Service difficulty report · Muffler · Piper PA44180

Difficulty date
March 3, 2010
Submitted
April 2, 2010
Operation
General aviation
Aircraft
N577ER
Make and model
Piper PA44180
Aircraft serial
4496153
Engine
Lyc LO360A1H6
Propeller
Hartzl HCC2YR2
Part
Muffler
Part number
86299007
Condition
Cracked
Location
Rt Engine
Stage of operation
IN
How discovered
V
Nature of condition
O
Precautionary procedure
K

As reported to the FAA. Reports are unverified, and codes are left as the FAA publishes them.

What was found

UPON PREFLIGHT INSP, THE RT ENG AFT MUFFLER WAS FOUND TO BE MISSING THE TAIL/EXIT PIPE SECTION. THE MUFFLER HAD BEEN ON THE ENG FOR ONLY 350 HRS TIS. UPON INSP, THE MUFFLER WAS NOTICED TO HAVE SOME CAN AREA CHAFING MARKS ON IT. ANALYSIS WAS DONE ON THIS MUFFLER PLUS A COUPLE OTHERS THAT WERE REMOVED FOR REPAIR, THE ANALYSIS SHOWED THAT THE CHAFED AREA ON THE MUFFLER CAN HAD WORN INTO THE METAL SURFACE. THIS HAD CAUSED SOME METAL FATIGUE LEADING TO VERY SMALL CRACKS ON ALL THE MUFFLERS THAT WERE ANALYZED. THE PROBLEM STEMS FROM THE FWD AND AFT MUFFLERS CHAFING ON EACH OTHER BETWEEN EACH UNIT AND WEARING/FATIGUING THE METAL. THE PROBLEM IS THAT THE MUFFLERS ON HAVE ABOUT .2500 INCH CLEARANCE BETWEEN THE 2 UNITS ON AVERAGE WHEN THEY ARE COLD BUT PROBABLY EXPAND ENOUGH WHEN HOT TO CAUSE CONTACT IN FLIGHT. MUFFLERS NEED TO BE NARROWED OR THE RISER DESIGN CHANGED TO ALLOW MORE CLEARANCE BETWEEN THE UNITS. ALSO, A 4 CYLINDER INTO 1 SINGLE MUFFLER DESIGN WOULD WORK EVEN BETTER.

More about the Piper PA-44-180