What happened
The FAA’s narrative, in sentence case. The FAA writes it in capitals and removes private details.
(-23) Prior to departure from otg-gxy, the pilot obtained wx information from greenbay flight service station. Rain was forecast as FAR south as Wyoming, but not into Colorado. At approximately 0017, it was reported that the airplane was having icing problems and may need to make an emergency landing at Washington county airport, located north of Akron, Colorado. The pilot states that he requested an altitude several times in an attempt to avoid the icing condition, but the icing persisted. He began losing altitude and requested to land. He was diverted back to Washington airport by ATC. The sheriffs responded to the airport and observed the airplane approach for landing. It was not level and traveling too fast, which is normal in these conditions. It touched down at approximately midpoint on the runway and skidded off the runway. The pilot stated that he landed the airplane by looking out of the side window as the windsheild was covered with ice. Ice was approximately 4 inches thick on the wings and thicker on the props. The damage to the wing tip and the engine cowl were minor. The aircraft taxied to the main hangar for inspection and was repaired. Pilot continued his flight the next day.
As the FAA filed it
(-23) PRIOR TO DEPARTURE FROM OTG-GXY, THE PILOT OBTAINED WX INFORMATION FROM GREENBAY FLIGHT SERVICE STATION. RAIN WAS FORECAST AS FAR SOUTH AS WYOMING, BUT NOT INTO COLORADO. AT APPROXIMATELY 0017, IT WAS REPORTED THAT THE AIRPLANE WAS HAVING ICING PROBLEMS AND MAY NEED TO MAKE AN EMERGENCY LANDING AT WASHINGTON COUNTY AIRPORT, LOCATED NORTH OF AKRON, COLORADO. THE PILOT STATES THAT HE REQUESTED AN ALTITUDE SEVERAL TIMES IN AN ATTEMPT TO AVOID THE ICING CONDITION, BUT THE ICING PERSISTED. HE BEGAN LOSING ALTITUDE AND REQUESTED TO LAND. HE WAS DIVERTED BACK TO WASHINGTON AIRPORT BY ATC. THE SHERIFFS RESPONDED TO THE AIRPORT AND OBSERVED THE AIRPLANE APPROACH FOR LANDING. IT WAS NOT LEVEL AND TRAVELING TOO FAST, WHICH IS NORMAL IN THESE CONDITIONS. IT TOUCHED DOWN AT APPROXIMATELY MIDPOINT ON THE RUNWAY AND SKIDDED OFF THE RUNWAY. THE PILOT STATED THAT HE LANDED THE AIRPLANE BY LOOKING OUT OF THE SIDE WINDOW AS THE WINDSHEILD WAS COVERED WITH ICE. ICE WAS APPROXIMATELY 4 INCHES THICK ON THE WINGS AND THICKER ON THE PROPS. THE DAMAGE TO THE WING TIP AND THE ENGINE COWL WERE MINOR. THE AIRCRAFT TAXIED TO THE MAIN HANGAR FOR INSPECTION AND WAS REPAIRED. PILOT CONTINUED HIS FLIGHT THE NEXT DAY.