Page MG 15 - 15 fully validate this analogous data set, a degree of direct evidence for the actual equipment being monitored is still likely to be necessary to prove similarity of application. This might be achieved by performing an appropriate number of seeded defect tests and, in effect, "sampling" the range of failure types contained.
NOTE: For both direct and indirect evidence, the whole system must be validated endto-end.
(4) Controlled Introduction to Service .
(i) For some credit applications, full validation and implementation may be possible during the development period. However, for many HUMS techniques, a plan for a controlled introduction to service may be necessary to fully validate the credit.
(ii) There must be provisions in t he certification process to instruct the continued airworthiness effort to ensure compliance with the aforementioned plan.
(iii) During the implementation of this plan, data is accumulated by operational aircraft, and from this data, refinements and adjustments to the original criteria can be made. This period may also allow a proposed credit to be operated in parallel with alternative or standard procedures when it is necessary to gain additional in-service validation by way of back-to-back comparison
(iv) The plan should include procedures and provisions for this controlled period and should include clear goals by which progress and ultimately termination of this phase can be measured. The plan may include a multi-credit HUMS that will require a phased introduction of credits.
(5) Continued Airworthiness and Synthesis of Credit . Normal and established procedures will prevail for HUMS as for all other continued airworthiness matters.
Arrangements should be made to validate the performance of an approved credit throughout its service use. Provisions should be made to allow for the synthesis of the service experience with relevant engineering evidence from rejected components, development testing, seeded testing, etc. Any necessary or desired modifications to the HUMS application or the component/equipment being monitored must be re-evaluated.
h. Instructions for Continued Airwor thiness (ICA) and Other Requirements for Health and Usage Monitoring System (HUMS). This section addresses the ICA, operator's HUMS program, HUMS training, and Master Minimum Equipment List (MMEL) revision to incorporate HUMS.
(1) Instructions fo r Continued Airworthiness. The applicant for HUMS is required to provide ICA developed in accordance with FAR/JAR Part 29 and Appendix A. This section provides supplemental guidance with addressing aspects unique to
AC 29-2C, Chg 1 2/12/03
Page MG 15 - 16 HUMS. The applicant may be an airframe manufacturer, HUMS equipment manufacturer, or an operator. The ICA should address HUMS integration with the aircraft. This section addresses both airborne and ground based systems and equipment.
(i) HUMS ICA Items . The applicant must address the following subjects in addition to FAR/JAR Part 29. These subjects should address both airborne and ground based systems and equipment unless specifically indicated otherwise.
(A) Control and operating instructi ons must be provided for each element of HUMS, and where applicable, include data acquisition, transfer processing, display, configuration management, and resulting actions.
(B) Acceptance and rejection criteria and associated actions must be defined.
(C) A procedure is required when the system becomes inoperative because data is missing.
(D) When required, there mu st be a procedure for collecting and transferring HUMS data when the aircraft is away from the main HUMS data processing base.
(E) Provide a procedure for independent verification as defined in paragraph f(3), if applicable.
(F) Provide a procedure for implementing mitigating actions, when mitigating actions are applied.
(G) Provide a procedure for im plementing controlled introduction to service instructions as defined in paragraph g(4), if applicable.
(H) Provide a training pr ogram on HUMS airborne and ground based systems and equipment.
(I) The airworthiness limitation section must be amended to address the following, if required:
( 1 ) Requirements for independent verification and associated procedures.
( 2 ) Requirements for mitigation actions and associated procedures.
( 3 ) Requirements for controlled introduction to service and associated procedures.
Page MG 15 - 17
(ii) Ground Based System and Equipment . A procedure must be defined to ensure the security of the ground-based system and equipment and the integrity of the HUMS data.
(2) Owner/Operator's HUMS Program .
(i) General . An owner/operator that installs and utilizes health and usage monitoring equipment on aircraft and intends to request maintenance credit will need a program. This program and revision to existing maintenance and/or inspection programs must be submitted to the aviation Authority for approval. This is due to the fact that maintenance credit may change existing maintenance inspection, overhaul requirements, and/or life limits.
(ii) HUMS Program Items . Regardless of the size and complexity of the health and usage monitoring equipment, the HUMS program must contain the following:
(A) A system must be provided for tracking the HUMS monitored component/system, including identification of component/system, recording requirement, tracking procedure, and other related activities.
(B) A system to assure that a maintenance credit must be maintained.
The historical HUMS data must be traceable when such components/assemblies are transferred between aircraft.
