Page C - 93
(1) The rotorcraft support structure, structure-float attachments, and floats should be substantiated for rational limit and ultimate ditching loads.
(2) The most severe wave heights fo r which approval is desired are to be considered. A minimum of Sea State 4 condition wave heights should be considered (reference paragraph AC 29.801 (§ 29.801) for a description of Sea State 4 conditions).
(3) The landing structural design consideration should be based on water impact with a rotor lift of not more than two-thirds of the maximum design weight acting through the center of gravity under the following conditions:
(i) Forward velocities of 0 to 30 knots (or a reduced maximum forward velocity if it can be demonstrated that a lower maximum velocity would not be exceeded in a normal one-engine-out landing).
(ii) The rotorcraft pitch attitude that would reasonably be expected to occur in service. Autorotation flight tests or one-engine-inoperative flight tests, as applicable, should be used to confirm the attitude selected. This information should be included in the Type Inspection Report.
(iii) Likely roll and yaw attitudes.
(iv) Vertical descent velocity of 5 FPS or greater.
(4) Landing load factors and water l oad distribution may be determined by water drop tests or analysis based on tests.
(5) Auxiliary or emergency float l oads should be determined by full immersion or the use of restoring moments required to react upsetting moments caused by sidewind, asymmetrical rotorcraft landing, water wave action, rotorcraft inertia, and probable structure damage and punctures considered under § 29.801. Auxiliary or emergency float loads may be determined by tests or analysis based on tests.
(6) Floats deployed after initial water c ontact are required to be substantiated by tests or analysis for the specified immersion loads (same as for (5) above and for the specified combined vertical and drag loads).
AC 29-2C, Chg 1 2/12/03 Page C - 94
SUBPART C - STRENGTH REQUIREMENTS
FATIGUE EVALUATION
AC 29.571. § 29.571 FATIGUE EVALUATION OF FLIGHT STRUCTURE .
a. Explanation . An evaluation is required to assure structural reliability of the rotorcraft in flight. AC 27 MG 11 contains background information and acceptable means of compliance with the requirements pertaining to the safe life methodology. A safe life may be assigned or the structure may be fail safe as prescribed or a combination of these may be used.
b. Procedures .
(1) The fatigue evaluation requires c onsideration of the following factors:
(i) Identification of the stru cture/components to be considered.
(ii) The stress during operating conditions.
(iii) The operating spectr um or frequency of occurrence.
(iv) Fatigue strength, and/or fa tigue crack propagation characteristics, residual strength of the cracked structure.
(2) Since the design limits, e.g., rotor RPM (maximum and minimum), airspeed, and blade angles (thrust, weight, etc.) affect the fatigue life of the rotor system, it is necessary that flight conditions be conducted at limits that are appropriate for the particular rotorcraft and at the correct combination of these limits. It will be the responsibility of flight test personnel to determine that the flight strain program includes conditions of flight at the various combinations of rotor RPM, airspeed, thrust, etc., that will be representative of the limits used in service. The flight test personnel should assure that the severity of the maneuvers to be investigated is such that actual service use will not be more severe. Flight test verification may be achieved through:
(i) Flying a representative set of maneuvers with the applicant’s pilot in the test aircraft at noncritical combinations of weight, CG, and speed. (An FAA/AUTHORITY letter for specific test authorization would ordinarily be required.)
(ii) Flying a representative set of maneuvers with the applicant’s pilot in a similar (certified) model to assess and agree upon the required maneuvers, control deflections, and aircraft rates. The required maneuvers or conditions will be specified in the flight strain program plan.
(iii) Flying a chase aircraft which has a flight envelope appropriate to allow visual confirmation of the proposed and programmed flight maneuvers.
Page C - 95
(iv) Observation of telemetered flight data to assure desired control deflections, rates, and aircraft attitudes.
(v) Some combinations of it ems b(2)(i) through b(2)(iv) above.
(3) Assessing the operation spectrum and the flight loads or strain measurement program will involve airframe, propulsion, and flight test personnel.
(4) Variation in the operating or loading spectrum among models, and variations in the spectrum for a particular model rotorcraft, should be evaluated.
