Page D - 139 FIGURE AC 29.865-1 (continued) SUMMARY OF PART 133 ROTORCRAFT LOAD COMBINATIONS CERTIFIABLE UNDER § 29.865
CLASS D
Basic Definition and Intended Use
Single Point Suspension External Airborne Personnel Load Is defined by § 1.1, as a load combination in which the external load is other than Class A, B, or C and has been specifically approved by the Administrator for that operation. This load combination includes human cargo. For human cargo operations, the payload which typically consists of personnel and their containment device is suspended from a hook or a similar device during all or part of a flight. The hook may be rigidly attached to the rotorcraft or may be attached to a movable hoist cable and the hoist itself rigidly attached to the rotorcraft. Typical use is for transfer of personnel to a ship. Carrying devices may transport one or more persons.
Typical carrying devices are vest and straps, baskets, life preservers with straps and attachment devices, cages, or a suspended container.
Typical Load Limits
Certification limit load is NZW X Maximum Substantiable External load. NZW varies from 2.5 at max gross weight to 3.5 at minimum gross weight. (See Procedures (2)). Load is usually limited by hoist allowable or by personnel carrying device allowable (See Procedure (2), (3), and
(10)).
Quick Release Requirements
Section § 29.865(b) does not currently contain quick release requirements for Class D rotorcraft
- load combinations, but § 133.45(e)(4) requires that a primary emergency release system control device (requiring two distinct actions) be installed on a primary control or be installed near a designated crew member’s station. Also, a manual quick-release system backup actuation device must be available and readily accessible.
Certification Requirements -- Considerations
- For loads other than Class A, B, or C loads. Is used for external personnel loads.
- § 29.865 has not been revised to reflect this category’s requirements (it is currently covered by § 133.45(e)(4) only).
- Unless a public-use rotorcraft is being certified, only transport Category A rotorcraft are eligible to use this load category.
- Transport Category A rotorcraft must be certified for an OEI weight and altitude envelope which becomes the maximum envelope that can be used for Class D operations. This is currently required for a Class D rating by § 133.45(e)(1).
- Personnel lifting devices must be approved separately or as part of the certification project.
AC 29-2C, Chg 2 4/25/06 Page D - 140 FIGURE AC 29.865-1 (continued) CLASS D (continued)
- Devices must carry personnel internally or secure them safely in a harness or equivalent device.
- Flight Manual Restrictions - § 133.47 requires a rotorcraft load combination flight manual supplement. Any flight envelope restrictions from § 29.865 should be a part of this supplement.
- Load limit placards are required by § 29.865(c).
- Flight envelope restriction placards may also be required.
- Certifiable external load capacity is further limited by §§ 133.41, 133.43 and 133.45(e)(3), the load limit of the personnel carrying device.
- Quick release devices must be approved and be operable on a nonhazard basis by the pilot or a designated crewmember per §§ 133.44(c)(6) and 29.865(b).
- The lifting device must have an emergency release requiring two distinct actions § 133.45(e)(4).
- Manual backup must be accessible and reliable.
- Rotorcraft must be equipped to allow direct intercom among all crewmembers per § 133.45(e)(2). This may affect § 29.865 indirectly if human error or placarding could cause inadvertent load release or retention.
- Effect of maximum suspended load and its attachment to rotorcraft structure on load paths, loads and fatigue of existing structure should be determined.
- TIA testing may be necessary to determine whether or not the system performs as intended and if placards and flight manual supplements are adequate.
AC 29.865B. § 29.865 (Amendment 29- 43) EXTERNAL LOAD ATTACHING MEANS.
a. Background . The standards for external load attaching means, transport and normal category rotorcraft were originally contained in Subpart D, "Airworthiness Requirements of 14 CFR Part 133, Rotorcraft External-Load Operations." Amendment 29-12, issued in 1977, added a new § 29.865, which moved these standards from Part 133 to Part 29. An identical transfer occurred in 1977 for Part 27. Amendment 29-26, issued in 1990, clarified the intent of Amendment 29-12 but did not change it substantively. Transport Categories A and B and Normal Category rotorcraft were initially used under Part 133 operations, and after Amendment 133-6, restricted category rotorcraft were also included under Part 133 operations. The carriage of persons external to the rotorcraft for hire first came about when a Part 29 operator, exempt from Part 133, transferred harbor pilots to and from ships by a hoist and sling.
