AC 29-2C

Change 2Historical

Advisory circular · Certification of Transport Category Rotorcraft

A newer version is currentThis is a historical version. AC 29-2C CHG 9 is the version in force, approved June 23, 2023.
Approved
April 25, 2006
Last reviewed
December 4, 2008
Family
AC 29-2 · 13 versions
Revision
C, change 2
14 CFR parts
29

Guidance, not mandatory unless a rule or AD requires it. DRS record last changed November 22, 2025.

Show pages 853–864
Page 865Open in PDF

Page MG 4 - 6 acceptable limits while transitioning to the backup mode and while using the backup control.

(iv) Ability of crew to switch to back-up : If crew action is required for switching to the back-up mode, this ability must be demonstrated during all phases of flight from any seat which may be occupied by the pilot in command or the copilot. The process to be used by the pilot to switch to the back-up mode should be clearly described in the Rotorcraft Flight Manual (RFM) as required by FAR paragraph 29.1581.

(v) Transfer to backup : The transfer to the back-up mode from the primary control mode or an intermediate mode (fixed position) must occur without excessive time delay or variation in power. Time delays and power variations experienced during the transfer should be evaluated during flight test for acceptability. A means should be provided to alert the pilot that transfer to the back-up mode has occurred.

(vi) Annunciation : Adequate annunciations should be provided to cue the crew of faults/failures and/or transfer of engine controls. These annunciations are of visual and aural types and must be distinct as to purpose and should not be misleading, especially under any fault/failure. Flight evaluation of these annunciations is required before final acceptance can be made.

(vii) Automatic Transfer : If the system is designed to accomplish automatic transfer between control modes, the transfer should occur without excessive variation in power and a means should be provided to alert the pilot that transfer to the back-up mode has occurred. Multiple automatic transfers between control modes may cause aircraft instability. A method to lockout the primary control after its initial failure and automatic transfer to the backup should be provided. If pilot reset is to be allowed, the procedure should be described in the RFM.

(viii) Calculated failure rate (with unannunciated faults present): Before a calculation of the failure rate can be attempted, the failure should be defined. The determination of failure rate, using the definition of failure, can be the product of a Failure Mode Effects Analysis (FMEA) combined with a reliability analysis, using individual part reliability figures. The figures should come from some recognized data base. The failure rate calculations should consider the worst case application limitations such as flight operation, environmental considerations, and time of operation. The flight operations to be considered for the worst case scenario include all flight segments (take off, cruise, hover, landing, etc.) together and separately for the various missions the aircraft is expected to be used in. Another way to determine failure rate is to use service history. However, service history is applicable only if a high degree of similarity exists for the FADEC and its installed application. The calculated failure rate is the direct result of the FMEA, and should

Page 866Open in PDF

Page MG 4 - 7 meet the integrity level requirement determined by the Functional Hazard Assessment.

(6) Certification Approach :

(i) Analysis Requirements : Functional Hazard Assessment:

Compliance to the requirements of FAR paragraphs 29.1141 and 29.1309 for a single channel FADEC in a single engine application should be based on criticality of application for the system under consideration. This criticality of application may be determined by performing an aircraft level hazard assessment that starts with the type of possible failures and ends with the results of these failures. The results can be categorized into criticality levels and the required integrity levels can be obtained by matching the required integrity level to the criticality level. The main emphasis should be on determining the higher levels of criticality (Major and above) and their source. This process should include consideration of failures seen at the operational level and interaction of the failures with the airframe and crew as well as the system itself. The following subject areas are related to this assessment.

(A) Assumptions : Assumptions should be made about the airframe/crew interface in order to perform the aircraft level hazard assessment.

These assumptions are prerequisites to perform an aircraft level hazard assessment and must be listed in this hazard assessment and validated by airframe testing when the airframe is available. If the assumptions cannot be validated, the actual airframe test data must be substituted for the invalidated assumptions (assumed prerequisites) and the hazard assessment re-evaluated with the new data supported prerequisites. The results of this new assessment would be the deciding factor for acceptance of the FADEC system for the installation as designed or provide the necessity for design changes.

