Service difficulty report · Wire · Piper PA44180

Difficulty date
May 1, 2014
Submitted
May 5, 2014
Operation
General aviation
Aircraft
N446PA
Make and model
Piper PA44180
Aircraft serial
4496086
Aircraft time
6,769 hours
Engine
Lyc O360A1H6
Propeller
Hartzl HCC2Y*
Part
Wire
Condition
Broken
Location
Downlock Switch
Part time
2,239 hours, 3,420 cycles
Stage of operation
TX
How discovered
V
Nature of condition
O
Precautionary procedure
O

As reported to the FAA. Reports are unverified, and codes are left as the FAA publishes them.

What was found

DURING PREFLIGHT, THE PILOT NOTED THE RT MLG DOWNLOCK SWITCH HAD A BROKEN WIRE. MAINTENANCE REPLACED THE SWITCH. FURTHER INSPECTION OF THE FAILED SWITCH REVEALED IT HAD 3 OF 12 WIRES BROKEN. HAD THE ISSUE NOT BEEN DISCOVERED ON PREFLIGHT, THE SWITCH WOULD HAVE PROVIDED AND INTERMITTENT OR NONEXITENT GEAR DOWN-AND-LOCKED INDICATION. THIS REPAIR STATION HAS SEEN NUMEROUS FAILURES OF THIS SWITCH, SOME OF WHICH RESULTED IN INCORRECT GEAR INDICATIONS AND EMERGENCY LANDINGS. THESE SWITCHES HAVE A WIRING HARNESS COVERED IN THICK SHRINK WRAP THAT ENCOURAGES THE WIRES TO FLEX IN ONE SMALL AREA NEAR THE SWITCH BODY. THE SHRINK WRAP AND SILICONE ON THE HARNESS ALSO MAKE IT EXTREMELY DIFFICULT TO SEE ANY DAMAGE OR DEFECTS WITH THE WIRES, SO EVEN DILIGENT INSPECTION MAY NOT DETECT A BROKEN WIRE.

More about the Piper PA-44-180