The exemption was granted to study the feasibility of passenger transfer outside of the cabin. Grant of the exemption was based, in part, on similar, prior operations that had been conducted in Europe and Africa, for hire, with helicopters approved by the appropriate authorities and, in part, on similar military and public helicopter operations, not for hire, in the U.S. Subsequently, Amendment 133-9,adopted in January 1987, established a new Class D rotorcraft load combination (RLC) for transporting loads
Page D - 141 other than Class A, B, or C that are specifically approved by the Administrator external to the rotorcraft. Amendment 133-9 also provided for the limitations and conditions for transport of external loads other than Class A, B, or C and the necessary, associated safety requirements. Part 29 has recently been changed to reflect RLC Class D requirements. Also, the scope and thus the title of the standard have changed from "External load attaching means" to "External loads" to reflect the more comprehensive approach for external loads required to assure the proper level-of safety.
b. Explanation .
(1) This advisory material contains guidance for the certification of helicopter external load attaching means and load carrying systems to be used in conjunction with operating rules such as Part 133, "Rotorcraft External Load Operations." Subpart D of Part 133 contains supplemental airworthiness requirements. 14 CFR Part 1 defines the four RLC classes that are approvable under Part 133 operating rules and that are eligible for certification under § 29.865. The four RLC classes are summarized in figure AC 29.865-1 and discussed in paragraph d. Under the operating rules RLC Classes A, B, and C are eligible, under specific restrictions, for both human external cargo (HEC) and nonhuman external cargo (NHEC) operations. However, under U.S. operating rules, only RLC Class D is eligible for transporting HEC for compensation. Paragraph AC 29.25 (reference § 29.25) also concerns, in part, jettisonable external cargo.
(2) Section 29.865 provides a minimum level of safety for transport category rotorcraft designs to be used with operating rules such as Part 133. Certain aspects of operations such as microwave tower and high-line wirework may also be regulated separately by other Federal agencies such as DOE, EPA, and OSHA or by other international entities. For applications that could come under multiple agency regulation (or regulation by other entities), special certification emphasis will be required by both the applicant and the approving authority to assure all relevant safety requirements are identified and met. Potential additional requirements, where thought to exist, are noted herein.
c. Definitions.
(1) Applicable cargo type. The ca rgo type (i.e., non-human external cargo (NHEC), human external cargo (HEC), or both) that each RLC Class is eligible to use by regulation (Figure AC –29.865-1 contains explicit definitions for U.S. Part 133 Operations).
(2) Backup Quick-Release Subsystem (BQRS). The secondary or "second choice" subsystem used to perform a normal or emergency jettison of external cargo.
(3) Cargo. The part of any Rotorc raft-Load Combination that is removable, changeable, and is attached to the rotorcraft by an approved means.
AC 29-2C, Chg 2 4/25/06 Page D - 142
(4) Cargo hook. A hook that can be rated for both HEC and NHEC. It is typically used by being fixed directly to a designated hardpoint on the rotorcraft.
(5) Dual actuation device (DAD). This is a sequential control that requires two distinct actions in series for actuation. One example is removal of a lock pin followed by a "then free" switch or lever activation for load release to occur (in this scenario, a load release switch protected only by an uncovered switch guard is not acceptable). For jettisonable HEC applications a simple covered switch does not qualify as a DAD.
Familiarity with covered switches allows the pilot to both open and activate the switch in one motion. This has led to inadvertent load release.
(6) Emergency jettison (or complete load release). The intentional, instantaneous release of NHEC or HEC in a preset sequence by the quick release system (QRS) that is normally performed to achieve safer aircraft operation in an emergency.
(7) External fixture. A structure exter nal to and in addition to the basic airframe that does not have true jettison capability and has no significant payload capability in addition to its own weight. An example is an agricultural spray- boom. These configurations are not approvable as "External Loads" under § 29.865.