(C) A procedure for new or overhauled HUMS monitored components.
(D) A procedure to address i noperative HUMS in accordance with paragraph j(1)(i)(C).
(E) A means for implementing pr ocedures specified in paragraph j(1)(ii).
(F) A procedure for adjusting maintenance credits.
(G) An organization with clearly defined responsibilities to collect, analyze, and act upon the HUMS data.
(H) A procedure for implementi ng the training program specified in paragraph j(1)(i)(H).
(I) Where appropriate, a proc edure for implementing the controlled introduction to service plan. See section g(4), Controlled Introduction to Service.
(iii) Ground Based System and Equipment .
AC 29-2C, Chg 1 2/12/03
Page MG 15 - 18
(A) A procedure for troubles hooting and testing of the HUMS.
(B) A procedure for revising and using the operator’s Minimum Equipment List (MEL) for HUMS.
(iv) Master Minimum Equipment List (MMEL)/Minimum Equipment List.
(A) The MMEL may need to be revised to include the HUMS equipment.
Once the MMEL contains the HUMS equipment, the operator can revise their MEL to include HUMS and submit the MEL to the aviation Authority for approval.
(B) The aviation Authority should coordinate with engineering in evaluating the revised MEL.
NOTE: Any MMEL allowance should be determined considering the criticality of the 'credit' effect resulting from the HUMS application(s). MMEL allowances should be substantiated based on a Functional Hazard Assessment (FHA).
AC Page MG 16 - 1 CHAPTER 3
AIRWORTHINESS STANDARDS
TRANSPORT CATEGORY ROTORCRAFT
MISCELLANEOUS GUIDANCE (MG)
AC 29 MG 16. CERTIFICATION PR OCEDURE FOR ROTORCRAFT NIGHT VISION
IMAGING SYSTEMS (NVIS) LIGHTING EQUIPMENT
a. Background
(1) This guidance is designed to assist in the certification of NVIS internal and external aircraft lighting systems. It covers the two processes involved in NVIS lighting certification:
1. Installation and certification of the NVIS compatible lighting on the aircraft.
2. Certification of the NVIS lighting installation and cockpit compatibility with night vision goggles (NVGs).
Expanded guidance is found in RTCA/DO-275, Minimum Operational Standards for Night Vision Imaging Systems, dated 12 October 2001. Additionally, this guidance is meant for use with NVIS using night vision goggles and does not apply to other night or low visual environment enhancement devices (i.e., forward-looking infrared system (FLIR), enhanced vision system (EVS), etc.). Due to the fundamental effect NVGs have on visual perception and the inherent characteristics of NVIS technology, modifications to the aircraft to make it NVIS-compliant should always be considered a major alteration.
(2) The guidance in this MG is one method to show compliance with 14 CFR Part 29 regarding aircraft lighting modification for NVIS compatibility. The applicant should also be familiar with RTCA/DO-268, Concept of Operations: Night Vision Imaging System for Civil Operators, dated 27 March 2001.
NOTE 1: Aircraft that are intended for NVG operations must go through the NVIS certification process, whether modified or produced by the manufacturer. A night VFR approval does not constitute NVIS certification. In addition, some rotorcraft may not be suitable for NVIS certification due to factors such as cockpit obstructions, inability of pilots to move their heads while wearing NVGs, inability of the cockpit to accommodate a pilot wearing a helmet, etc.
NOTE 2: Certification scheduling should account for moon cycles and sky condition (lighting from starlight only, if possible). Type inspection authorization (TIA) flights should be accomplished in no-moon, clear sky conditions to avoid masking possible low illumination, incompatible lighting effects during the NVIS cockpit and NVG interface evaluations.
AC 29-2C, Chg 2 4/25/06 Page MG 16 - 2 NOTE 3: Installation of a NVIS lighting system does not authorize the operator to use NVGs. The operator must coordinate with the FAA or Civil Aviation Authority oversight office to obtain operational authorization.
NOTE 4: Operational requirements for use of NVIS/NVG are found in FAA HBAT
04-02.
b. Revisions
(1) This revision focuses the gui dance on NVIS lighting and NVG and NVIS lighting cockpit compatibility. Information on NVG certification is found in TSO-C164.
Additional NVG and helmet interface information is also included in this MG.
(2) NVIS/cockpit evaluation guides/checklists can be found at http://www.faa.gov/aircraft/air_cert/design_approvals/rotorcraft/nvis/.
c. Definitions
(1) Cultural Lighting: Li ght emitted from cities, towns, residences, street lights, or other artificial sources. Cultural lighting may help or hinder the pilot’s external view through NVGs depending on intensity, reflection off cloud cover, landing zone topography, etc.
