Service difficulty report · Hinge Fitting · Beech 77

Difficulty date
January 13, 2012
Submitted
January 20, 2012
Operation
General aviation
Aircraft
N3732F
Make and model
Beech 77
Aircraft serial
WA154
Part
Hinge Fitting
Condition
Cracked
Location
Crew Door
Part time
5,176 hours
Component
Door
Component part number
1084300101
Stage of operation
IN
How discovered
V
Nature of condition
O
Precautionary procedure
K

As reported to the FAA. Reports are unverified, and codes are left as the FAA publishes them.

What was found

DURING AN ANNUAL, DISCOVERED A WELDED REPAIR TO A CRACK ON THE PILOT-SIDE DOOR ON THE INNER SKIN BELOW THE RIVETS THAT FASTEN THE LOWER HINGE TO THE DOOR. WHILE THIS DOOR IS SERVICEABLE, THE SAME CRACK EXISTED ON ANOTHER ACFT SERVICED EARLIER. THE CRACK WAS APPROX 3-4" LONG AND THE PREVIOUS MECHANIC HAD TRIED TO (UNSUCCESSFULLY) DRILL-STOP IT. IT IS UNCLEAR HOW FAR THE CRACK EXTENDED. THIS CRACK DID NOT EXIST ON THE CO-PILOT DOOR ON EITHER AIRPLANE, LIKELY DUE TO HEAVIER WEAR ON THE PILOT SIDE. PROBABLE CAUSE IS LIKELY BOTH THE OPERATOR USING EXCESSIVE FORCE AND INADEQUATE REINFORCEMENT FOR THE DOOR HINGE. A REPAIR CAN LIKELY BE MADE WITH MULTIPLE METHODS IAW AC 43.13-1B, CHAP 4, SEC 4. RECOMMEND THAT THE AFFECTED AREA OF THE DOOR BE INSPECTED EVERY 100 HRS OR DURING ANNUAL, WHICHEVER COMES FIRST. UNCLEAR AT THIS TIME IF DRILL-STOPPING DURING THE EARLY DEVELOPMENT OF A CRACK WILL BE SUCCESSFUL.

More about the Beech 77