(8) Hoist. A hoist is a device that exer ts a vertical pull, usually through a cable and drum system (i.e., a pull that does not typically exceed a 30-degree cone measured around the z-rotorcraft axis).
(9) Hoist demonstration cycle (or "one cycle"). The complete extension and retraction of at least 95 percent of the actual cable length, or 100 percent of the cable length capable of being used in service (i.e., that would activate any extension or retraction limiting devices), whichever is greater.
(10) Hoist load-speed combinations. Some hoists are designed so that the extension and retraction speed slows as the load increases or nears the end of a cable extension. Other hoist designs maintain a constant speed as the load is varied. In the latter design, the load-speed combination simply means the variation in load at the constant design speed of the hoist.
(11) Human external cargo (HEC). A person(s) that at some point in the operation is carried external to the rotorcraft. (Figure AC 29.865-1 contains explicit definitions for U.S. Part 133 Operations). See Nonhuman external Cargo (NHEC).
(12) Nonhuman external cargo (NHEC) . Any external cargo operation that does not at any time involve a person(s) carried external to the rotorcraft (Figure AC
29.865-1 contains explicit definitions for U.S. Part 133 Operations).
(13) Normal jettison (or selective load release). The intentional release, normally at optimum jettison conditions, of an NHEC.
Page D - 143
(14) Personnel carrying device system (PCDS). The entire attached or suspended system used to carry HEC. This is any HEC carrying configuration such as a suspended (e.g., hoist, cable, harness) HEC system or an attached (e.g., a rigid basket or cage attached to skids) HEC system. (See TSO C167)
(15) Primary Quick-Release Subsystem (PQRS). The primary or "first choice" subsystem used to perform a normal or emergency jettison of external cargo.
(16) Quick-release system (QRS). The entire release system for jettisonable external cargo, (i.e., the sum total of both the primary and backup quick-release subsystems). The QRS consists of all components including the controls, the release devices, and everything in between.
(17) Rescue hook (or hook). A hook that can be rated for both HEC and NHEC. It is typically used in conjunction with a hoist or equivalent system.
(18) Rotorcraft-load combination (RLC ). The combination of a rotorcraft and an external-load, including the external-load attaching means. Rotorcraft-load combinations are designated as Class A, Class B, Class C, and Class D, as follows:
(i) Class A rotorcraft-load combinat ion means one in which the external load cannot move freely, cannot be jettisoned, and does not extend below the landing gear.
(ii) Class B rotorcraft-load combinat ion means one in which the external load is jettisonable and is lifted free of land or water during the rotorcraft operation.
(iii) Class C rotorcraft-load combination means one in which the external load is jettisonable and remains in contact with land or water during the rotorcraft operation.
(iv) Class D rotorcraft-load combinat ion means one in which the externalload is other than a Class A, B, or C and has been specifically approved by the Administrator for that operation (i.e., HEC operations for which the operator is receiving compensation from the person being transported).
(19) Spider: A spider is a system of attaching a lowering cable or rope or a harness to a NHEC (or HEC) RLC to eliminate unwanted flight dynamics during operations. A spider usually has four or more legs (or load paths) that connect to various points of a PCDS to equalize loading and prevent spinning, twisting, or other undesirable flight dynamics.
(20) True jettison capability. The ability to safely release an external load using an approved QRS in 30 seconds or less.
AC 29-2C, Chg 2 4/25/06 Page D - 144 NOTE: In all cases, a PQRS should release the external load in less than 5 seconds.
Many PQRS's will release the external load in milliseconds, once the activation device is triggered. However a manual BQRS such as a set of cable cutters could take as much as 30 seconds to release the external load. The 30 seconds would be measured starting from the time the release command is given and ending when the external load is cut loose.
(21) True payload capability. The ability of an external device or tank to carry a significant payload in addition to its own weight. If little or no payload can be carried, the external device or tank is an external fixture (see definition).
(22) Type inspection authorization (TIA). This is FAA Form 8110-1. It is used for authorizing official ground inspections and flight tests necessary to fulfill the requirements for type certification or supplemental type certification. Order 8110.4, Chapter 2, Section 1, Paragraph 16, states the criteria for TIA issuance.