(2) Night Vision Imaging System (NVIS) . Integrates all elements (including the NVG, windshield, lighting system, etc.) required to successfully and safely operate an aircraft with the aid of NVGs.
(3) NVIS Lighting Component is any component intended for use with NVGs that emits or transmits light within the flight deck or other crew compartments, or that is attached to the aircraft exterior, and does not degrade NVG performance.
(4) NVIS Lighting System is an aircraft lighting system that has been modified or designed to incorporate NVIS lighting components. It provides adequate illumination, under day and night conditions, of instruments, displays, and controls for the unaided eye without degrading NVG performance. NVIS lighting systems must meet 14 CFR Part 29 lighting requirements.
(5) NVG Compatible. Aircraft internal and external lighting is NVG compatible if it does not adversely affect the NVG image.
(6) Aided flight is flight using NVGs to aid visual flight.
(7) Unaided flight is flight without NVGs or with the NVGs in a non-operational position.
AC Page MG 16 - 3
(8) Transparencies: Windows, chin bubbles, overhead windows that the crew uses to look outside the aircraft.
d. Procedures
(1) General. One method to show compliance is outlined in this AC and includes evaluation of the NVIS lighting system and cockpit through both day, night ground, night aided, and night unaided flight evaluations.
(2) References:
(i) Regulatory
Section Section
29.1 29.1383
29.21 29.1385
29.141c 29.1387
29.561 29.1389
29.771 29.1391
29.773 29.1393
29.777 29.1395
29.779 29.1397
29.785 29.1399
29.803 29.1401
29.811 29.1413
29.812 29.1501
29.853 29.1523
29.1301 29.1525
29.1303 29.1529
29.1305 29.1541
29.1307 29.1543
29.1309 29.1545
29.1321 29.1549
29.1322 29.1553
29.1331a(3) 29.1555
29.1333 29.1557
29.1351 29.1561
29.1355 29.1581
29.1357 29.1583
29.1359 29.1585
29.1381
AC 29-2C, Chg 2 4/25/06 Page MG 16 - 4
(iii) Other References
Ref Document Title TSO-C4C Bank and Pitch Indicators TSO-C8D Vertical Speed Indicators TSO-C67 Radar Altimeters TSO-C164 Night Vision Goggles AC 25-11 Electronic Displays AC 20-152 Design Assurance Guidance for Airborne Electronic Hardware AC 20-74 External Lighting AC 20-88 Instrument Markings and Limits RTCA DO-268 Concept of Operations, Night Vision Imaging Systems for Civil Operators RTCA DO-275 Minimum Operational Performance Standards for the Integrated Night Vision Imaging System Equipment SAE ARP 4754 Certification Considerations for Highly-Integrated or Complex Aircraft Systems SAE ARP 4761 Guidelines and Methods for Conducting the System Safety Assessment Process on Civil Airborne Systems and Equipment
(3) Certification Basis. The NVIS design must comply with the aircraft certification basis. The use of NVIS is a new type of operation, which requires special considerations. The same aircraft design can be certified for other types of operation, such as Category A, Day visual flight rules (VFR), Night VFR, and instrument flight rules (IFR). The certification basis (reference 14 CFR § 29.1) of the aircraft must be appropriate for all certified types of operation, and may require adoption of later amendment levels of 14 CFR Part 27 or special conditions.
NOTE 5: NVIS operations in conjunction with Category A takeoffs and landings are beyond the scope of this section. Other special flying operations, such as agricultural or external loads, will require special considerations, and coordination with an operational specialist may be required to determine the scope of the certification evaluation.
(4) Additional NV IS equipment and components.
(i) Due to the limitations of NVGs , some additions to the crew station in the form of instruments or controls might be necessary to accomplish a successful NVG certification. Some examples of additional instruments (added to a night VFR only certified aircraft) are attitude indicator(s), vertical speed indicator(s), radar (radio) altimeter(s), generator or alternator of adequate capacity, and two-way radio communication equipment. For further detail on the need for these instruments, refer to RTCA DO-268.
( ii) NVG compatibility with the NVIS lighting and cockpit configuration will be assessed using NVGs meeting TSO-C164 requirements. NVG compatibility will also
AC Page MG 16 - 5 be assessed using the type and model of NVG that the operator will use in their NVG operations.
(5) Installation Design .