(B) Criteria : Acceptance of an engine fitted with a single channel FADEC system in a single engine rotorcraft application requires that the integrity levels of the FADEC system be compliant with the criticality levels determined by the aircraft level Functional Hazard Assessment (FHA). In addition, final acceptance of the system at the aircraft level for the application is based on the integrity level(s) that match the criticality level(s) determined by the hazard assessment that uses data that has been validated during the aircraft flight test program. These assumptions/prerequisites would include operational aspects associated with the possible FADEC failures and would include as a minimum the following:

( 1 ) Crew/aerodynamic response to failure.

( 2 ) Worst case flight operation for fail ure to occur. (Landing, IFR, etc.)

( 3 ) Duration of flight operation (exposure time).

Page 867Open in PDF

Page MG 4 - 8 ( 4 ) System interaction with shared Inputs/Outputs with other systems and/or with back-up systems.

( 5 ) Adequate annunciation of failure.

(ii) Validation Criteria:

(A) General :

( 1 ) Validation of the assumptions/prerequisites made by the engine manufacturer in developing the SSA, using aircraft level FHA requirements, must be validated by conducting flight testing during the certification of the installation. The possibility exists that if the assumptions cannot be validated during flight testing, then engine and/or FADEC redesign may be required.

( 2 ) Failure management methods that are related to operational characteristics should be addressed. It should be determined that the FADEC/engine manufacturer's envisioned failure management is desirable and compatible with the operational requirements. Therefore, the following basic FADEC related information should be identified:

( i ) The detected failures.

( i i ) The failures that are not detected.

(iii ) The action that the FADEC takes when failures are detected.

( i v ) The failures that are annunciate d to the crew and in what manner.

( v ) The anticipated operati onal action required as a result of detected failures.

( v i ) Possible operational result s of the undetected failures.

(vii) Verification that the assumed worst case flight operation is the worst case.

(B) Manual Backup : Additional aircraft operational testing is required to specifically evaluate the manual backup system for compliance with the FAR requirements. The acceptability of the manual backup system depends substantially on its installation and interface with the airframe. The following items need to be demonstrated in accordance with § 29.927 and § 29.939 or accomplished on each application prior to the acceptance of the manual backup system:

Page 868Open in PDF

Page MG 4 - 9

( 1 ) It should be demonstrated by flight test with the failure of the primary engine control, that the aircraft can be flown and a safe and controlled power-on landing executed without creating an undue pilot workload.

( 2 ) It should be demonstrated by flight test that switching between control modes will not create an unsafe condition during any phase of operation within the aircraft operating envelope.

( 3 ) The pilot action required as a result of a failure of the primary control and used as an assumption in the FHA and FMEA should be validated during flight tests and listed in the emergency procedures section of the flight manual.

c. FADEC RELIABILITY REVIEW DUE TO INCREASED ROTORCRAFT

ENDURANCE

(1) Background . This advisory material is to provide guidance for reevaluation of the FADEC control system reliability due to extension of the aircraft mission endurance. During the initial type certification of an aircraft, an analysis is normally conducted on systems to determine their criticality category (e.g.

catastrophic, hazardous, major, etc.) and reliability requirements. To establish a system’s reliability, an exposure time is determined by making certain assumptions.

In most cases, the exposure time is the average endurance based on the various flight scenarios in which the aircraft is to be used. When an aircraft’s expected mission endurance is increased by adding fuel capacity, a new analysis for system reliability should be conducted taking into account the new increased mission endurance.

(2) Requirements.

(i) If the applicant has access to the initial analysis used for the type certification, one method to accomplish the new reliability analysis is by multiplying the exposure time used in the original reliability analysis by the ratio of the increased maximum endurance to the original maximum endurance. That is, if the aircraft endurance increases by 50 percent due to additional fuel capacity, the assumed exposure time should also increase by 50 percent. The applicant should then rework the analysis using this new exposure time.

(ii) If the applicant does not have a ccess to the initial analysis it will be incumbent upon them to provide the rationale used for determining the new exposure time and to provide a complete analysis for the systems determined to be critical. The FAA engineer should compare this new analysis to the original.

