Service difficulty report · Landing Gear

Difficulty date
July 3, 2020
Submitted
September 25, 2020
Operation
General aviation
Aircraft
N89MA
Engine
Pwc PT6A42A
Engine time
52 hours
Propeller
Hartzl HCE4N3
Part
Landing Gear
Condition
Broken
Location
Nose
Part time
52 hours, 25 cycles
Stage of operation
LD
How discovered
O
Nature of condition
O
Precautionary procedure
O

As reported to the FAA. Reports are unverified, and codes are left as the FAA publishes them.

What was found

MECHANICAL FAILURE OF AN UNDETERMINED COMPONENT IN THE NOSE GEAR ASSEMBLY. THIS RESULTED IN THE AIRCRAFT NOT RESPONDING TO PILOT INPUTS UPON LANDING, CAUSING THE AIRCRAFT TO EXIT THE PAVED RUNWAY SURFACE & SKID 100 YARDS IN THE GRASS. IMPRESSIONS ON THE RUNWAY & THROUGH THE GRASS INDICATE A NOSE GEAR TIRE WAS NOT CENTERED & POSSIBLY COMPLETELY SIDEWAYS. 5 - M600 AIRCRAFT HAVE HAD SIMILAR RUNWAY EXCURSIONS, 3 OF WHICH ARE VERY CLOSE IN SERIAL NUMBER, & HAD BEEN EQUIPPED WITH THE COMPONENTS FOR THE SLS (GARMIN AUTOLAND). THE AIRCRAFT SERIAL NUMBERS: 4698109, 115, 117, & THE AIRCRAFT W/O THE SLS COMPONENTS: 012, AND 018. EACH AIRCRAFT HAD SIMILAR ACCIDENTS: AFTER TOUCHDOWN & AS SOON AS THE NOSE GEAR TOUCHES DOWN THE AIRCRAFT DOES NOT RESPOND TO RUDDER AND NOSEWHEEL STEERING INPUT, CAUSING RUNWAY EXCURSIONS. IMPRESSIONS INDICATING SKIDDING NOSEWHEEL ARE COMMON TO EACH. RELEASE OF THE PREVIOUS MODEL, THE PA-46-500TP, A SIMILAR PHENOMENON WAS HAPPENING & AS STATED IN SERVICE BULLETIN 1106, A CONTRIBUTING CAUSE OF THE TURNING TENDENCY HAS BEEN IDENTIFIED AS REDUCED NOSE GEAR STEERING AUTHORITY. WHICH, UNDER CERTAIN CONDITIONS, CAN ALLOW THE NOSE GEAR STEERING ROTATION TO MOMENTARILY EXCEED THE PILOT’S INPUT. A CUSTOMER INFORMATION LETTER FROM MAR 08, TITLED PA-46 OPERATIONAL & MAINTENANCE INFORMATION, NOSE GEAR STEERING, STATED THE RATE OF OCCURRENCE (I.E., NUMBER OF RUNWAY EXCURSIONS REPORTED FOR A GIVEN YEAR, DIVIDED BY THE NUMBER OF AIRCRAFT IN THE FLEET) WAS 7.6%. THE NEWER PA-46-600TP, IS HEAVIER MORE POWERFUL, HAS LARGER AND DIFFERENTLY PLACED MAIN GEAR, AND BASICALLY THE SAME NOSE GEAR SYSTEM AS THE PA-46-500TP. THUS THE SAME PHENOMENON IS HAPPENING AGAIN, DUE TO EITHER A COMPONENT FAILURE, OR INADEQUATE NOSE GEAR DESIGN FOR THE AIRFRAME.