(23) Winch. A winch is a device t hat can employ a cable and drum or other means to exert a horizontal (i.e., x-rotorcraft axis) pull. However, since a winch can be used to perform a hoist function by use of a 90-degree cable direction change device (such as a pulley or pulley system), a winch system may be considered a hoist.
d. Procedures . The following certification procedures are provided in the most general form. Where there are significant differences between the cargo types, the differences are highlighted.
(1) General Compliance Procedures for § 29.865 : The applicant should clearly identify both the Rotorcraft Load Combinations (RLC) and the applicable cargo types (NHEC or HEC) for which application is being made. The structural loads and operating envelopes for each RLC class and applicable cargo type should be determined and used to formulate the flight manual supplement and basic loads report.
The applicant should show by analysis, test, or both, that the rotorcraft structure, the external load attachment means, and the PCDS, if applicable, meet the specific requirements of §§ 29.865, 133.41, 133.43, 133.45, and the other relevant requirements of Part 29 for the proposed operating envelope.
NOTE: It is possible, if approved, to carry both HEC and NHEC externally, simultaneously as two separate external loads. However, in no case is it intended that the approved Maximum Internal Gross Weight be exceeded for any approved HEC configuration (or combined NHEC and HEC configuration) in normal operations.
Reliability of the external load system. The failure of the external load system, including the PCDS where applicable, and its attachments to the rotorcraft should be shown to be extremely improbable (i.e., 1 x 10-9 failures per flight) for all failure modes that could cause a catastrophic failure, serious injury, or fatality anywhere in the total airborne system. All significant failure modes of lesser consequence should be shown to be
Page D - 145 improbable (i.e., 1 x 10-5 failures per flight). An acceptable method of achieving this goal is to submit and achieve approval of all of the following:
(i) A failure modes and effects analysis (FMEA) showing that all potential failure modes of the airborne system which may result in catastrophic failures, serious injuries, or fatalities are extremely improbable and any less significant failures are improbable.
(ii) A repetitive test of all func tional devices that cycles these devices under critical structural conditions, operational conditions, or a combination of both at least 30 times.
(iii) An environmental qualificat ion review over the proposed operating environment.
AC 29-2C, Chg 2 4/25/06 Page D - 146
Figure AC 29.865B-1 U.S. OPERATIONAL (PART 133) ROTORCRAFT-LOAD COMBINATION
VERSUS APPLICABLE CARGO TYPE DATA AND DEFINITION SUMMARY
Possible RLCs and Cargo Types Category “A” Rating and One Engine Inoperative (OEI) Hover Capability
Notes Direct 2-Way Voice Communications Required See Paragraph d(10) RLC A, HEC No Note 2 No RLC A, NHEC No N/A RLC B, HEC No Note 2 No RLC B, NHEC No N/A RLC C, HEC No Note 2 No RLC C, NHEC No N/A RLC D, HEC Yes, See Paragraph d(12) Note 1, 3, 4 Yes
NOTES:
1. A person(s), being carried or transported for compensation outside the rotorcraft can only be carried as a Class D RLC.
2. A person who is not being carried or transported for compensation, is knowledgeable of the risks involved, and at some point is required to be outside of the rotorcraft in order to fulfill the mission. These persons are considered as RLC Class A, B, or C HEC as appropriate to the operation.
3. The rotorcraft is approved to the Category A engine isolation requirements of Part 29 and have One Engine Inoperative/Out of Ground Effect (OEI/OGE) hover performance capability, for the requested operating and weight envelopes, to be eligible for certification to the Class D RLC. (Reference Paragraph d(12))
4. A Class D RLC operation may be conducted with an external cargo design having a physical configuration that meets the definitions of § 1.1 for RLC Class A, B, or C.
Page D - 147
(2) § 29.865(a) Static Structural Substantiation Procedures: The following static structural substantiation methods should be used.
(i) Critical basic load determination . The critical basic loads and corresponding flight envelope are determined by statically substantiating the gross weight range limits, the corresponding vertical limit load factors (NZW) and safety factors applicable for the type of external load for which the application is being made.