Figure AC 27 MG 11-7 contains typical flight load measurement program conditions to be investigated. An example of a twin turbine spectrum is presented in Figure AC 27 MG 11-9. The tables should be used only as a guide and should be modified as necessary for each particular rotorcraft design.
(5) The difference in loading spectr um for different models that may be anticipated is illustrated by comparing the percentage of time assigned to level flight conditions, specifically 0.8 VH to 1.0 VH for three different rotorcraft designs where VH is the maximum airspeed at maximum continuous power in level flight. The first column applies to a single-piston-engine powered small rotorcraft used in utility operations. The second was obtained from data for a single-turbine-engine powered seven-place small business and utility rotorcraft. The third was obtained from data for a twin-engine-powered 13 passenger transport rotorcraft. It should be noted that the level flight percentage of occurrences shown in the table below for the turbine utility business and turbine transport rotorcraft are examples of a particular design. The high percentage of time shown in this flight regime could be unconservative for some designs, especially if the stresses under these design conditions produce an infinite fatigue life for the particular component. The fatigue spectrum percentage of occurrences may be modified according to the intended operation usage of the rotorcraft. However, a conservative application should be considered. This variation illustrates the "tailoring" of the loading spectrum for the type of rotorcraft and the anticipated usage.
AC 29-2C, Chg 1 2/12/03 Page C - 96 FIGURE AC 29.571-1
Comparison Percent of Time in Level Flight
Piston Utility Turbine Utility Business
Twin Turbine Transport
0.8 V NE 25% 0.8 V H 16% 0.8 V H 15%
1.0 V H 15% 0.9 V H 21% 0.9 V H 20%
1.0 V NE 3% 1.0 V H 24% 1.0 V H 38% Total 43% 61% 73%
This variation illustrates the “tailoring” of the loading spectrum for the type of rotorcraft and the anticipated usage.
(6) External cargo operations ar e a unique and demanding operation. A “logging” operator may use 50 maximum power applications per flight hour to move logs from a cutting site to a hauling site. Power is used to accelerate, decelerate, or hover prior to load release. Lifting loads over an obstruction or natural barrier is another example of very frequent high power applications for takeoff and for hovering over the release area. Similar types of operations require flight loads data to assess the effects on fatigue critical components.
(7) Frequently the applicant may reques t approval of a gross weight for an external cargo configuration that exceeds the standard configuration gross weight. The external cargo VNE is typically significantly lower than the standard configuration VNE possibly due to adverse effects on flight loads at the increased weight.
(8) The impact of the external car go operation on standard configuration limits should be assessed to determine whether or not the component service lives will be affected. The assessment may be done by calculating an “external cargo configuration” service life for each critical component. The lowest service life obtained from standard configuration flight loads data and loading spectrum, or from external cargo configuration flight loads data and loading spectrum is generally the approved service life. This procedure avoids prorating the operating time between the two types of operations. This procedure is necessary since the regulatory maintenance and operating rules do not require recording time in service for the different types of operations.
(9) The applicant should plan to conduct a flight loads survey program for both a standard configuration and an external cargo configuration, if appropriate. This procedure will avoid delays associated with reinstallation and calibration of equipment.
Page C - 97 AC 29.571A. §29.571 (Amendment 29-28) FATIGUE EVALUATION OF STRUCTURE.
a. Explanation . Amendment 29-28 adds a requirement to substantiate tolerance to flaws during the fatigue evaluation of structure. A flaw tolerant safe-life evaluation or a fail-safe (residual strength after flaw growth) evaluation is required by § 29.571(b) unless “the applicant establishes that these fatigue flaw tolerant methods for a particular structure cannot be achieved within the limitations of geometry, inspectability, and good design practices.”
b. Procedures .
(1) AC 29 MG 11 provides acceptabl e general procedures for complying with Amendment 29-28.
(2) Specific rotorcraft drive system gear fatigue evaluation procedures, which supplement Appendix 1, follow:
(i) Fatigue test evidence is necessary for the fatigue evaluation of gears.
The test evidence should be provided by rotating tests of complete gearbox specimens operating under power. The tests provide the basis for analysis leading to the establishment of safe-life.