(i) Mechanical Installation. Airc raft modifications should be made to (1) ensure compliance with the airworthiness regulations and (2) comply with the equipment manufacturer’s recommendations. The designer should observe good engineering practices, in specifying material type, wire routing, fastener type, light switches and controls, edge distance, and ergonomic considerations (§§ 29.777,
29.1307, 29.785, and 29.1359).
(ii) Arrangement and Visibility. T he mounting position of all instruments, switches, position labels, and controls should be visible to the pilot during unaided and aided flight and in all cockpit lighting conditions (day and night). Technical Standard Order (TSO) approval does not assure instruments will be acceptable in a particular cockpit installation or for all lighting conditions. The instruments, switches, and placards should be free from reflections. Warning, caution, and advisory annunciation devices should be conspicuous, NVG compatible, and clearly visible to the pilot (day and night).
Gauge and instrument markings should be clearly seen and the colors of the markings maintained. (See §§ 29.771, 29.773, 29.777, 29.811, 29.853, 29.1303, 29.1321,
29.1322, 29.1381, 29.1555, 29.1557 and 29.1559, RTCA DO-275, and Advisory Circular 20-69.)
(iii) Interior Lighting. Internal lighting systems should not adversely affect the performance of the NVIS. Instrument markings and illuminated instrument markings must comply with § 29.1381 and AC 20-88 and should be demonstrated during aided and unaided operations. Colors should be uniform (different shades of red/amber/green are not acceptable) to avoid confusion. For example, different shades of red (NVIS red and aviation red) within the cockpit have not been accepted. Additionally, NVIS red with orange hue has not been accepted in cockpits with amber caution lights/indicators.
(iv) Exterior Lighti ng. External lighting systems should not adversely affect the performance of the NVIS. Compliance with §§ 29.1383 to 29.1401 and AC 20-74 should be demonstrated. External lighting should be evaluated under probable terrain, illumination, and environmental operating conditions (e.g., rain, snow, fog, dust, etc.). Consider modifying position lights with NVIS compatible lights. There are NVIS-compatible position lights available. Non-NVIS compatible position lights can cause unacceptable shadowing and interference with NVG performance in dark areas where there is little or no cultural lighting.
(v) Reflections and Glare. There should be no glare or reflections that interfere with unaided or NVG aided operations. Sources of reflection and glare could include aircraft interior surfaces (floor, panels, etc.), equipment, seats, etc. Compliance with §§ 29.771, 29.773, and 29.1381 should be demonstrated in the ground and flight test.
AC 29-2C, Chg 2 4/25/06 Page MG 16 - 6
(vi) Controls.
(A) NVIS lighting controls shoul d be readily identifiable and accessible.
(B) NVIS control design should mi nimize the probability of the inadvertent selection of incompatible light sources in the cockpit. The detrimental effects of incompatible light sources on the external view through the NVG should be minimized if there is a capability to select an NVIS incompatible light source
(C) NVIS Lighting should have a dimming range consistent with aided and unaided operations. Compliance with §§ 29.777, 29.1301, 29.1309, and 29.1381 should be demonstrated.
(D) Some installations incorporate master light switches to control special busses for the lighting systems. If this capability is provided, it should be evaluated to assure failure modes are not introduced that will result in the illumination of incompatible light sources or loss of all required lighting (§§ 29.1307 and 29.1367).
(E) Compliance with §§ 29.777, 29.1301, 29.1309, and 29.1381 should be demonstrated.
(vii) NVIS Power Sources. Determi ne whether the electrical power source capacity is adequate for the system installation under all foreseeable operating conditions including engine failure. Duplicate systems should be powered from separate busses and, in some cases, from independent sources if required by the airworthiness regulations (§§ 29.1309 or 29.1351).
(viii) Cooling Test. Systems and components that are added or modified
(e.g., addition of filters to light sources) for NVIS operations should be tested in accordance with AC 29.1309 (cooling test procedures) for continued acceptability. This is important because the installation of a filter could result in an appreciable increase in a system or component temperature. This issue would be most critical for a system that remained brightly illuminated during daylight operations.
(6) NVIS Cockpit and NVG Integration:
(i) Accessibility and Workload.
(A) The NVIS configuration should not compromise the ability to perform all necessary duties. Scanning and control accessibility should be considered. The applicant should determine the representative flight profiles and environmental conditions under which the workload should be evaluated. The purpose of this evaluation is to ensure that the workload associated with NVIS operations does not compromise safety of flight. Compliance with §§ 29.771, 29.773, 29.777, and 29.1523 should be demonstrated.