Page 869Open in PDF

AC 29-2C, Chg 2 4/25/06 Page MG 4 - 10

d. CERTIFICATION GUIDELIN ES FOR COMPLIANCE TO THE

REQUIREMENTS FOR ELECTROMAGNETIC COMPATIBILITY (EMC) TESTING FOR

NON-QUALIFIED EQUIPMENT AND EQUIPMENT KNOWN TO HAVE A HIGH

POTENTIAL FOR INTERFERENCE WHEN INSTALLED ON ROTORCRAFT WITH ELECTRONIC CONTROLS THAT PROVIDE CRITICAL FUNCTIONS.

(1) Background .

(i) Rotorcraft operations are varied and use a wide assortment of equipment. While some of this equipment is qualified to aircraft standards, particularly environmental standards, some of the equipment not qualified to such standards may be the source of harmful electromagnetic interference. Rotorcraft typically have not had electronic controls that perform critical functions, such as engine controls and flight controls; therefore, there was no real concern about requiring equipment to be qualified to aircraft standards. Typically, this equipment was installed with only a cross-matrix operational check for EMC. These tests consisted of operating the equipment in question and checking visually for an indication of interference. The equipment was, for the most part, non-required equipment and the primary concern was that interference might be emitted from the equipment.

(ii) Unqualified equipment and thei r effects on critical systems is of particular concern due to the recent increase in the number of rotorcraft with electronic engine controls and the implementation of fly-by-wire technology. Additionally, the physical close proximity of installed equipment to electronic controls that provide critical functions is inherent due to the smaller size of most rotorcraft and represents a greater potential for interference than for larger fixed wing aircraft.

(2) Requirements .

(i) The rules to assure that requi red functions are not subject to interference are provided in the certification basis for the rotorcraft. Although the certification basis may differ between aircraft, the requirements that address electromagnetic interference are similar and result in the same methods for compliance. A note has been added to the type certificate data sheets for rotorcraft that employ FADECs. This note was added to remind all modifiers that the requirement for addressing interference exists and that special EMI test considerations must be addressed to show compliance. Most EMC considerations can be addressed by the operational interference checks addressed in the background discussion. However, when a critical control function is provided by some electronic means, special EMI test considerations must also be addressed, in addition to the previously described EMC tests. The determination of when these other, more rigorous tests are required is a simple concept, but complex in practice. More rigorous testing is required to satisfy the concern for the installation of equipment that would interfere with the critical control (e.g., FADEC, Fly-By-Wire, etc.) or failure management of the critical control. This class of equipment is “equipment known to have a potential for interference,” which may or may not be qualified to an aircraft

Page 870Open in PDF

Page MG 4 - 11

(ii) standard, such as high frequency (HF) radios, high powered radars, hoists, transmitting antennas located near the controls systems, etc. The concern associated with this class of equipment is the possible interference with the critical electronic controls.

(ii) Accomplishment . In addition to the following special testing considerations addressed in paragraph (2)(iii), “EMI Installation Testing for Critical Controls” and “Installation Test Conditions,” all installed equipment should undergo a cross-matrix operational check for EMC considerations by operating all equipment under consideration and determining if an interference hazard is created.

(A) Class of Equipment - Equipment Known to Have a High Potential for Interference: This class of equipment should be tested in the installation as described in the “EMI Installation Testing for Critical Controls/Installation Test Conditions,” paragraph (2)(iii). Since the concern of this class of equipment is its high potential for interference, its EMI laboratory qualification does not preclude the EMI installation testing.

Equipment that meets any one of the following criteria is considered to be “equipment known to have a high potential for interference.”

• Equipment that requires 25 amps or more to operate,

• Equipment that transmits 30 watts or more,

• Equipment with an antenna located 0.5 meters or less from the FADEC, or

• High Frequency (HF) Transmitters of any power.

The types of equipment in this class include HF radios, high-powered radars, hoists, high-powered radios, installations where radio transmission antennas are in close proximity to the controls, and equipment that require large currents to operate or radiate strong electromagnetic fields. Examples of this type of equipment are some Emergency Medical Service (EMS) equipment, night sun lights, some air conditioners, video and sound systems that require large currents (25 amps – up) to operate, Forward Looking Infrared System (FLIRS), some forward looking radars, some weather radars, some communication systems that transmit 30 watts or more, some data link transmission systems, etc.

