.7 hours actual instrument time with corresponding 15 instrument approaches during the preceding 6 months all in the airplane category. During the preceding 90 days he logged eight takeoff's and landings in the accident airplane and he was given a checkride in accordance with 14 CFR Part 135.297 and 135.299 on October 26, 1995. On March 2, 1994, he was also given a checkride in a Cessna 501 airplane. Additional information pertaining to the first pilot may be obtained in the NTSB Factual Report on page 3.

Review of the second pilot's logbook revealed that he had logged about 93 hours within the preceding 90 days of which about 68 hours were in the accident airplane. During that same time he logged about 17 hours actual instrument time and 17 instrument approaches. Also during that time he logged 61 hours as pilot-in-command and last attended Flight Safety on January 12-14, 1995, for recurrent Citation II flight training. Additional information pertaining to the second pilot may be found the NTSB Supplement E.

Aircraft information

Review of the maintenance records revealed that both altimeters, the air data computer, and the pilot's airspeed indicator were calibrated and leak checked on April 10, 1995. Additionally, the last recorded VOR test was performed on September 14, 1995.

Meteorological information

The Naples Airport ATIS "Q" that was monitored by the flightcrew before initiating the approach indicated that the recorded ceiling at 1155 was measured one thousand two hundred broken, with 6 miles of visibility in fog. The wind was from 150 degrees at 8 knots and the altimeter was 30.00 inHg. The Naples Airport is located about 11 nautical miles and 331 degrees magnetic from the Marco Island Airport.

According to the office assistant at the Marco Island Airport who was monitoring the CTAF at the time of the accident, one flightcrew member of the accident airplane reported that the flight was inbound to runway 35. The assistant broadcast to the flightcrew that runway 17 was the active but there was no response. The flightcrew member did not ask for the wind or altimeter setting. The flightcrew of an another airplane that landed at the Marco Island Airport about 30 minutes before the accident reported executing the VOR/DME approach to runway 17. They did not