Service difficulty report · Fuel Cap · Cessna 185

Difficulty date
November 1, 2020
Submitted
November 2, 2020
Operation
General aviation
Aircraft
N9803X
Make and model
Cessna 185
Aircraft serial
1850003
Aircraft time
3,500 hours, 1 cycles
Part
Fuel Cap
Part number
FC006
Condition
Faulted
Location
Fuel Cell
Part time
1 hours, 1 cycles
Stage of operation
IN
How discovered
9
Nature of condition
O
Precautionary procedure
K

As reported to the FAA. Reports are unverified, and codes are left as the FAA publishes them.

What was found

DUE TO A DESIGN/MANUFACTURING FLAW IN THE HARTWIG AIRCRAFT "MONARCH PREMIUM FUEL CAPS" INSTALLED ON THIS AIRCRAFT THE CAPS WILL NOT SEAL. THIS IS DUE TO INCORRECT PLACEMENT OF THE FUEL CAP CHAIN RETAINING TAB FABRICATED IN THE FEMALE SECTION OF THE FUEL CAP ASSEMBLY (FILLER NECK). THE MALE CAP ASSEMBLY MAKES CONTACT WITH THIS TAB PRIOR TO THE CAP BEING FULLY SEATED, CAUSING THE FUEL TANKS TO REMAIN OPEN EVEN THOUGH THE CAP IS "TIGHT". IN OTHER WORDS, THE CAP THREADS BIND TO CAUSE THE CAP TO APPEAR TO BE TIGHT EVEN THOUGH THE FILLER REMAINS OPEN. IF THE AIRCRAFT IS ALLOWED TO FLY IN THIS CONDITION THE FUEL WILL SIPHON OUT OF THE FILLER INTO THE LOW PRESSURE AIRSTREAM ABOVE THE WING CAUSING A VARIETY OF SAFETY ISSUES, NOT LIMITED TO FUEL STARVATION AND/OR FIRE. FROM MY ASSESSMENT THIS CAP ASSEMBLY IS UNAIRWORTHY BY DESIGN. IN SOME FURTHER INTERNET RESEARCH, IT SEEMS AS THOUGH THIS PROBLEM HAS BEEN SEEN BY MANY END USERS IN THE FIELD, INDICATING A PROBABILITY OF MULTIPLE AIRCRAFT CURRENTLY UNKNOWINGLY OPERATING IN A DEGRADED CONDITION.

More about the Cessna 185