19990114012769I

Incident · Substantial damage

FAA incident report · EMB EMB120 · Atlanta, GA · January 14, 1999

Date
January 14, 1999 · 22:20 local
Place
Atlanta, GA
Airport
The William B Hartsfield Atla
Phase of flight
Ground Taxi, Other Airplane
Operating rules
Air carrier (Part 121)
Operator
ASOA
Damage
Substantial damage
Aircraft
N233AS
Reported as
EMB EMB120
Reported engine
Pratt & Whitney PW118
People aboard
13
Fatal injuries
1
Pilot’s flight hours
6,158 total6,158 in this make and model216 in the last 90 days

From the FAA’s Accident/Incident Data System (AIDS), through its Aviation Safety Information Portal, as reported. The NTSB investigates accidents separately, and its record of an accident is the fuller one. The aircraft is matched to the registry by N-number and event date, checked against the reported make and model; the registry’s history has gaps, so older matches can be wrong. Compare the reported make and model.

What happened

The FAA’s narrative, in sentence case. The FAA writes it in capitals and removes private details.

On the morning of Friday January 15, at approx. 0815, inspector jones requested that I dispatch myself to the Atlanta airport to represent the FAA, and team b from the operations standpoint with any assistance needed regarding the Emb-120 ramp accident which occurred at approx. 2230 on January 14. After arriving at the airport, I joined asa's safety officer riley shamburger, capt. john goodson (program mgr. Emb-120), and bob levesque (director of maintenance) on a trip to the northwest airlines ramp to inspect aircraft 223AS and a delta airlines "tug' both of which were involved in the ramp accident. While approaching the aircraft, it was easy to notice that two of the four propeller blades on the right engine were broken off, there was considerable damage to the fuselage starting at the right wing root and traveling rearward. This was in the form of both holes in the fuselage, and"buckling" of the skin which was a result of the tug traveling under the aircraft. The tug itself had complete damage to the steering wheel, considerable damage done to the exterior. From all accounts that morning, it appeared as if the tug driver, Mr. David mitchell, was traveling nw on the "crossover" location on the southern end of ramp 4. This occurred at night, during heavy rain, with poor visibility. It was also stated that the driver may have had his hand over his raincoat hood,further restricting his view of the taxiing aircraft. From all indications, he accidentally contacted the right side of the aircraft at or near the right engine propeller. It has been reported that the aircraft taxi light was not on at the time. I also noted myself, that the "crossover" lines were painted in a less noticeable color and design than the mid-pt. And end boundary lines. privacy data omitted

As the FAA filed it

ON THE MORNING OF FRIDAY JANUARY 15, AT APPROX. 0815, INSPECTOR JONES REQUESTED THAT I DISPATCH MYSELF TO THE ATLANTA AIRPORT TO REPRESENT THE FAA, AND TEAM B FROM THE OPERATIONS STANDPOINT WITH ANY ASSISTANCE NEEDED REGARDING THE EMB-120 RAMP ACCIDENT WHICH OCCURRED AT APPROX. 2230 ON JANUARY 14. AFTER ARRIVING AT THE AIRPORT, I JOINED ASA'S SAFETY OFFICER RILEY SHAMBURGER, CAPT. JOHN GOODSON (PROGRAM MGR. EMB-120), AND BOB LEVESQUE (DIRECTOR OF MAINTENANCE) ON A TRIP TO THE NORTHWEST AIRLINES RAMP TO INSPECT AIRCRAFT 223AS AND A DELTA AIRLINES "TUG' BOTH OF WHICH WERE INVOLVED IN THE RAMP ACCIDENT. WHILE APPROACHING THE AIRCRAFT, IT WAS EASY TO NOTICE THAT TWO OF THE FOUR PROPELLER BLADES ON THE RIGHT ENGINE WERE BROKEN OFF, THERE WAS CONSIDERABLE DAMAGE TO THE FUSELAGE STARTING AT THE RIGHT WING ROOT AND TRAVELING REARWARD. THIS WAS IN THE FORM OF BOTH HOLES IN THE FUSELAGE, AND"BUCKLING" OF THE SKIN WHICH WAS A RESULT OF THE TUG TRAVELING UNDER THE AIRCRAFT. THE TUG ITSELF HAD COMPLETE DAMAGE TO THE STEERING WHEEL, CONSIDERABLE DAMAGE DONE TO THE EXTERIOR. FROM ALL ACCOUNTS THAT MORNING, IT APPEARED AS IF THE TUG DRIVER, MR. DAVID MITCHELL, WAS TRAVELING NW ON THE "CROSSOVER" LOCATION ON THE SOUTHERN END OF RAMP 4. THIS OCCURRED AT NIGHT, DURING HEAVY RAIN, WITH POOR VISIBILITY. IT WAS ALSO STATED THAT THE DRIVER MAY HAVE HAD HIS HAND OVER HIS RAINCOAT HOOD,FURTHER RESTRICTING HIS VIEW OF THE TAXIING AIRCRAFT. FROM ALL INDICATIONS, HE ACCIDENTALLY CONTACTED THE RIGHT SIDE OF THE AIRCRAFT AT OR NEAR THE RIGHT ENGINE PROPELLER. IT HAS BEEN REPORTED THAT THE AIRCRAFT TAXI LIGHT WAS NOT ON AT THE TIME. I ALSO NOTED MYSELF, THAT THE "CROSSOVER" LINES WERE PAINTED IN A LESS NOTICEABLE COLOR AND DESIGN THAN THE MID-PT. AND END BOUNDARY LINES. ^PRIVACY DATA OMITTED^