Service difficulty report · Pulley · Piper PA28R200

Difficulty date
September 22, 2023
Submitted
September 22, 2023
Operation
General aviation
Aircraft
N774LR
Make and model
Piper PA28R200
Aircraft serial
28R7435297
Part
Pulley
Part number
4100110
Condition
Unknown
Location
Zone 100
Stage of operation
IN
How discovered
9
Nature of condition
O
Precautionary procedure
K

As reported to the FAA. Reports are unverified, and codes are left as the FAA publishes them.

What was found

IN THE PROCESS OF REPLACING WORN PULLEYS, WE ORDERED PMA REPLACEMENT PULLEYS, PART NUMBER 41001-10 PULLEYS FROM UNIVAIR THROUGH AIRCRAFT SPRUCE. WE WERE SENT U-41001-8 PULLEYS WHICH WERE REPRESENTED AS BEING FAA/PMA REPLACEMENTS. HAVING A -8 SUPERSEDING A -10 PART NUMBER SEEMED ODD TO ME SO I CONTACTED RALMARK WHICH IS THE MANUFACTURER OF THE PULLEY. THEY INFORMED ME THAT THE 41008-08 HAS A SIDE LOAD LIMIT OF 200 LBS. THE 41008-10 HAS A SIDE LOAD LIMIT OF 280 LBS. AT THE TIME, THE ONLINE UNIVAIR PARTS CATALOG INDICATED THAT THE 41001-10 SUPERSEDES TO A U-41008-08. I THEN CONTACTED UNIVAIR AND THEY TOLD ME THAT THE -8 DOES SUPERSEDE THE -10. WHEN I EXPLAINED WHAT RALMARK SAID, UNIVAIR THEN RESEARCHED THEIR FAA/PMA APPROVAL AND TOLD ME THAT THE -8 IS NOT A REPLACEMENT FOR THE -10. THE UNIVAIR ONLINE CATALOG HAS NOW BEEN CORRECTED. STILL SHOWS THE 41008-08 IS A REPLACEMENT FOR A 41008-10. ALTHOUGH WE HAVE THE CORRECT PART NUMBER PULLEYS FOR THIS AIRCRAFT, MY CONCERN IS THAT THIS INCORRECT SUPERSEDED PULLEYS HAVE BEEN INSTALLED FOR DECADES IN THE PIPER SERIES AIRCRAFT.

More about the Piper PA-28R-200