What happened
The FAA’s narrative, in sentence case. The FAA writes it in capitals and removes private details.
(-23) Aircraft number 1 was united express flight #7517 operated by shuttle america departing gate D10 at the ind airport. Aircraft number 2 was frontier airlines flight #619 departing gate D-3 at ind. These concourses share an alley for common pushback, taxi and departure. This area is not under positive control of ATC ground control. The incident occurred at approximately 1440 EST. The FAA ATC ground controller issued a clearance to aircraft #1 to "pushback at pilot's discretion from gate D-10". Aircraft #2 was issued a taxi clearance to "pushback and taxi at pilot's discretion from gate C-3, caution for traffic pushing off of "d" concourse" or words to that effect. Aircraft #1 was parked in the alley after completing his pushback and the ground crew was disconnecting the tow bar from the tug when aircraft #2 chose to attempt to pass on the right side of aircraft #1 in the alley. As he was taxiing a/c #2 struck the right elevator and horizontal tip cap of aircraft #1 with his left winglet assembly. Frontier participates in the asap program and the incident has been referred to the asap review committee for action. The shuttle america aircraft was parked and hooked to the tow tractor at contact.
As the FAA filed it
(-23) AIRCRAFT NUMBER 1 WAS UNITED EXPRESS FLIGHT #7517 OPERATED BY SHUTTLE AMERICA DEPARTING GATE D10 AT THE IND AIRPORT. AIRCRAFT NUMBER 2 WAS FRONTIER AIRLINES FLIGHT #619 DEPARTING GATE D-3 AT IND. THESE CONCOURSES SHARE AN ALLEY FOR COMMON PUSHBACK, TAXI AND DEPARTURE. THIS AREA IS NOT UNDER POSITIVE CONTROL OF ATC GROUND CONTROL. THE INCIDENT OCCURRED AT APPROXIMATELY 1440 EST. THE FAA ATC GROUND CONTROLLER ISSUED A CLEARANCE TO AIRCRAFT #1 TO "PUSHBACK AT PILOT'S DISCRETION FROM GATE D-10". AIRCRAFT #2 WAS ISSUED A TAXI CLEARANCE TO "PUSHBACK AND TAXI AT PILOT'S DISCRETION FROM GATE C-3, CAUTION FOR TRAFFIC PUSHING OFF OF "D" CONCOURSE" OR WORDS TO THAT EFFECT. AIRCRAFT #1 WAS PARKED IN THE ALLEY AFTER COMPLETING HIS PUSHBACK AND THE GROUND CREW WAS DISCONNECTING THE TOW BAR FROM THE TUG WHEN AIRCRAFT #2 CHOSE TO ATTEMPT TO PASS ON THE RIGHT SIDE OF AIRCRAFT #1 IN THE ALLEY. AS HE WAS TAXIING A/C #2 STRUCK THE RIGHT ELEVATOR AND HORIZONTAL TIP CAP OF AIRCRAFT #1 WITH HIS LEFT WINGLET ASSEMBLY. FRONTIER PARTICIPATES IN THE ASAP PROGRAM AND THE INCIDENT HAS BEEN REFERRED TO THE ASAP REVIEW COMMITTEE FOR ACTION. THE SHUTTLE AMERICA AIRCRAFT WAS PARKED AND HOOKED TO THE TOW TRACTOR AT CONTACT.