(ii) The tests are conducted spec ifically for the purpose of gear tooth evaluation, and components subjected to the tests do not have to be considered serviceable on completion of the test. Excessive wear on bearings and shafts and marking (including spalling) of bearings and gear teeth are acceptable provided no fatigue damage is evident on the gear teeth. However, fatigue damage other than tooth fatigue should be considered for test validity and the integrity of the affected part confirmed as necessary.
(iii) The test conditions (torque versus number of cycles) should permit the setting of mean strength curve(s) to be associated with each primary gear in the drive train. The minimum test condition should encompass those power levels for which repeated application in service is expected under normal conditions. The S-n curve(s), for the material and type of gear, should be reduced by a factor of safety to take into account material and manufacturing variability. The factored curve will then be used in conjunction with the flight power spectrum to determine a life (limited or unlimited) for the gears in the primary drive system.
(iv) Special procedures, which do not affect fatigue evaluation of the gear teeth, may be allowed to facilitate completion of the test provided they have been justified and they do not affect life determination. These include periodic interruption for inspection, replacement of non-critical parts and the use of special lubricants, special cooling systems, and methods to prevent unrepresentative deflections at the test torque levels.
AC 29-2C, Chg 1 2/12/03 Page C - 98
(v) From evidence in relation to the strength of steel gears of conventional design, it is accepted that adequate fatigue strength can be demonstrated by the use of the above safety factor of 1.4 for a single test, 1.35 for two tests, 1.32 for three tests, and 1.3 for four or more tests. Where several tests are to be conducted, specimens should be selected from different manufacturing batches if practicable.
(vi) Demonstration of infinite lif e for gear teeth will normally require tests of a minimum of 107 cycles duration at factored power levels. Use of shorter duration tests should be justified.
Page D - 1 CHAPTER 2. PART 29
AIRWORTHINESS STANDARDS
TRANSPORT CATEGORY ROTORCRAFT
SUBPART D - DESIGN AND CONSTRUCTION
DESIGN AND CONSTRUCTION - GENERAL
AC 29.601. § 29.601 DESIGN .
a. Explanation .
(1) This rule requires that no design f eatures or details be used that experience has shown to be hazardous or unreliable.
(2) Further, the rule requires that the suitability of each questionable design detail and part must be established by tests.
b. Procedures .
(1) This rule is met partially by a review of service history of earlier model rotorcraft, or for a new model, review of service experience of models with similar design features. Specifically, this rule covers “features or details” such as the following:
(i) Seat track-to-seat interface fittings should have adequate locking devices to prevent both premature structural failure and premature unlatching.
(ii) Seat belt and harness shoul d be of a type and construction that service experience has shown to be easy to don, unlatch, and remove. They should also be of a type that is reliable, does not interfere with egress, and does not sustain unnecessary wear and tear under normal operations.
(iii) Metallic parts less than a certain thickness gauge and composite materials less than a certain number of plies should not be used. The minimum thickness and number of plies should be based to a large degree on service experience (normal wear and tear) with similar designs.
(2) The effects of service wear on t he loading of critical components should be considered. Flight testing, ground testing, and analyses may be used in these considerations.
(3) Tests are required for details and parts which the applicant chooses to use after questions have arisen concerning their suitability.
AC 29-2C, Chg 2 4/25/06 Page D - 2 AC 29.602 § 29.602 CRITICAL PARTS .
a. Explanation .
(1) Critical parts requirements apply to structural components, rotor drive systems, rotors, and mechanical control systems.
(2) The objective of identifying critical parts is to ensure that critical parts are controlled during design, manufacture, and throughout their service life so that the risk of failure in service is minimized by ensuring that the critical parts maintain the critical characteristics on which certification is based.
(3) Definitions with respect to § 29.602:
(i) The use of the word “could” in paragraph 29.602(a) of the rule means that this failure assessment should consider the effect of flight regime (i.e., forward flight, hover, etc.). The operational environment need not be considered.
(ii) With respect to this rule, the term “catastrophic” means the inability to conduct an autorotation to a safe landing, without exceptional piloting skills, assuming a suitable landing surface is available.
(iii) The use of the word “and” in paragraph 29.602(a) of the rule means the part must have both a catastrophic failure mode together with one or more critical characteristics.
(iv) With respect to this rule, t he term “part” means one piece, or two or more pieces permanently joined together.