AC Page MG 16 - 7
(B) The rotorcraft characteristics need to be such that the workload is acceptable and the required instruments are within the pilot’s primary scan when using NVGs. The design of the NVIS should consider flight into inadvertent instrument meteorological conditions (IMC) and unusual attitude recovery. Inadvertent IMC is defined for these purposes as loss of visual references, such as actual IMC, brownout, whiteout, etc. It is important to assess the transition from aided flight to instrument flight. Therefore, the applicant should plan this evaluation during all requested phases of flight (such as cruise flight or takeoff and landing, if requested).
(C) Assess the NVIS lighting fo r readability, uniformity, balance, light leakage, reflections, and degradation of NVG performance. An NVIS and NVG Cockpit integration checklist is provided at:
http://www.faa.gov/aircraft/air_cert/design_approvals/rotorcraft/nvis/.
Also, RTCA DO-275, Section 4.0, provides an expanded explanation.
(D) NVGs shall be TSO-C164 compliant. A cockpit evaluation should be accomplished with NVGs that meet the minimum TSO-C164 standards as well as NVGs the applicant intends to use in operations (if they exceed TSO-C164 standards). In no case will NVG’s that do not meet or exceed TSO-C164 standards be approved for use in the cockpit.
(ii) Controls
(A) Accessibility of NVIS Lighting System Controls. Pilots should be able to readily identify, access, and operate, with one hand, the NVIS lighting controls inflight from their normal seated position.
(B) Inadvertent Actuation of Cont rols. Appropriate protection should be provided to minimize the possibility of the inadvertent actuation of NVG controls and non-NVIS light sources.
(iii) Visibility.
(A) Windscreen. The wind screen and transparencies should not decrease NVG light sensitivities more than 12% or one resolution element on a tri-bar chart. If the aircraft has a windscreen anti-ice function, the windscreen should be evaluated with anti-ice on and off to assess effect on the NVGs. Operation of windscreen anti-ice should follow manufacturer’s procedures and limitations.
(B) Glare and reflectivity. Gl are and reflectivity can be produced from internal and external light sources.
( 1 ) Internal light sources:
AC 29-2C, Chg 2 4/25/06 Page MG 16 - 8
( i ) Permissable reflections should be no worse than the original unaided lighting. However, NVGs may pick up more reflections than seen with unaided vision.
Those reflections should be blocked to ensure they do not interfere with the pilot’s ability to see outside the aircraft while wearing NVGs.
(ii) Glare can result from poor ly filtered or fitted lighting. Additionally, if there are non-NVIS compatible light sources in other areas of the aircraft, they can cause interference. Assess light sources causing glare and develop mitigating solutions to keep them from interfering with the pilots view through NVGs.
( 2 ) External Light Sources:
( i ) Usually, external light glare or refl ectivity is assessed during the night flight. Evaluating the effects of glare and reflections that interfere with NVGs from external aircraft lighting is very important when operating in remote, dark areas. There are NVIS compatible external aircraft lights available. Consider using them if operations are conducted in very dark areas where there is little to no ambient cultural lighting.
Methods to reduce glare or reflections caused by external aircraft lighting depend on where the light enters the cockpit and from what aircraft structure reflects the light. For example, light that reflects off of skids or wire cutters can be mitigated by use of nonreflective paint on the reflecting surfaces. Additionally, chin-bubble mats have been used to block light and reflections through the chin-bubble.
NOTE 6: If chin bubble mats are used, pay particular attention to:
(1) restrictions in the pilot's field-of -view through the chin bubble, particularly during take-off, landing, and hover operations, and
(2) the potential for the mat to be mov ed or dislodged during flight, thereby causing interference with the tail rotor pedals.
Use of chin bubbles mats should be evaluated during both ground and flight test.
NOTE 7: Some non-compatible lighting such as landing or taxi lights, search lights, etc.; can aid as well as hinder NVG operations. Their effects on NVGs in the specific helicopter flown should be assessed and recorded during integration evaluations.
(ii) Evaluation of external light sources t hat pilots could use to assist them with NVG flight should be evaluated for their effect on NVG performance. If the aircraft has landing lights, searchlights, or other lights that the pilots use, they should be assessed to evaluate their effect on the aided vision range. For instance, if the pilot uses a searchlight or landing lights to help assess landing area or while landing with NVGs, then the light’s effect on the range of vision within and beyond the light boundaries should be evaluated and documented.