Page MG 11 - 11
(iv) Partial Failures. The following are typical examples of the type of partial failures that may be considered in the flaw growth fail-safe evaluation:
(A) Detectable skin cracks in the trailing edge sections of rotor blades.
(B) Detectable failures of i ndividual straps in “strap packs.”
(C) Detectable skin cracks em anating from the edge of structural openings or cutouts.
(D) Detectable circumferential or longitudinal skin crack in the basic fuselage or tail boom structure.
(E) Complete severance of interior frame elements or stiffeners in addition to a detectable crack in the adjacent skin.
(F) Presence of a detectable fatigue failure in at least the tension portion of the spar web or similar element.
(G) Detectable failure of a prim ary attachment, including blade attachment fittings and control surface hinge and fittings.
(H) Fretting, corrosion, and ga lling conditions expected in service.
(v) Initial inspection time . The initial crack size to be used for evaluation of the initial inspection time should be the flaw size controlled by manufacturing quality and damage that can go undetected for the life of the part.
(vi) Evaluation of the inspection intervals. For multiple load paths, a minimum of three inspection intervals is recommended between the initially detectable damage time and the time when residual strength is reduced to design limit load by crack growth. For single element structures, a minimum of four inspection intervals is recommended. The repeated loads should be defined in the loading, temperature, and humidity spectra. The loading conditions should take into account the effects of structural flexibility and rate of loading where it is significant.
Tests of two or more specimens should be used to obtain crack propagation data using either a realistic load spectrum or an accelerated load (spectrum or single) associated with the use of propagation theory and data after cracks have been initiated. As far as applicable, crack growth tests should be carried out considering a fatigue crack naturally induced in testing. In the other cases, crack initiation points should be made by suitable methods, reference paragraph g(3)(viii). Unless a more rational method with an equivalent level-of-safety is applied for, the following methods of setting inspection intervals should be applied. In all cases, the inspection methods and intervals should
29-2C, Chg 1 2/12/03 Page MG 11 - 12 adequately consider variables such as inspectability, type of inspection, crack growth behavior, and other scheduled maintenance considerations.
(A) For a single element (load path) structure, plot the data and set the inspection as shown in Figure AC 29.MG 11-1.
( 1 ) Set the initial inspection at L 1 /3.
( 2 ) Set the repetitive inspection intervals at L 2 /4.
CRITICAL CRACK LENGTH FOR LIMIT LOAD
FLAW SIZE
FIELD DETECTABLE FLAW SIZE
FLAW SIZE CONTROLLED I
BY MANUFACTURING QUALITY LIFE FIGURE AC 29 MG 11-1 CRACK GROWTH FOR SINGLE ELEMENT STRUCTURE Page MG 11 - 13
29-2C, Chg 1 2/12/03 Page MG 11 - 14 (B) For a multi-element load pat h structure substantiated by test:
( 1 ) Obtain a complete failure of the cr itical load path, either by initiating and propagating a crack or by artificially disabling it.
( 2 ) Damage (i.e. crack growth starti ng from nominal flaw or crack initiation) accumulated in the structure prior to load path failure should be considered in establishing Lr .
( 3 ) Note when the residual strength of the remaining elements decreases to limit load due to crack growth, provided with a load margin if appropriate.
( 4) From Figure AC 29.MG 11-2, set repetitive inspection intervals at Lr /3.
FLAW SIZE
FAILURE OF
CRITICAL CRACK LENGTH FOR LIMIT LOAD CRITICAL MEMBER,
FOR REMAINING MEMBERS OR ELEMENT
AFTER FAILURE OF CRITICAL MEMBER
IN CRITICAL REMAINING DETECTABLE FLAW SIZE _ FLAW GROWTH GROWTH FLAW LIFE FIGURE AC 29 MG 11-2 CRACK GROWTH FOR REMAINING ELEMENTS
OF MULTIPLE ELEMENT STRUCTURE
(vil) No/Benign Crack Growth Page MG 11 - 15
29-2C, Chg 1 2/12/03 Page MG 11 - 16
(A) This method depends on replacement rather than inspection to ensure the continued airworthiness of a PSE. The replacement time is established based on consideration of crack growth characteristics.
(B) To substantiate a structur e in the no/benign crack growth category requires demonstration either by analysis, testing, or both, that the rogue crack (aR), which is the most severe crack consistent with manufacturing, maintenance and service environment, will not grow or will not grow to critical size (aCRIT) under the service loading and environment before the structure is replaced. The crack should be assumed at the critical location, as defined by the largest stress intensity factor range under the expected service loading range including the ground–air–ground cycle.
(C) To determine the replacement time, the rogue cracks should be assumed at the critical location and the crack growth characteristics should be determined for the expected load/environment spectrum. There are three different scenarios that could result from a crack growth assessment and be used for establishing a replacement time. These scenarios are illustrated in Figures AC 29.MG 11-3, -4 and –5.
(D) The no crack growth scenario is illustrated in Figure AC.29.MG 11-3.
In this figure, the rogue flaw does not grow or growth is insignificant. In this case the replacement time should not exceed the design service life (LDES).
Page MG 11 - 17
(E) Figure AC 29.MG 11-4 illustra tes the scenario where the rogue crack grows relatively slowly but becomes critical prior to becoming detectable (aDET). In this case the replacement time should be set equal to the total crack growth life (LT) divided by a factor N.