Note: In cases where NHEC or HEC can have more than one shape, center-of-gravity, center-of-lift, or be carried at more than one distance in flight from the rotorcraft attachment, a critical configuration for certification purposes may not be determinable.
If such a critical configuration can be determined, it may be examined for approval as a "worst case" to satisfy a particular certification criterion or several criteria, as appropriate. If such a critical configuration can not be determined, the extreme points of the operational – external load configuration envelope should be examined with consideration given to any other points within the envelope which experience or other rational would indicate should be investigated.
(ii) Vertical Li mit and Ultimate Load Factors. The basic NZW is converted to ultimate load by multiplying the maximum vertical limit load by the appropriate safety factor. (For restricted category approvals, see guidance in paragraph AC 29 MG 5.)
This ultimate load is used to substantiate all existing structure affected by, and all added structure associated with, the load carrying device, its attachments and its cargo.
Casting factors, fitting factors, and other dynamic load factors should be applied where appropriate.
(A) NHEC applications. In most cases, it is acceptable to perform a standard static analysis to show compliance. A vertical limit load factor (NZW) of 2.5 g is typical for heavy gross weight NHEC hauling configurations. (reference § 29.337). This vertical load factor should be applied to the maximum external load for which application is being made, together with a minimum safety factor of 1.5.
(B) HEC applications. If a safety factor 3.0 or more is used, it is acceptable to perform a standard static analysis to show compliance. The safety factor should be applied to the yield strength of the weakest component in the system (QRS, PCDS, and attachment load path). If a safety factor of less than 3.0 is used, both an analysis and a full-scale ultimate load test of relevant parts of the system should be submitted.
Since HEC applications typically involve lower gross weight configurations, a higher vertical limit load factor is required to assure that limit load is not exceeded in service.
The applicant should use either the conservative value of 3.5 g’s or an analytically derived maximum vertical limit load factor for the requested operating envelope. Linear interpolation between the vertical load factors of maximum and minimum design weights
AC 29-2C, Chg 2 4/25/06 Page D - 148 may be used. However, in no case may the vertical limit load factor be less than 2.5 g's for any RLC application for HEC.
For the purpose of structural analysis or test, assume a 223-pound man as the minimum weight of each occupant carried as HEC.
Note: If the HEC is engaged in work tasks that employ devices of significant added weight (heavy backpacks, tools, fire extinguishers, etc.), the total weight of the 223-pound man and equipment should be assumed in the structural analysis or test.
(iii) Critical Structural Case . For applications involving more than one RLC class or cargo type, the structural substantiation is required only for the most critical case. The most critical case should be determined by rational analysis.
(iv) Jettisonable Loads. For the substantiating analyses or tests of all jettisonable RLC external loads, including HEC, the maximum external load should be applied at the maximum angle that can be achieved in service but not less than 30 degrees. The angle should be measured from the sling-load-line to rotorcraft vertical axis (z axis) and may be in any direction that can be achieved in service. The 30-degree angle may be reduced in some or all directions if it is impossible to obtain due to physical constraints or operating limitations. The maximum allowable cable angle should be determined and approved. The angle approval should be based on structural requirements, mechanical interference limits, and flight handling characteristics over the most critical conditions and combinations of conditions in the approved flight envelope.
(v) Hoist system limit load .
Note: In cases where hoist cables or long-line cables are utilized, a new dynamic system is established. Characteristics of the system should be evaluated to assure that either no hazardous failure modes exist or that they are acceptably minimized. For example, the cable or long line may exhibit a natural frequency that could be excited by sources internal to the overall structural system (i.e., the rotorcraft) or by sources external to the system. Another example is the loading effect of the cable acting as a spring between the rotorcraft and the suspended external load.
(A) Determine the basic loads that result in the failure or unspooling of the hoist or its installation, respectively.
NOTE: This determination should be based on static strength and any significant dynamic load magnification factors.
(B) Select the lower of the two values as the ultimate load of the hoist system installation.
Page D - 149 (C) Divide the selected ultimate load by 1.5 to determine the true structural limit load of the system.
