Service difficulty report · Squat Switch · Piper PA44180

Difficulty date
February 17, 2015
Submitted
February 18, 2015
Operation
General aviation
Aircraft
N287PA
Make and model
Piper PA44180
Aircraft serial
4496110
Aircraft time
7,564 hours
Engine
Lyc O360A1H6
Propeller
Hartzl HCC2YR2
Part
Squat Switch
Part number
89291004
Condition
Separated
Location
Mlg
Part time
2,160 hours
Stage of operation
CL
How discovered
O
Nature of condition
N
Precautionary procedure
A

As reported to the FAA. Reports are unverified, and codes are left as the FAA publishes them.

What was found

AFTER TAKEOFF, THE PILOTS ATTEMPTED TO RAISE THE GEAR. THE GEAR DID NOT COME UP AND THE GEAR UNSAFE LIGHT ILLUMINATED AND THE HORN SOUNDED. THE PILOTS RECYCLED THE GEAR HANDLE WITH THE SAME RESULTS. THEY WERE ABLE TO LAND AND RETURN TO THE RAMP UNEVENTFULLY. INSPECTION REVEALED THE LT SQUAT SWITCH HAD 1 BROKEN WIRE. A SECOND WIRE BROKE AS THE SWITCH WAS REMOVED AND A THIRD IS ALMOST COMPLETELY BROKEN. THE SWITCH DESIGN HAS A PROBLEMATIC HISTORY WITH THIS REPAIR STATION, AS FAILURES ARE COMMON AND OCCUR VERY QUICKLY, PREVENTING EVEN DILIGENT INSPECTION FROM DETECTING PROBLEMS. THE BREAKAGE IS DUE TO FATIGUE; THE WIRES ARE COATED WITH SHRINK WRAP THAT FORCE THEM TO FLEX IN ONLY A SMALL AREA DESPITE CAREFUL ROUTING. ALSO, THE WIRES ARE NOT STRAIGHTENED OUT BEFORE THE SHRINK WRAP IS SHRUNK, CAUSING SOME TO BE VERY TIGHT AND OTHERS TO BE BULGING OUT.

More about the Piper PA-44-180