TIME
CRACK SI ZE aR LDES TIME
CRACK SIZE aR aCRIT aDET LT FIGURE AC 29.MG 11-3 Figure AC 29.MG 11-4
29-2C, Chg 1 2/12/03 Page MG 11 - 18 (F) Figure AC 29.MG 11-5 illustra tes the scenario where the rogue crack grows to a detectable size (at L1) before becoming critical (at L1+L2). In this case the replacement time should be set equal to the total crack growth life (L1+L2) divided by a factor N.
TIME
CRACK SIZE aR aDET aCRIT L1 L2
Figure AC 29.MG 11-5
Page MG 11 - 19 (G) In determining the factor of N to be used for determining the replacement time, consideration should be given to the crack growth data used (e.g., top of scatter data versus average data, number of specimens used to generate data, etc.).
(H) The minimum suggested N value should be (1) N=2 in the case where the conservative top-of-scatter crack growth data are used in the crack growth analysis, or (2) N=4 when the average crack growth data are used in the crack growth analysis, or when the crack growth life is obtained from the crack growth test of one specimen (for two or more full scale specimens, N=3 of the shortest crack growth life can be used).
(I) It should also be noted that, in the no/benign crack growth category, the validity of the crack growth threshold, ΔKITH, is especially important since there is no element of inspection to ensure continued airworthiness. Consistent with this, additional attention may be required relative to validating the crack growth threshold value(s) used in the analyses. Consideration should be given to the influence of the test procedure used to develop values, microstructure, heat treatment, crack size, loading conditions, environment, grain size and orientation, etc. In general a coupon testing program may be necessary to develop a consistent ΔKITH data base and the use of bibliographic data might require additional conservatism.
(viii) Testing of Princi pal Structural Elements.
(A) The nature and extent of tests on complete structures or on portions of the primary structure will depend upon applicable previous design, construction, tests, and service experience in connection with similar structures. For fail-safe testing considering crack propagation, simulated cracks should be as representative as possible of actual fatigue damage. Where it is not practical to produce actual fatigue cracks, flaws can be simulated by cuts made with a fine saw, sharp blade, guillotine, Electrical Discharge Machine, or other suitable means. The validity of saw cuts, etc., should be verified by comparison to coupon tests of a cracked specimen of the same material. In those cases where bolt failure, or its equivalent, is to be simulated as part of a possible flaw configuration in joints or fittings, bolts can be removed to provide that part of the simulation.
(B) Other test and inspection programs may be used if shown to have comparable or better probability of assuring that a catastrophic fatigue failure will not occur.
(ix) Analytical Evaluation The fail safe characteristics can also be shown analytically, by reliable and conservative methods, by demonstrating that the repeated loads and limit load stresses do not exceed those of previously verified fail safe designs of similar configuration, materials, and inspectability. Analytical models should be properly validated to assure that:
29-2C, Chg 1 2/12/03 Page MG 11 - 20 (A) Stress analysis is sufficiently accurate. This can be achieved by similarity with full scale strain surveys, thermography, or other suitable testing approaches.
(B) Fracture mechanics is properly applied.
(C) Load interaction models are veri fied for the specific load histories.
(D) Consistent material data base is used.
(x) Inspection plan . Detection of flaws before they become dangerous is the ultimate control in ensuring the flaw tolerance characteristics of the structure.
Therefore, the applicant should provide sufficient guidance information to assist operators in establishing the frequency, extent, and methods of inspection of the critical structure, and this kind of information should, under § 29.571(a)(2), be included in the maintenance manual required by § 29.1529. Due to the inherent, complex interactions of the many parameters affecting flaw tolerance, such as operating practices, environmental effects, load sequence on flaw growth, and variations in inspection methods, related operational experience should be taken into account in establishing inspection procedures. Comparative analysis can be used to guide the changes from successful past practice, when necessary. Therefore, maintenance and inspection requirements should recognize the dependence on experience and should be specified in a document that provides for revision as a result of operational experience, such as the one containing the operator’s FAA/AUTHORITY-approved structural inspection program developed through the Maintenance Review Board (MRB) procedures for FAR Part 121 operators.
(4) Safe-Life Demonstration
(i) Information to guide fatigue evaluation based on the safe-life approach is described in details in AC 27-1B MG 11. The safe-life approach is used when both the fail-safe and flaw-tolerant safe-life methods are verified to be impractical due to considerations of inspectability, geometry, or good design practice as described above in paragraph d(2).
(ii) The safe-life approach may not account for flaws and imperfections due to manufacturing and in service conditions as compared to the flaw tolerant approaches. Therefore, conservative factors that adjust for variations in both load and strength are generally utilized when substantiating by the safe-life method.
(5) Combining Methods .
(i) Components may be managed by a retirement time based on the Flaw Tolerant Safe-Life method, paragraph g(2); by an inspection program based on the Fail-Safe method, paragraph g(3); or, if approved, a retirement time based on conventional Safe Life, paragraph g(4). In some cases it may be appropriate to
Page MG 11 - 21 establish a retirement time based on the lowest from several methods, and in some cases it may be appropriate to establish both a retirement time and an inspection program for a given structure.
(ii) Retirement Times . The conventional Safe-Life retirement time of the two retirement times should be used. Additionally, inspection intervals resulting the need to conduct that specific inspection. In this event, the conventional safe life retirement time should be used if lower.
AC Page MG 12 - 1 CHAPTER 3
AIRWORTHINESS STANDARDS
TRANSPORT CATEGORY ROTORCRAFT
MISCELLANEOUS GUIDANCE (MG)
AC 29 MG 12. § 29.865 (Amendment 29-43) EXTERNAL LOADS.
This AC MG paragraph material is now contained in AC 29.865B, in Subpart D.