(D) Determine the manufacturer's approved (or applicants applied for) "limit design safety factor." Divide this factor into the true structural limit load (from (C) above) to determine the hoist system's working (or placarded) limit load.
(E) Compare the system's deriv ed limit load to the applied for one "g" payload multiplied by the maximum downward vertical load factor (NZWMAX) to determine the critical payload's limit value.
(F) The critical limit payload s hould be equal to or less than the system's derived limit load for the installation to be approvable.
(3) § 29.865(b) and § 29.865(c) Procedures for Quick Release Systems and Cargo Hooks: For jettisonable RLC's of any applicable cargo type, both a primary quick-release system (PQRS) and a back-up quick-release system (BQRS) are required. Features that should be considered are:
(i) The PQRS, BQRS and their load release devices and subsystems (such as electronically actuated guillotines) should be separate (i.e., physically, systematically, and functionally redundant).
(ii) The controls for the PQRS should be installed on one of the pilot's primary controls, or in an equivalently accessible location. The use of an "equivalent accessible location" should be reviewed on a case-by-case basis and used only where equivalent safety is clearly maintained.
(iii) The controls for the BQRS may be less sophisticated than that of the PQRS. For instance, manual cable cutters are acceptable provided they are listed in the flight manual as a required device and have a dedicated, placarded storage location.
(iv) The PQRS should release the external load in less than 5 seconds.
The BQRS should release the external load in less than 30 seconds. This time interval begins the moment an emergency is declared and the ends when the load is released.
(v) Each quick-release device should be designed and located to allow the pilot or a crewmember to accomplish external cargo release without hazardously limiting the ability to control the rotorcraft during emergency situations. The flight manual should reflect the requirement for a crewmember and the related functions.
(vi) Other load release types . In some current configurations, such as those used for high line operations, a load release may be present that is not on the rotorcraft but is on the PCDS itself. Examples are a tension release device that lets out
AC 29-2C, Chg 2 4/25/06 Page D - 150 line under an operationally induced load or a personal rope cutter. These devices are acceptable if:
(A) The off-rotorcraft release is c onsidered a "third release". This type of release is not a substitute for a required release (i.e., PQRS or BQRS);
(B) The release meets other rele vant requirements of § 29.865 and the methods of this AC or equivalent methods; and
(C) The release has no operational or failure modes that would affect continued safe flight and landing under any operations, critical failure modes, conditions, or combination of either.
(vii) Cargo hooks or equivalent devices and their related systems. All cargo hooks or equivalent devices should be approved to acceptable aircraft industry standards. The applicant should present these standards, and any related manufacturer’s certificates of production or qualification as part of the approval package.
(A) General . Cargo hook systems should have the same reliability goals and should be functionally demonstrated under critical loads for NHEC and HEC, as appropriate. All engagement and release modes should be demonstrated. If the hook is used as a quick-release device, then release of critical loads should be demonstrated under conditions that simulate maximum allowable bank angles and speeds and any other critical operating conditions. Demonstration of any re-latching features and any safety or warning devices should also be conducted. Demonstration of actual in-flight emergency quick-release capability may not be necessary if the quick-release capability can be acceptably simulated by other means.
NOTE: Cargo hook manufacturers specify particular shapes, sizes, and cross sections for lifting eyes to assure compatibility with their hook design (e.g., Breeze Eastern Service Bulletin CAB-100-41). Experience has shown that, under certain conditions, a load may inadvertently hang up because of improper geometry at the hook-to-eye interface that will not allow the eye to slide off an open hook as intended.
NOTE : For both NHEC and HEC designs, the phenomena of hook dynamic roll out (inadvertent opening of the hook latch and subsequent release of the load) should be considered to assure that QRS reliability goals are not compromised. This is of particular concern for HEC applications. Hook dynamic roll-out occurs during certain ground handling and flight conditions that may allow the lifting eye to work its way out of the hook.
Hook dynamic roll-out typically occurs when either the RLC's sling or harness is not properly attached to the hook, is blown by down draft, is dragged along the ground or through water; or is otherwise placed into the dangerous hook-to-eye configuration.