CHI00FA214

The airplane was destroyed during impact with terrain and post accident fire during a maneuver to return to the airport after loss of power on takeoff. The pilot was fatally injured. The annual inspection was completed on July 21, 2000. A witness stated that the airplane was just above power lines, that the airplane made a turn to the east, and that the airplane was even lower when it made a turn back to the north. She stated that the airplane impacted the ground with its left wing and then impacted the ground with its nose. She said that the airplane spun around and burst into flames when it hit the ground. She stated that the engine was sputtering. At 1440 she called 911. A fuel pump log indicated the plane was last fueled at 1429. Continuity to all control surfaces and to both engines was established. A thumb compression was found at all cylinders. All magnetos except the right engine's left magneto produced spark when rotated. A liquid was found in the left engines carburetor bowl and "analysis of item 1 revealed the presence of water and a flammable liquid consistent with aviation fluid." Mineral matter, plant matter, fibers, glass like particles, metallic particles, and unidentified particles were found in that fluid. Both carburetor inlet screens contained a media and the NTSB Materials Laboratory report on the screens stated, "Examination of the cylindrical screen revealed the sides were partially blocked with debris and the round end was totally blocked. Approximately 60% of the [right] screen mesh was blocked with debris. ... Approximately 30% of the [left] screen mesh was blocked." Both propellers' witness marks indicated low blade angle and no anomalies were found. The left governor was tested and had no anomalies found. The right governor was not tested. Review of aerial photographs show suitable fields for emergency landings around the airport.

History of flight

On July 22, 2000, about 1435 central daylight time, a Piper PA-23, N1069P, piloted by a private pilot, was destroyed during impact with terrain and post accident fire following a maneuver south of Dodge Center Airport, near Dodge Center, Minnesota. The flight was operating under 14 CFR Part 91. Visual meteorological conditions prevailed during the flight. No flight plan was on file. The pilot was fatally injured. The local flight originated from Dodge Center Airport at time unknown.

The annual inspection was completed on July 21, 2000. A fuel pump log indicates that on July 22, 2000, the airplane was fueled at 1426 with 88.89 gallons and at 1429 with 5.66 gallons. (See appended fuel pump log and pump legend.)

A witness stated that she was at the corner of County Road 10 and County Road I when she saw the airplane flying southbound along County Road I with its gear retracted. She said that the airplane was just above power lines, that the airplane made a turn to the east, and that the airplane was even lower when it made a turn back to the north. She stated that the airplane impacted the ground with its left wing and then impacted the ground with its nose. She said that the airplane spun around and burst into flames when it hit the ground. She stated that the engine was sputtering. At 1440, Dodge County Dispatch received her call reporting the airplane crash.

Another witness at the same corner stated that the engine was not loud and that it was sputtering. He estimated the power lines to be 35 feet above the ground and said that the airplane banked into a left turn, which was approximately 45 degrees of bank. He stated that the airplane descended during the left turn and impacted the ground with its left wing.

Personnel information

The pilot held a Private pilot certificate with Airplane Multiengine Land, Airplane Single Engine Land, and Instrument ratings. He held a 3rd Class Medical Certificate with no limitations, dated April 3, 2000. He listed 1,650 hours of flight time at the time of that medical examination.

Aircraft information

The airplane was a Piper PA-23, serial number 23-80. The airplane's annual inspection was completed on July 21, 2000. That inspection entry listed 4,285.6 hours total time on the airplane. Receipts indicate that both of the airplane's propellers were sent to a propeller repair station for "A/D COMPLIANCE".

Meteorological information

At 1454, the Rochester Municipal Airport, 139 degrees and about 17 nautical miles from Dodge Center Airport, observation was: Wind variable at 3 knots; visibility 10 statute miles; sky condition few 9,000 feet; temperature 23 degrees C; dew point 13 degrees C; altimeter 30.18 inches of mercury.

