20190526017189A

Accident · Substantial damage

FAA accident report · Jones Mark S RAND ROBINSON KR-2S · Poplar Grove, IL · May 26, 2019

Date
May 26, 2019 · 17:05 local
Place
Poplar Grove, IL
Airport
Poplar Grove
Phase of flight
Takeoff: Climb Out
Operating rules
General operating rules (Part 91)
Damage
Substantial damage
Aircraft
N886MJ
NTSB investigation
NTSBCEN19LA152
Reported as
Jones Mark S Rand Robinson KR-2S
Reported engine
General Motors 100HP CORVAIR 164CI
People aboard
1
Fatal injuries
0
Other injuries
1
Pilot’s certificate
Private pilot
Pilot’s flight hours
623 total29 in this make and model23 in the last 90 days

From the FAA’s Accident/Incident Data System (AIDS), through its Aviation Safety Information Portal, as reported. The NTSB investigates accidents separately, and its record of an accident is the fuller one. The aircraft is matched to the registry by N-number and event date, checked against the reported make and model; the registry’s history has gaps, so older matches can be wrong. Compare the reported make and model.

What happened

The FAA’s narrative, in sentence case. The FAA writes it in capitals and removes private details.

All times are approximate. Alt and time data derived from aprs system tracking for KC9DAH transmitter operating in the aircraft at the time.

1550: Aircraft departed kfep rwy 6 after normal preflight and runup as per aircraft checklist.

1551: Climbout was normal to 2200 ft MSL. Flight proceeded direct to C77 (Poplar Grove)

1558: Decended to 1900MSL to avoid krfd trsa outer ring.

1605: Entered 45 angle for left downwind for rwy 30 at C77

1609: Landed C77. Taxi to parking and shutdown engine

1649: Engine start for departure back to kfep via rwy 30

1651: End of runway check completed. Runup normal no problems noted.

1653: Climbout from rwy 30 normal for first 60 sec

1654: I noted the aircraft not accelerating when nose lowered at full power. First hint of oil smoke in cockpit.

1654.15 Scan revealed a lower than normal oil pressure of 35 PSI. (This engine has always had 40-45 PSI oil pressure) oil smoke started to thicken. Scan also revealed that the oil temp was climbing. 220F max has been noted during previous climbouts. Oil temp was ~230F

1655 I lowered the nose to get more ram air cooling. This had no effect and smoke seemed to be getting worse

1656: Made radio call declaring I had oil pressure problems and was returning to the airport. Started left 180 turn at 658FT AGL.

1656.30 Completed turn @ 563 ft AGL and could hear engine loosing power. Scanning for C77 runway 12 revealed mostly trees between my position and the runway. I determined that I would not make the runway. I looked to my left and picked out my landing field.

1656.45 I made another radio call announcing my intension to land in a corn field 2 miles west of C77. With the engine still running I setup for an e to w landing into the prevailing wind.

1657. I made my final turn for landing at 327FT AGL. I deployed my speed brake ~ 50% and landed hard with (~1000FT) 50% of the field remaining. I bounced back into the air and held aft stick waiting for the aircraft to settle. It did settle and rolled about 100FT before the nosewheel dug into the soft ground and the aircraft flipped forward and over onto its back.

As the FAA filed it

ALL TIMES ARE APPROXIMATE. ALT AND TIME DATA DERIVED FROM APRS SYSTEM TRACKING FOR KC9DAH TRANSMITTER OPERATING IN THE AIRCRAFT AT THE TIME.

1550: AIRCRAFT DEPARTED KFEP RWY 6 AFTER NORMAL PREFLIGHT AND RUNUP AS PER AIRCRAFT CHECKLIST.

1551: CLIMBOUT WAS NORMAL TO 2200 FT MSL. FLIGHT PROCEEDED DIRECT TO C77 (POPLAR GROVE)

1558: DECENDED TO 1900MSL TO AVOID KRFD TRSA OUTER RING.

1605: ENTERED 45 ANGLE FOR LEFT DOWNWIND FOR RWY 30 AT C77

1609: LANDED C77. TAXI TO PARKING AND SHUTDOWN ENGINE

1649: ENGINE START FOR DEPARTURE BACK TO KFEP VIA RWY 30

1651: END OF RUNWAY CHECK COMPLETED. RUNUP NORMAL NO PROBLEMS NOTED.

1653: CLIMBOUT FROM RWY 30 NORMAL FOR FIRST 60 SEC

1654: I NOTED THE AIRCRAFT NOT ACCELERATING WHEN NOSE LOWERED AT FULL POWER. FIRST HINT OF OIL SMOKE IN COCKPIT.

1654.15 SCAN REVEALED A LOWER THAN NORMAL OIL PRESSURE OF 35 PSI. (THIS ENGINE HAS ALWAYS HAD 40-45 PSI OIL PRESSURE) OIL SMOKE STARTED TO THICKEN. SCAN ALSO REVEALED THAT THE OIL TEMP WAS CLIMBING. 220F MAX HAS BEEN NOTED DURING PREVIOUS CLIMBOUTS. OIL TEMP WAS ~230F

1655 I LOWERED THE NOSE TO GET MORE RAM AIR COOLING. THIS HAD NO EFFECT AND SMOKE SEEMED TO BE GETTING WORSE

1656: MADE RADIO CALL DECLARING I HAD OIL PRESSURE PROBLEMS AND WAS RETURNING TO THE AIRPORT. STARTED LEFT 180 TURN AT 658FT AGL.

1656.30 COMPLETED TURN @ 563 FT AGL AND COULD HEAR ENGINE LOOSING POWER. SCANNING FOR C77 RUNWAY 12 REVEALED MOSTLY TREES BETWEEN MY POSITION AND THE RUNWAY. I DETERMINED THAT I WOULD NOT MAKE THE RUNWAY. I LOOKED TO MY LEFT AND PICKED OUT MY LANDING FIELD.

1656.45 I MADE ANOTHER RADIO CALL ANNOUNCING MY INTENSION TO LAND IN A CORN FIELD 2 MILES WEST OF C77. WITH THE ENGINE STILL RUNNING I SETUP FOR AN E TO W LANDING INTO THE PREVAILING WIND.

1657. I MADE MY FINAL TURN FOR LANDING AT 327FT AGL. I DEPLOYED MY SPEED BRAKE ~ 50% AND LANDED HARD WITH (~1000FT) 50% OF THE FIELD REMAINING. I BOUNCED BACK INTO THE AIR AND HELD AFT STICK WAITING FOR THE AIRCRAFT TO SETTLE. IT DID SETTLE AND ROLLED ABOUT 100FT BEFORE THE NOSEWHEEL DUG INTO THE SOFT GROUND AND THE AIRCRAFT FLIPPED FORWARD AND OVER ONTO ITS BACK.

NTSB investigation

The NTSB’s investigation of this event, with its probable cause and findings. Matched to this report by N-number and date.