SDR 95ZZZX6069

Service difficulty report · Spar · Piper PA12

Difficulty date
July 8, 1995
Submitted
March 26, 2000
Operation
General aviation
Aircraft
N3297M
Make and model
Piper PA12
Aircraft serial
122153
Part
Spar
Condition
Broken
Location
Lt Elev
Stage of operation
IN
Nature of condition
W
Precautionary procedure
K

As reported to the FAA. Reports are unverified, and codes are left as the FAA publishes them.

What was found

AIRCRAFT MODIFIED TO USE BALANCED PA-18 TAIL SURFACES. AIRCRAFT WAS COMPLETELY RECOVERED APPROX 30 HOURS PRIOR. UPON EXITING AIRCRAFT AFTER A ROUTINE FLIGHT, LEFT ELEVATOR WAS FOUND BENT DOWNWARD APPROX 35 DEGREES OUTBOARD OF THE OUTERMOST HINGE. UPON EXAMINATION, ELEVATOR SPAR FOUND COMPLETELY BROKEN FROM STRESS CRACKS. ALSO, FOUND OUTBOARD HINGE BRAZED ON WHICH IS NOT APPROVED FOR STRUCTURAL MEMBERS. IT IS POSSIBLE EXCESS HEAT FROM THE BRAZING COULD HAVE ALLOWED BRAZING MATERIAL TO PENETRATE BETWEEN THE GRAINS IN THE STEEL AND CAUSE THE CRACKING. AC 43.13 IA CH 2, SECTION 1, PARA 56. BRAZING IS NOT APPROVED FOR PRIMARY STRUCTURES WHERE WELDING WAS USED ORIGINALLY.

More about the Piper PA-12