NOTE: Equipment that does not meet this criteria is considered to be “equipment not known to have a high potential for interference.”

(B) Class of Equipment – Equipment Not Known to Have a High Potential for Interference: Once it has been established that the equipment being proposed to be installed is not in the class of “equipment known to have a high

Page 871Open in PDF

AC 29-2C, Chg 2 4/25/06 Page MG 4 - 12 potential for interference,” per the criteria stated in paragraph (2)(ii)(A), there is no requirement to conduct the EMI installation tests described in the “EMI Installation Testing for Critical Controls/Installation Test Conditions” paragraph (2)(iii). However, the cross-matrix operational checks for EMC considerations described in paragraph (2)(ii) are still required.

(iii) EMI Installation Testing for Critical Controls:

(A) EMI installation testing is no longer required for unqualified equipment that does not have a high potential to cause interference. However, EMI installation testing is the only method of testing to show compliance for interference considerations, for the class of “equipment known to have a high potential for interference.” The criteria for determining whether the “equipment is known to have a high potential for interference” is stated in paragraph (2)(ii)(A).

(B) To accomplish the EMI installation tests, there must be an FAA- approved test plan that requires the high interference potential equipment to be operated through all reasonable modes of operation, in order to determine if electromagnetic interference is entering the electronic control system. EMI installation testing consists of interrogating the control, if it has such a feature, to determine if the critical electronic control system is adversely affected (identify the recorded faults that occur during the test). Additionally, real-time monitoring of the control’s input/output parameters should be accomplished. The pass/fail criteria is “no detected interference” for a pass state, and conversely a fail state if any interference is detected entering the control. If interference is detected, the source of interference should be investigated to determine if the detected interference is the worst case. In some cases, the detection of interference may result in flight tests being required to determine if the interference is worse in flight. After the worst case interference is defined, the interference must be eliminated at the source, or the interference must be evaluated to assure that the critical electronic controls, its functions, and its related indications do not result in an unsafe condition. For FADECs, special test equipment developed by the engine manufacturer will be required to interrogate and monitor the controls input/output parameters. Other types critical controls may also require special test equipment to perform this type of testing.

(C) Installation Test Conditions : “Equipment Known to Have a High Potential for Interference” represents the main concern for radiated and conductive interference; therefore, ground and flight tests are usually required. Therefore, when the EMI installation tests described in paragraph (2)(iii) are required, ground and flight tests will usually need to be conducted. Ground tests alone are usually not sufficient since some equipment may pose safety issues if operated on the ground, while other equipment cannot be satisfactorily operated on the ground, or the equipment would provide misleading results if operated on the ground. For example, some equipment is prohibited from being operated on the ground, such as hoists.

Page 872Open in PDF

Page MG 4 - 13 (D) If the proposed installed equipm ent has been tested in relation to the critical electronic control system on another identical installation, then there can be an exception to the EMI installation testing requirements defined in paragraph (2)(iii). The data showing identicality of the equipment and installation with passing test data are acceptable in place of further testing on the same type rotorcraft.

(3) Summary . The concern for potential interference to electronic controls that provide critical functions may be addressed by the methods contained within this document. To address the interference aspects of “equipment known to have a high potential for interference,” the equipment must be tested as a part of the installation as described in paragraph (2)(iii), during ground and flight tests.

Page 873Open in PDF

Page MG 5 - 1 CHAPTER 3

AIRWORTHINESS STANDARDS

TRANSPORT CATEGORY ROTORCRAFT

MISCELLANEOUS GUIDANCE (MG)

AC 29 MG 5. AGRICULTURAL DIS PENSING EQUIPMENT INSTALLATION.

NOTE: This paragraph has been extensively revised and expanded to clarify the restricted category certification of agricultural dispensing equipment installations on rotorcraft.

a. Explanation . In the early development of the rotorcraft one of its primary usages was agricultural operation. The FAA recognized that the existing requirements, which were designed primarily to establish an appropriate level of safety for passenger-carrying aircraft, imposed an unnecessary economic burden and were unduly restrictive for the manufacture and operation of aircraft intended only for use in rural, sparsely settled areas. Therefore, a special document that established new standards for agricultural dispensing equipment and other special purposes was developed. Restricted Category CAM 8 became effective October 11, 1950.

