Service difficulty report · Alternator · Mooney M20K

Difficulty date
May 7, 2026
Submitted
May 7, 2026
Operation
General aviation
Aircraft
N252AN
Make and model
Mooney M20K
Aircraft serial
251118
Engine
Cont TSIO520*
Part
Alternator
Part number
ALU9522
Part serial
A157523
Condition
Destroyed
Location
Engine
Part time
115 hours
Stage of operation
NR
How discovered
V
Nature of condition
J
Precautionary procedure
D

As reported to the FAA. Reports are unverified, and codes are left as the FAA publishes them.

What was found

ALTERNATOR DRIVE COUPLING DESTROYED CAUSING SUBSEQUENT FAILURE OF ENGINE'S DRIVE GEAR P/N 657984. ALL FOUR BOLTS P/N 649205 SHEARED OFF OR THREADS STRIPPED FROM SHANKS CAUSING SEPARATION OF GEAR FROM CRANKSHAFT. LOCK PLATES P/N 641909 FOUND IN TACT IN OIL SUMP AND SHOW SIGNS OF PROPER INSTALLATION AND BOLT HEAD LOCKING CONDITION AS REQUIRED. ENGINE IS COMPLETELY DESTROYED AS THE GEAR FACE WAS PUSHED AFT, WEARING INTO THE CRANKCASE. THE CRANKSHAFT WAS DAMAGED AS WELL AS THE ACCESSORY DRIVE TRAIN COMPONENTS IN THAT AREA.UNABLE TO DETERMINE WHERE THE FAILURE BEGAN, HOWEVER IT ALWAYS INVOLVES AN ASSEMBLY INVOLVING DRIVE COUPLINGS INSTALLED ON PLANE POWER ALTERNATORS. IN ALL INSTANCES, THERE'S BEEN A SUBSEQUENT FAILURE OF THE CRANKSHAFT GEAR RETAINING BOLTS. WE HAVE NOT SEEN THIS TYPE OF FAILURE WITH ANOTHER ALTERNATOR MANUFACTURER OR MODEL. IT SEEMS TO BE A COMMON OCCURRENCE WITH CRANKSHAFT DRIVEN HARTZELL PLANE POWER ALTERNATORS. THIS IS ONE OF THREE INSTANCES OF CATASTOPHIC ENGINE FAILURES WITH A PLANE POWER ALTERNATOR INSTALLATION THIS ENTITY HAS SEEN. CONVERSATIONS WITH OTHER ENTITIES INCLUDE CATASTROPHIC ENGINE FAILURES WITH PLANE POWER ENGINE DRIVEN ALTERNATORS INSTALLED. THE DRIVE COUPLING WAS PROPERLY INSTALLED AND THE CRANKSHAFT GEAR FACES AND TEETH WERE INSPECTED IN ACCORDANCE WITH CMI MANUAL M-0.

More about the Mooney M20K