Service difficulty report · Spark Plug · Mooney M20

Difficulty date
September 7, 2020
Submitted
January 13, 2021
Operation
General aviation
Aircraft
N3345M
Make and model
Mooney M20
Aircraft serial
320003
Aircraft time
500 hours, 500 cycles
Engine
Cont IO550G
Engine time
500 hours
Part
Spark Plug
Part number
URHB32S
Condition
Failed
Location
Engine
Part time
500 hours
Stage of operation
CR
How discovered
O
Nature of condition
R, E, G
Precautionary procedure
A

As reported to the FAA. Reports are unverified, and codes are left as the FAA publishes them.

What was found

A STRING OF 3 IN FLIGHT MAGNETO FAILURES (MAGNETOS PURCHASED/OVERHAULED FROM 2 DIFFERENT SOURCES) OVER THE COURSE OF APPROXIMATELY 100 FLIGHT HOURS WAS LINKED TO BAD TEMPEST FINE WIRE SPARK PLUGS, ONE OF WHICH LOST A CENTER ELECTRODE IN FLIGHT DURING ENGINE OPERATION. OTHER THAN LOSS OF ELECTRODE, NO VISIBLE DAMAGE OR DEFECT COULD BE DETECTED ON THE GROUND. SUSPECTED BUILDUP OF HIGH ELECTRICAL RESISTANCE AT HIGH ENGINE OPERATING TEMPERATURES. PROBLEM IS WORST WHEN OUTSIDE AIR TEMPERATURE IS ABOVE STANDARD, AND UNDER FLIGHT CONDITIONS WHERE HIGH CYLINDER PRESSURE AND HIGH DENSITY ALTITUDE ARE PRESENT AND INTERNAL AIR PRESSURE INSIDE THE NON-PRESSURIZED MAGNETO IS AT ITS LOWEST LEADING TO ARCING INSIDE THE MAGNETO. ONE MAGNETO FAILURE OCCURRED AT 14,000 FT DURING WHICH THE POINTS ON THE MAGNETO FAILED COMPLETELY RESULTING IN PARTIAL POWER LOSS, THE NEXT AT 17,000 FT (INCIPIENT FAILURE) APPROXIMATELY 2 FLIGHT HOURS LATER, AND THE THIRD (INCIPIENT FAILURE) AT 11,000 FT APPROXIMATELY 50 FLIGHT HOURS AFTER THE FIRST TWO FAILURES. SINCE REPLACING THE PLUGS, APPROXIMATELY 100 FLIGHT HOURS HAVE ELAPSED WITH NO MORE MAGNETO FAILURES OR ABNORMAL OPERATION FROM THE IGNITION SYSTEM. FAILURE MAY BE RELATED TO THE BONDING PROCESS OF THE CENTER ELECTRODE TO THE INSULATOR OR FAULTY WELDING OF THE CENTER ELECTRODE TO THE CORE OF THE PLUG. APPROXIMATELY $5,000 IN PARTS AND LABOR COST ASSOCIATED WITH DAMAGE TO MAGNETOS CAUSED BY THESE PLUGS BEFORE THE FAULTY PLUGS WERE DISCOVERED AND REMOVED, THANKFULLY NO CRASH OR LOSS OF LIFE.

More about the Mooney M20