Service difficulty report · Structure · Gulstm GVSPG550

Difficulty date
July 23, 2009
Submitted
July 24, 2009
Operation
General aviation
Make and model
Gulstm GVSPG550
Part
Structure
Condition
Debonded
Location
E/E Rack
Stage of operation
LD
How discovered
O
Nature of condition
G, B, S
Precautionary procedure
O

As reported to the FAA. Reports are unverified, and codes are left as the FAA publishes them.

What was found

2 FWD ELECTRICAL RACKS ON THE ACFT ARE VERY UNSAFE DURING A 9G FWD EMERGENCY LANDING. THE ANALYSIS FOR THE CERTIFICATION IS INADEQUATE. STRUCTURE CANNOT SUSTAIN THE IMPACT LOAD OF ELECTRICAL EQUIPMENT AND HONEYCOMB WILL DEBOND. DEFLECTION ON HONEYCOMB PANELS OF THE ELECTRICAL WILL BE MORE THAN THE GAP BETWEEN ELECTRICAL RACKS AND PILOT SEATS, RESULTING IN SEVERE INJURY TO BOTH PILOTS. MFG IS AWARE OF THESE DEFECTS, BUT IS UNWILLING TO TAKE NECESSARY STEPS TO CHANGE DESIGN, BECAUSE OF FINANCIAL REASONS. SUBSEQUENT ANALYSIS USING COMPUTER SIMULATION HAVE DEMONSTRATED THAT 2 FWD ELECTRICAL RACKS CANNOT SUSTAIN 9G FWD EMERGENCY LANDING. FASTENERS IN THE ELECTRICAL RACKS ARE INSTALLED IN THE SIDE OF THE HONEYCOMB (XY DIRECTION) INSTEAD OF NORMAL Z-DIRECTION (THE FASTENER NORMAL Z-DIRECTION IS PARALLEL TO THE XY-DIRECTION OF THE HONEYCOMB). DUE TO THE REPEATED LOADING THE AL SKIN WILL DEBOND FROM THE HONEYCOMB (STRUCTURAL FAILURE OF THE ELECTRICAL RACKS).