Service difficulty report · Piston Ring · Piper PA28151

Difficulty date
February 14, 2005
Submitted
March 25, 2005
Operation
General aviation
Aircraft
N4238F
Make and model
Piper PA28151
Aircraft serial
287715010
Engine
Lyc O320D3G
Part
Piston Ring
Part number
SL3601SC
Condition
Failed
Location
Engine
Stage of operation
IN
How discovered
9
Nature of condition
W
Precautionary procedure
K

As reported to the FAA. Reports are unverified, and codes are left as the FAA publishes them.

What was found

OUT OF CONCERN FROM HAVING 2 PREVIOUS OIL RING FAILURES THAT COULD HAVE BROUGHT ME DOWN. PULLED CYLINDER NR 1 AND NR 2 TO REPLACE RING WITH SAME PRODUCTION DATE AS ONE THAT FAILED. PULLING AND INSPECTING NR 1, FOUND THE RING GAP TO BE EXCESSIVE, MFG CALLS FOR .0015 TO .0030. , SEEMS LIKE A LOT OF WEAR IN TOO SHORT OF PERIOD. HAD RINGS FROM CYLINDERS NR 1, 2, 4 SENT TO REPAIR STATION TO CHECK FOR HARDNESS OF RINGS. RING NR 1 CYLINDER WAS 1.5 ON C SCALE ROCKWELL MACHINE, NR2 WAS A 2.0 ON SAME SCALE. CYL NR 4 (RING IN 3 PIECES) LARGE PART OF RING WAS BETWEEN 1.5 AND 2, 2ND PIECE WAS A 5.5, 3RD PIECE WAS 3.5. MAN DATE 10-1-2002. SENT MFG BAD RINGS, SENT NEW RINGS AND OLD RINGS BACK WITH COMMENT. (K)

More about the Piper PA-28-151