Wreckage and impact information

The airplane's nose came to rest in a bean field about 515 feet south of County Road 10 and about 718 feet east of County Road I. An area approximately 4 feet wide and between 30 to 100 feet west of the airplane's nose was found devoid of vegetation. In this area, a piece of translucent red colored media and a navigation light assembly were found approximately 88 feet west of the airplane's nose. An indentation in the ground within this area, approximately 2 feet in diameter and one foot below grade, was found approximately 54 feet west of the airplane's nose. Another indentation within this area, approximately 1 foot in diameter and one foot below grade, was found approximately 37 feet west of the airplane's nose. The left wing outboard of the spar splice was found detached, deformed, discolored, and covered with a soot like substance. The inboard portion of the left wing was found detached from the airframe at its root and the left flap was found loosely attached and resting under the wing. The right wing was found attached to the fuselage. The right wing, outboard of the nacelle, was found deformed, discolored, and covered with a soot like substance. All landing gear were found in the retracted position.

An on-scene investigation was conducted. The airplane exhibited continuity to all control surfaces. Continuity was found to both engines. A thumb compression was found at all cylinders. The right engine's left magneto revealed melted internal parts and did not produce a spark when rotated. All other magnetos produced a spark when rotated. A liquid was found in the left engine's carburetor bowl. That liquid was observed and it revealed it consisted of fluids that did not mix together. The left wing had 38.4 gallons of a blue colored liquid extracted from its inboard 36-gallon tank. Both carburetor inlet screens were removed and observed. Both of these screens contained a media. (See appended photographs.)

Medical and pathological information

An autopsy was performed on the pilot by the Ramsey County Medical Examiner on July 24, 2000.

The FAA Civil Aeromedical Institute prepared a Final Forensic Toxicology Accident Report. The report was negative.

Fire

A witness said that the airplane burst into flames when it hit the ground. Approximately a 40-foot oval shaped area, centered about where the airplane's nose came to rest, was found devoid of vegetation. Charred remnants of vegetation within and vegetation along the edge of this oval was found discolored, charred, and covered with a soot like substance.

Tests and research

The liquid found in the carburetor was sent to the DuPage County Sheriff's Office Crime Laboratory, Wheaton, Illinois, for examination. The report stated, "Instrumental analysis of item 1 revealed the presence of water and a flammable liquid consistent with aviation fluid. Microscopical examination of item 1 revealed the presence of the following: mineral matter; plant matter; fibers; glass like particles; metallic particles; unidentified particles."

The fuel screen assemblies and the media they contained were sent to the National Transportation Safety Board's Materials Laboratory for examination. The portion of the report on the right screen stated, "Examination of the cylindrical screen revealed the sides were partially blocked with debris and the round end was totally blocked. Approximately 60% of the screen mesh was blocked with debris. ... The majority of the debris consisted of black flakes of various sizes, mostly with a slight curvature. ... A small number of tan colored flakes and an even smaller number of red colored flakes were also observed. ... The flakes were analyzed using X-ray energy dispersive spectroscopy (EDS). Spectra from all the flakes were similar and displayed peaks of barium, lead and silicon with traces of copper, iron, zinc, aluminum, carbon and oxygen." A piece of debris was found "that appeared to have a fibrous appearance similar to wood." The portion of the report on the left screen stated, "Examination of the cylindrical screen revealed that the sides were partially blocked with debris, although not as badly as screen 'R' and the round end was totally blocked. Approximately 30% of the screen mesh was blocked. ... The majority of the debris consisted of black flakes of various sizes, mostly with a slight curvature, similar in appearance to those illustrated in figure 3 although fewer and generally smaller. ... The spectra from EDS analysis of the flakes in [the left screen] was very similar to the spectra of the flakes found in [the right screen]." A piece of debris was found that acted "in an elastomeric manner." Particles, other than flakes were found. A particle was found to be "hard and shiny with an undulating surface." Another particle had "a fibrous appearance similar to wood." A brown colored particle with folds, "was thin and had a rubbery consistency." Shiny metal particles were found to be predominantly aluminum with a trace of iron. A particle was found that had the appearance of sandstone and displayed a spectra of "a large silicon peak, a small iron peak and traces of alumin