(1) During the recodification of 1965, CAR 8 ceased to exist as a regulatory basis and selected portions addressing certification were incorporated into FAR 21.

While the specific standards in CAR 8 were not changed substantially when adopted into FAR 21, the less restrictive philosophy of CAM 8 and the policy material that was stated in the preamble to CAM 8 were not clearly conveyed.

(2) Advisory material published in 1965 and revised in 1975, summarized the information contained in the advisory portions of CAM 8. This new advisory material indicated that the CAM advisory material would be applicable to the related FAR’s.

Unfortunately, this document specified that CAM 8 could be used in conjunction with certain FAR’s for restricted category certification of small agricultural airplanes only.

Rotorcraft were omitted.

(3) A survey of restricted category roto rcraft projects related to agricultural modifications indicates that the CAM 8 philosophy was interpreted to allow the use of AC 43.13-2A structural criteria for most STC’s issued through the early 1980’s. Since then more restrictive guidance based on CAR 6 and FAR 27 requirements has been applied by some ACO’s to several STC applications. Since the more restrictive guidance imposed a significant economic burden on the industry, the HAI requested a meeting with the FAA during the 1990 annual convention in Dallas. As a result of the meeting, an Action Notice to clarify the interpretation of FAR 21.25(a)(1) for restricted category aircraft has been issued.

(4) The following advisory material is a result of a reassessment of past and present policy.

Page 874Open in PDF

Page MG 5 - 2

b. Procedures . The certification basis for agricultural dispensing equipment in the restricted category is FAR 21.25(a)(1) as interpreted by Action Notice 8110.22. The accountable Directorate guidance for the substantiation requirements for rotorcraft is as follows:

(1) Substantiation of the agricultura l dispensing system hoppers or spray tanks to the load factors provided in figure AC 29 MG 5-1 provides for proof of structure. The load factors of figure AC 29 MG 5-1 address the critical structural load conditions of dispensing equipment mounted in or near the fuselage and provide adequate margins of safety.

FIGURE AC 29 MG 5-1

ACCEPTABLE ULTIMATE LOAD FACTOR FOR

AGRICULTURAL DISPENSING EQUIPMENT DESIGN

UP DOWN SIDE FORWARD AFT

Tanks & Equipment Mounted In Or Near The Fuselage

1.5g 4.0g 2.0g 4.0g Note 1

- - - - Spray Booms 1.5g 2.5g - - - - Note 1 2.5g Note 2

Note 1: An ultimate load factor of 2 G’s is acceptable for externally side or under fuselage mounted tank and forward mounted spray booms where failure in a minor crash landing will not create a hazard to occupants or prevent exit from the rotorcraft.

Note 2: The aft loads for spray booms may be developed by the applicant based on the 111 percent of VNE for which certification is requested or the load factors of figure AC 29 MG 5-1, whichever is greater.

(2) The applicant may elect to substantia te his/her product by either static or dynamic testing, by analysis, or any combination thereof.

(3) Lower load factors may be used only when justified by manufacturer’s data, rational analysis, or actual rotorcraft flight and ground load demonstrations.

(4) Tank pressure test, while not mandated, is recommended for safety reasons. An acceptable procedure is included in paragraph AC 29 MG 5(c)(4).

Page 875Open in PDF

Page MG 5 - 3

(5) Dispensing equipment installation attach points. If attach points exist which are an integral part of the rotorcraft and these attach points have been certified to the standard category requirements no further substantiation of the attach point is required if an analysis indicates the dispensing system does not impose loads which exceed those for standard category certification.

