Service difficulty report · Oil Cooler · Beech A36

Difficulty date
January 20, 2011
Submitted
January 27, 2011
Operation
General aviation
Aircraft
N315W
Make and model
Beech A36
Aircraft serial
E3515
Aircraft time
2,364 hours
Engine
Cont IO550B
Engine time
694 hours
Part
Oil Cooler
Part number
635996
Part serial
J06495247
Condition
Cracked
Location
Engine
Part time
696 hours
Stage of operation
IN
How discovered
V
Nature of condition
K
Precautionary procedure
K

As reported to the FAA. Reports are unverified, and codes are left as the FAA publishes them.

What was found

AFTER AN OIL CHANGE, THE CUSTOMER COMPLAINED OF OIL ON TOP OF THE NOSE GEAR WELL AREA BEHIND & BELOW ENGINE. ENGINE COMPARTMENT CLEANED, GROUND RUN & ENGINE COMPARTMENT INSPECTED FOR LEAKS. NONE NOTED. CUSTOMER CONTACTED SHOP THE FOLLOWING WEEK AFTER FLYING OVER WEEKEND WITH SAME COMPLAINT. ENGINE COMPARTMENT CLEANED AGAIN & PILOT INSTRUCTED TO FLY THE PLANE JUST AROUND PATTERN & RETURN TO SHOP. A FEW DROPS OF FRESH OIL NOTED. AN OIL HOSE REMOVED TO INSPECT OIL COOLER WHERE IT IS BOLTED TO ENGINE CORE. THERE APPEARED TO BE A SMALL CRACK IN THIS AREA AROUND AFT LOWER MOUNTING BOLT HOLE. COOLER REMOVED & A MUCH LARGER CRACK WAS DISCOVERED THAT COULD NOT BE SEEN AS MOUNTED TO ENGINE. IT APPEARS TO THIS INSPECTING MECHANIC THAT THE COOLER COULD HAVE DEVELOPED THE CRACK IN ONE OF TWO WAYS. THERE COULD HAVE BEEN A CASTING FLAW IN THE METAL AT THE TIME OF MFG OR O/H. ALSO DISCOVERED A WAY TO CREATE STRESS IN THIS AREA AT THE TIME OF INSTALLATION. IF THE BOTTOM THREE MOUNTING NUTS ARE TIGHTENED ON THE STUDS BEFORE THE TOP TWO ARE FULLY INSTALLED, THE TOP NUTS WILL BOTTOM OUT ON THE MOUNTING FLANGE AND CREATE A BENDING MOTION AT THE BOTTOM OF THE COOLER IN THE AREA OF THE DISCOVERED CRACK. CARE SHOULD BE TAKEN DURING INSTALLATION TO TURN THE TOP NUTS ALL THE WAY DOWN BEFORE THE BOTTOM ONES.

More about the Beech A36