(v) With respect to this rule, t he term “critical characteristic” means any dimension, tolerance, finish, material, or any manufacturing or inspection process, or other feature which cannot tolerate variation from type design requirements and, if nonconforming, would cause failure of the critical part.
(4) Many rotorcraft manufacturers alr eady have procedures in place within their companies for handling “critical parts.” These plans may be required by their dealings with other customers, frequently military (e.g., US DoD, UK MoD, Italian MoD).
Although these plans may have slightly different definitions of “critical parts” which have sometimes been called “Flight Safety Parts,” “Critical Parts,” “Vital Parts,” or “Identifiable Parts,” they have in the past been accepted as meeting the intent of this requirement and providing the expected level of safety. It is acceptable for these plans to use alternative names and terminology provided they meet the intent of this requirement.
b. Procedures . The rotorcraft manufacturer should establish a Critical Parts Plan that identifies and controls the critical characteristics. The policies and procedures which constitute that plan should be such as to ensure that--
Page D - 3
(1) All critical parts of the rotorcraft are identified by means of an appropriate failure assessment and a Critical Parts List is established.
(2) Documentation draws the attention of the personnel involved in the design, manufacture, maintenance, inspection, and overhaul of a critical part to the special nature of the part and details the relevant special instructions. For example all drawings, work sheets, inspection documents, etc., could be prominently annotated with the words "Critical Part" or equivalent and the Instructions for Continued Airworthiness and Overhaul Manuals (if applicable) should clearly identify critical parts and include the needed maintenance and overhaul instructions. The documentation should:
(i) Contain comprehensive instructions for the maintenance, inspection and overhaul of critical parts and emphasize the importance of these special procedures;
(ii) Indicate to operators and overhaulers that unauthorized repairs or modifications to critical parts may have hazardous consequences;
(iii) Emphasize the need for careful handling and protection against damage or corrosion during maintenance, overhaul, storage, and transportation and accurate recording and control of service life (if applicable);
(iv) Require notification of the manufacturer of any unusual wear or deterioration of critical parts and the return of affected parts for investigation when appropriate;
(3) Procedures should be established for identifying and controlling critical characteristics.
(4) To the extent needed for control of critical characteristics, procedures and processes for manufacturing critical parts (including test articles) are defined (for example material source, forging procedures, machining operations and sequence, inspection techniques, and acceptance and rejection criteria). Procedures for changing these manufacturing procedures should also be established.
( 5) Any changes to the manufacturing procedures, to the design of a critical part, to the approved operating environment, or to the design loading spectrum are evaluated to establish the effects, if any, on the fatigue evaluation of the part.
( 6) Materials review procedures for critical parts (i.e., procedures for determining the disposition of parts having manufacturing errors or material flaws) are in accordance with paragraphs (4) and (5) above.
( 7) Critical parts are identified as required, and relevant records relating to the identification are maintained such that it is possible to establish the manufacturing history of the individual parts or batches of parts.
AC 29-2C, Chg 2 4/25/06 Page D - 4 ( 8) The critical characteristics of critical parts produced in whole or in part by suppliers are maintained.
AC 29.603. § 29.603 (Amendm ent 29-17) MATERIALS.
a. Explanation . The rule requires that the suitability and durability of materials, the failure of which could adversely affect safety, must be determined by three-fold considerations:
(1) Considerations bas ed on experience or tests.
(2) Meeting approved specifications.
(3) Taking into account environmental conditions such as temperature and humidity.
b. Procedures .
(1) Experience may be used to show a material’s resistance to wear and deterioration from environmental effects (environmental effects include both natural environmental effects such as exposure to sunlight, water, salt spray, etc., and installation environmental effects such as exposure to fuel, hydraulic fluids, deicing fluids, etc.). Installation environmental effects should consider both direct exposure contact and expected migration of potentially deleterious fluids and compounds.
Testing for environmental effects may use either coupon testing, full-scale testing, or a combination. A combination of testing and experience may also be used.
(i) MIL-HDBK’s-5, -17, and - 23 include consideration of some environmental effects and contain reference to additional methods of testing for environmental effects.
(ii) The use of AC 20-107A, Composite Aircraft Structure, is recommended for environmental and damage tolerance considerations of advanced composite materials. (Also see paragraph AC 29 MG 8.)
