Service difficulty report · Switch · Beech 58

Difficulty date
July 22, 2010
Submitted
August 17, 2010
Operation
General aviation
Aircraft
N3214H
Make and model
Beech 58
Aircraft serial
TH1731
Aircraft time
9,365 hours
Engine
Cont IO550C
Part
Switch
Part number
35380132103
Condition
Burned
Location
Zone 100
Part time
1,486 hours
Stage of operation
TX
How discovered
O
Nature of condition
M, B
Precautionary procedure
O

As reported to the FAA. Reports are unverified, and codes are left as the FAA publishes them.

What was found

THE ACFT LANDING LIGHT SWITCH WAS OBSERVED TO BE HOT AND EMITTING SMOKE. SWITCH IS POST AD 2008-13-17. THESE SWITCHES ARE THE SAME AS ORIGINAL WITH ADDITION OF AN INSULATOR THAT PREVENTS A FAILED "OPEN" SWITCH FROM CONDUCTING CURRENT THROUGH THE POINTS HOLD OPEN SPRING THAT THEN BEGINS TO OVERHEAT AND BURN. APPARENTLY, THIS FAILED SWITCH HAD A MFG DEFECT THAT ALLOWED CURRENT TO FLOW THROUGH THIS SPRING. AN INTERNAL INSPECTION OF THE SWITCH WAS INCONCLUSIVE AS TO THE INSTALLATION OR PLACEMENT OF THE INSULATOR PADS DUE TO THE DAMAGE SUSTAINED DURING THE OVERHEAT EVENT. IN A 10 MONTH PERIOD, A FLEET OF 12 ACFT HAS REQUIRED REPLACEMENT OF 21 OF THESE SWITCHES. THE FAILURES HAVE BEEN LIMITED TO THE LANDING AND TAXI LIGHT CIRCUITS. FORTUNATELY, ALL EXCEPT THIS ONE HAVE FAILED IN THE OPEN CONDITION WITH NO INDICATION OF SMOKE OR BURNING. ALL SWITCHES THAT HAVE BEEN OPENED FOR INSPECTION FAIL WHERE THE COPPER BRAID FROM THE POINTS IS ATTACHED TO THE SWITCH FRAME. MFG LISTS THIS SWITCH AS BEING RATED FOR 10,000 MECHANICAL CYCLES BUT EVEN ACCOUNTING FOR UNUSUALLY HEAVY FLEET USAGE, THE FAILURE RATE SEEMS TO BE NO MORE THAN 4000 CYCLES. MUCH HAS BEEN MADE OF THE OVERKILL OF AD 2008-13-17, BUT UNTIL YOUR FLYING IFR AT NIGHT WITH A CIRCUIT THAT IS OVERHEATING AND BURNING WITH NO MEANS OTHER THAN THE MASTERSWITCH TO SHUT IT DOWN, SUDDENLY A GLOWING HOT SWITCH BECOMES MUCH MORE THAN AN INCONVENIENCE. FINAL RESOLUTION OF THIS ISSUE APPEARS TO STILL BE ALLUSIVE.

More about the Beech 58