Service difficulty report · Landing Gear · Stnson V77

Difficulty date
September 3, 2011
Submitted
October 4, 2011
Operation
General aviation
Aircraft
N9112H
Make and model
Stnson V77
Aircraft serial
77311
Aircraft time
1,440 hours
Part
Landing Gear
Condition
Collapsed
Part time
1,440 hours
Stage of operation
TX
How discovered
O
Nature of condition
O
Precautionary procedure
O

As reported to the FAA. Reports are unverified, and codes are left as the FAA publishes them.

What was found

ACFT WAS TAXIING OUT FOR TAKEOFF WHEN GUST OF WIND FROM LT REAR AT ABOUT 15 KNOTS CAUGHT TAIL AND SPUN AIRPLANE IN HARD GROUND LOOP TO LT. RT LANDING GEAR COLLAPSED COMPLETELY CAUSING SUBSTANTIAL DAMAGE TO ACFT. FOLLOW UP TO ACCIDENT FOUND WELDED STEEL TUBING NEAR RT GEAR ATTACH POINTS WAS HEAVILY CORRODED AND TUBING CLUSTER WELDS BROKE CLEANLY AT WELD LINES WITH LITTLE SIGNS OF BENDING OR STRESS. RT GEAR PIVOT BUSHING MADE OF STEEL TUBING ALSO CRACKED LONGITUDINALLY AND SPLIT CLEANLY IN HALF ALLOWING GEAR LEG TO SEPARATE FROM AIRPLANE. EVIDENCE OF CORROSION AND CRACKS NOTED IN RT GEAR PIVOT BUSHING. UNABLE TO DETERMINE FROM VISUAL INSP WHY TUBING FAILED. SUSPECTED CAUSES ARE: PRIOR CORROSION, PREEXISTING UNREPAIRED DAMAGE, AND /OR POOR WELDING FROM ORIGINAL CONSTRUCTION OR A LATER WELDED REPAIR. THE STRUCTURAL SECTION OF THE FUSELAGE THAT FAILED IS ALSO THE LOWER WING STRUT ATTACH POINT, RAISING CONCERNS ABOUT POTENTIAL IN-FLIGHT WING FAILURE. FOLLOW UP LAB ANALYSIS OF FAILED STEEL TUBING SECTIONS RECOMMENDED TO NTSB IIC IN ORDER TO DETERMINE CAUSE OF ACCIDENT AND GEAR FAILURE.