(iii) The effects of excessive w ear and delamination of elastomeric and self-lubricated bearings used in critical load carrying applications in relation to redistribution of loading should be considered.
(2) Where possible, materials that meet widely accepted specifications such as AISI, SAE, MIL, or AMS and alloys which have favorable experience or tests should be used. Where company-developed materials are used, approved specifications are required to ensure the developed properties are duplicated in each lot of material. Raw material quality control is defined in FAA Order N8020-11 which is scheduled to be integrated into a forthcoming advisory circular. Documented specification usage is necessary to maintain quality assurance of materials.
Page D - 5
(3) Section 29.613 concerns strengt h properties and design values. (See paragraph AC 29.613.)
AC 29.605. § 29.605 ( Amendment 29-17) FABRICATION METHODS.
a. Explanation . The basic requirement of this rule is that the methods of fabrication must produce sound structure and produce it consistently.
(1) A process specification is requir ed for fabrication processes requiring close control.
(2) A test program is explicitly requi red for each new aircraft fabrication method.
b. Procedures .
(1) The approved specifications required by this rule may either be established government/industry specifications such as MIL, AISI, ASTM, or SAE, or the specifications may be company-developed proprietary specifications. Sufficient data should be provided to the FAA/AUTHORITY aircraft engineering offices to show that the desired features are provided by the process specification. In addition, sufficient process controls, inspections, and tests should be coordinated with FAA/AUTHORITY manufacturing inspection personnel to ensure that continued quality of the process is provided.
(2) In addition to the examples given by the rule; i.e., gluing, spot welding, and heat treating process, specifications should also be prepared for types of welding other than spot welding, for platings of metals, for protective finishes (other than decorative), for sealing, and for unique fabrication methods such as those used for composite materials.
(3) The required test programs should c onsider static strength effects, fatigue strength effects, and environmental effects as appropriate to the processes.
(4) During the fabrication of advanced composite materials, the effects of fabrication anomalies (i.e., disbonds, voids, porosity) should be considered. Special nondestruct testing inspection techniques and procedures should be developed to cover fabrication with allowable anomalies and permitted repair procedures. (See also paragraph AC 29 MG 8.)
AC 29.607. § 29.607 (Amendment 29-5) FASTENERS .
a. Explanation . Section 29.607 of Amendment 29-5 requires dual locking removable fasteners in critical locations. A nonfriction locking device is specifically required in any bolt subject to rotation, as stated in the rules.
Page D - 6
b. Procedures . Advisory Circular 20-71, Dual Locking Devices or Fasteners, December 8, 1970, contains information, procedures, and means of complying with § 29.607 of Amendment 29-5.
AC 29.609. § 29.609 PROTECTION OF STRUCTURE .
a. Explanation . The structure should be suitably protected as specified in the rule to maintain its design strength. Ventilation and drainage provisions must be provided as specified in the rule. Overboard drains should be furnished for corrosive or waste liquids. Drains for flammable fluids are specified in other rules such as §§ 29.999 and
29.1187.
b. Procedures .
(1) The structure may be preserved, pai nted, or treated with chemical films to protect it from strength deterioration. An approved process specification should be used for these types of treatments.
(2) Parts may be plated or chemically tr eated, such as anodized, for protection.
An evaluation and substantiation may be required to assure the structure or parts are not adversely affected during, or as a result of, the plating or treatment process.
(§ 29.605 concerns approval of process specifications and fabrication methods.)
(3) Plating or material surface har dness or composition changes may require fatigue substantiation to assure the fatigue strength is not altered or is otherwise properly assessed. An approved process specification should be used for these types of treatments.
(4) To prevent water accumulation, drain holes should be placed at possible dams such as bulkheads, and at low points in the fuselage and in the stabilizing surfaces.
(5) Control tubes and tubes used as primary mount structures (i.e., transmission support structure and engine mount structure) should be designed to prevent entry and collection of corrosive fluids or vapor, including water.
(i) A closed insert in each tube end may be used.
(ii) A sealant applied around the tube ends and around each rivet head may be used.
(6) Overboard drains should discharge clear of the entire rotorcraft. Dyed water discharged in flight, may be used to assure fluids are properly drained.