SDR 95ZZZX1423

Service difficulty report · Valve Spring · Piper PA28140

Difficulty date
March 3, 1995
Submitted
March 26, 2000
Operation
General aviation
Aircraft
N3975K
Make and model
Piper PA28140
Aircraft serial
2823861
Engine
Lyc O320E3D
Part
Valve Spring
Part number
65427
Condition
Wrong Part
Location
Outer
Stage of operation
IN
Nature of condition
W
Precautionary procedure
K

As reported to the FAA. Reports are unverified, and codes are left as the FAA publishes them.

What was found

CUSTOMER REPORTED ENGINE 'BACKFIRING' INTERMITTENTLY AT HIGH IDLE. VALVE TRAIN PROBLEMS SUSPECTED & COLD CYLINDER TESTER DISCLOSED NR 3 CYL SLIGHTLY COOL (COMPRESSION WAS EXCELLENT). CLOSER INSP DISCLOSED INCORRECT SPRINGS PN 65427 INSTALLED INSTEAD OF LW-11800. NO RECORD OF MX ON THIS CYL SINCE O/H. PN 65427 SPRING HAS ABOUT 35 POUNDS LESS LOAD THAN CORRECT SPRING & IS USED IN O-235/O-290 SERIES ENGINES. VALVE & GUIDE WEAR WERE CHECKED & WITHIN LIMITS, BUT ENOUGH MUST HAVE CHANGED SINCE ENG HAS RUN 1620 HRS SMOH W/O COMPLAINT OF BACKFIRING. IN THIS CASE, 'WEAK' SPRINGS ALLOWED VALVES TO RESONATE OR BOUNCE IN A NARROW RPM RANGE (1200-1500 RPM) & RESULTED IN 'AFTERFIRING'. REPLACING SPRINGS CURED PROBLEM.

More about the Piper PA-28-140