(6) Ground clearance for dispensing equi pment installation. A 5-inch ground clearance has typically been used for skid gear equipped rotorcraft which incorporate belly mounted supply tanks/hoppers or systems which have dual side mounted supply tanks/hoppers and the design incorporates cross tubes or other system components which are located beneath the bottom of the fuselage when these components are rigidly attached to the airframe structure. The 5-inch dimension is measured vertically from the ground to the lowest point of the installed system, with the rotorcraft in its operational configuration and gross weight (including disposable load) and while resting on a smooth, level asphalt surface. For rotorcraft equipped with wheels and/or landing gear struts, the maximum system deflections should be considered when determining the 5 inches of acceptable static ground clearance. The 5-inch ground clearance would only apply to original configuration of newly manufactured rotorcraft. However, a 3-inch ground clearance has been found acceptable and may be approved for skid gear equipped rotorcraft to account for the in-service permanent set allowed for skid gear members, (i.e., cross tube deflections allowed per the maintenance manual). Cable supported systems, (i.e., cargo hook installations) or dispensing systems utilizing flexible ducts (certain types of dry material dispensing equipment which may or may not be retractable) have been approved even though portions of the system may contact the surface during a normal landing.

(7) A number of rotorcraft are approved fo r external cargo operations that allow a gross weight higher than the approved internal gross weight limit. This difference is usually due to the allowable weight limit restriction of the landing gear. (The gear is not approved for the higher weight.) Those types of dispensing equipment, that can be loaded in flight to a weight that exceeds the allowable limit of the landing gear should incorporate a reliable means that rapidly reduces the total aircraft gross weight to within allowable landing gear limits. In most cases, this will involve jettison of the disposable load. The time interval for this operation should be demonstrated, and should not exceed a recommended 3 seconds from a level flight condition.

(8) A flight check or demonstration of the agricultural dispensing equipment installation is normally conducted. This flight check should also qualitatively determine that no hazardous deflection or resonance in the rotorcraft or dispensing system exists.

For FAA flight operations approval, this flight check must be conducted in accordance with the requirements of FAR 133.41. In addition, recent service history has shown that external equipment and external fixture modifications can affect main rotor mast bending loads. In lieu of a mast bending survey, a pre and post modification flight test may be conducted at identical weights, center-of-gravity (CG), power, and density

Page 876Open in PDF

AC 29-2C, Chg 1 2/12/03 Page MG 5 - 4 altitude to compare a critical control position parameter (typically longitudinal cyclic stick position) at pre and post modification Vne airspeeds.

(i) If required, the post modificati on Vne should be reduced so that the post modification longitudinal cyclic stick position is slightly aft of (or less than) the pre modification stick position. This alternative procedure assumes that the static longitudinal stability of the helicopter has not been altered by the modification. For helicopters with neutral static stability, a more comprehensive investigation may be required.

(ii) In some cases, a control position parameter other than longitudinal stick position may be critical. For example, a heavy external device mounted to the side of the helicopter that gives a lateral CG close to the limit and an asymmetric yaw component would require pre and post modification lateral cyclic stick and pedal position measurements. Operating limitations other than Vne may need to be established, or reduced from pre modification limitations, to ensure pre modification mast bending is not exceeded.

(9) For rotorcraft certificated in dual categories, the inspection requirements of FAR 21.187(b) must be observed when converting from restricted to normal category.

c. Acceptable Means of Compliance .

(1) Analysis Method . Structural analysis (static) may be used if the structure is of a configuration for which experience has shown the method to be reliable. Structural substantiation of tanks that are designed to contain liquid materials may be accomplished by pressure testing. For tanks or hoppers designed to contain dry material, (e.g., dust or fertilizer) static load tests may be used to verify structural integrity. The tank/hopper, mounting hardware, and support structure should all be substantiated to the load conditions specified by this paragraph considering the effects of internal fluid pressures when applicable.

(2) Static Tests . Static tests of tank/hoppers, mounting hardware, and support structure for each critical load condition may be accomplished using conventional techniques; such as, dead weight loading, whiffletree systems, and hydraulic rams. If tests of the tank and its mounting hardware are conducted using a test fixture representing the rotorcraft, the rotorcraft support structure may be substantiated independently by means of test and/or analysis. Static test loads should be applied in combination with associated internal fluid pressure loadings. The ultimate loads specified in paragraph AC 29 MG 5 should be sustained for at least 3 seconds without failure.

(3) Dynamic Tests .