What happened
The FAA’s narrative, in sentence case. The FAA writes it in capitals and removes private details.
(-23) Flight from benton harbor, Michigan to wheeling, west Virginia. While cruising at 3500' the pilot exhausted all fuel in the left wing and lost power. The pilot was unable to regain power after switching the fuel selector valve to the right tank numerous times. He declared an emergency and attempted to land at Mansfield Lahm airport, landing in a soybean field about a mile north of runway 23. The aircraft sustained damage to the propeller, nose landing gear and the main landing gear fairings. On August 3, 2006, maintenance technicians were able to prime the engine and run it off the right fuel tank and then the left tank. It is suspected that the right fuel pump was not engaged after the fuel tank selector valve was switched to the right fuel tank. End
As the FAA filed it
(-23) FLIGHT FROM BENTON HARBOR, MICHIGAN TO WHEELING, WEST VIRGINIA. WHILE CRUISING AT 3500' THE PILOT EXHAUSTED ALL FUEL IN THE LEFT WING AND LOST POWER. THE PILOT WAS UNABLE TO REGAIN POWER AFTER SWITCHING THE FUEL SELECTOR VALVE TO THE RIGHT TANK NUMEROUS TIMES. HE DECLARED AN EMERGENCY AND ATTEMPTED TO LAND AT MANSFIELD LAHM AIRPORT, LANDING IN A SOYBEAN FIELD ABOUT A MILE NORTH OF RUNWAY 23. THE AIRCRAFT SUSTAINED DAMAGE TO THE PROPELLER, NOSE LANDING GEAR AND THE MAIN LANDING GEAR FAIRINGS. ON AUGUST 3, 2006, MAINTENANCE TECHNICIANS WERE ABLE TO PRIME THE ENGINE AND RUN IT OFF THE RIGHT FUEL TANK AND THEN THE LEFT TANK. IT IS SUSPECTED THAT THE RIGHT FUEL PUMP WAS NOT ENGAGED AFTER THE FUEL TANK SELECTOR VALVE WAS SWITCHED TO THE RIGHT FUEL TANK. END